Jump to content
sd181612

Player arguing play

Recommended Posts

Here is a situation that I know you all will be able to help me with: 1 out runner on second. Batter hits a ball towards first base foul territory, ball is caught. Runner from second takes off without tagging, wild throw towards the SS covering 2B. Runner goes back, slides, base flies a few feet; runner is safe. There's this player on the defense who had already expressed discontent on a bang-bang play; he argues on this one as well. Question is, should I have ejected him. This is triple-AAA little league, about 9-11 years old.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This depends (imo) on how he argued. If he said "I thought I got him!" on both, letting it slide.

 

If he says stuff like "cmon man, you're killin me smalls!" Well ,that's different.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Depends on how responsive they are to you at that age. If you can turn it into a teaching moment about not arguing with umpires I'm sure your fellow umpires will thank you down the road. I don't see much here for an ejection especially since the kid is somewhere between 9 and 11. Unless he argues vociferous or continuously I'm probably going to ignore it. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A kid that young arguing every time he doesn't like a call? He has a lesson to be learned, and you are the teacher. How you do it is for you to decide, in the context of the game: although an EJ might be too harsh, "son, that's all from you I going to take today" or "coach, if you want to keep that kid in the game, get him under control" or some such. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That age is instructional, but I wouldn't rely on a daddy coach to instruct (if he does, I'd stay out of the way).

"Right or wrong, never argue with an umpire. Your coach can ask about a call if he wants to, but you'll play your best if you keep your head in the game."

Now, if he drops an F-bomb on me, that's another story....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, maven said:

That age is instructional, but I wouldn't rely on a daddy coach to instruct (if he does, I'd stay out of the way).

"Right or wrong, never argue with an umpire. Your coach can ask about a call if he wants to, but you'll play your best if you keep your head in the game."

Now, if he drops an F-bomb on me, that's another story....

Tanner Boyle syndrome...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At this age, you really don't want to eject. I would approach the coach and let him know that he needs to start coaching. Then give him a choice/warning, if it happens again, he's got 15 seconds to sit his player, or you'll sit him and he won't be playing the next game as well. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Aside from a child arguing... what was he arguing about? Caught ball and a bad throw... was the slide back into first bang/bang? Per LL rules the base detaching is expected and the offense can either go to where the bag should be or where it currently lies and still be safe.

So why was he complaining? As for a 8-9 year old whining that is something to take up with the coach quickly or little Johnny will be seeing the remainder of the game from the dug-out. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Mudisfun said:

Aside from a child arguing... what was he arguing about? Caught ball and a bad throw... was the slide back into first bang/bang? Per LL rules the base detaching is expected and the offense can either go to where the bag should be or where it currently lies and still be safe.

So why was he complaining? As for a 8-9 year old whining that is something to take up with the coach quickly or little Johnny will be seeing the remainder of the game from the dug-out. 

He was complaining about a banger at first, and then about the detached base issue.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably a little young to use the "go read the rule book" line...

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If it's a nasty arguing ... regardless of whether you eject or not, go to the coach.  Every parent on that team will report child endangerment if you so much as raise your voice at him.  I know.  It even happens in High School.

 

If it's a question ... keep your distance ... smile ... and answer him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/29/2016 at 9:15 PM, sd181612 said:

Here is a situation that I know you all will be able to help me with: 1 out runner on second. Batter hits a ball towards first base foul territory, ball is caught. Runner from second takes off without tagging, wild throw towards the SS covering 2B. Runner goes back, slides, base flies a few feet; runner is safe. There's this player on the defense who had already expressed discontent on a bang-bang play; he argues on this one as well. Question is, should I have ejected him. This is triple-AAA little league, about 9-11 years old.

I had a SS doing that in a u10 tournament I was helping out with. After a walk with the bases clean, as I'm running from A to B I could see him throwing his arms up and loudly questioning how that pitch was also a ball. I told him very sternly that if he wants to continue to play baseball that day that he needed to find a way to get his attitude in check.

Didnt hear from him the rest of the game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/29/2016 at 11:15 PM, sd181612 said:

Question is, should I have ejected him. This is triple-AAA little league, about 9-11 years old.

No. 

Talk to the coach first. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/30/2016 at 10:55 AM, LRZ said:

coach, if you want to keep that kid in the game, get him under control" or some such. 

THIS

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Thomas Mullaney said:

After a walk with the bases clean, as I'm running from A to B I could see him throwing his arms up and loudly questioning how that pitch was also a ball.

Pujols was ejected for precisely the same thing 6-7 years ago before he even left the box. He ran all the way to 1B when his 1BC had to break the news.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And the topic is Player Arguing...let's get back to that or move on. Nothing to see here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talk to the coach.  My usual routine with kids this age is something like this:  "Skip, this kid's pushing the limit with his arguments/comments/attitude.  Why don't you put him on the bench for a couple innings (and let him know why) so I don't have to eject him."  Sometimes coaches will comply, others won't.  Those who don't get this next statement "Skip, you're the adult in the room.  I consider you responsible for the behavior of your players and coaches.  If I have any further problem with him, I'm going to have a problem with you as well."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By catoblue
      OK, coaches hat on my head for this one...

      Last night, LL majors game: For starters, I had an idea on what we had for umpires right from the plate conference: BIG deer-in-the-headlights look when they mentioned DBT and I said "2 from the field and 1 from the mound, right?":jerkit:

      Bottom of 1st 0 outs, R1 (This kid is about 5'10" and 200 lbs).
      Ground ball to F5, who scoops it and throws to F4. R1 slides into 2B with cleats 3 feet in the air, hits F4 in the glove arm with cleats and ball gets dropped - F4's arm is bleeding from cleat marks. By the way, this was clearly intentional to break up the DP.

      Now, were I calling this game, R1 is gone. The bozos that were calling the game, however, did nothing about it until at the half inning I called BU aside and said I'm concerned that he didn't at minimum, issue a warning - which he promptly did.

      Anyone else here that would have punched this kid's ticket for going in to 2B with the cleats into F4's arm? (remember this is LL!)

      Next play, grounder to 4'6" F6, the un-ejected (big-boy) R2, runs straight line towards 3B, keeping F6 from fielding the ball - here I have INT since F6 had to to choose: stop or get splattered! No call from the umpires, but it gets even better...


      Ball gets past F6, F7 is charging and bare hands the ball to throw to F5, who is standing just behind 3B, Before the throw gets there, R2 shoves F5 out of the way and heads home to score!!!!! Again no calls by the crew.

      Absolutely clueless!!! Oh yeah, the BU would line up right behind F1 (infield) with runners on - on a 60' diamond!?!

      My only thought by the end of the game was "...and they PAY for umpires like this?!" We play in a multi-community league, where ours is the only one that doesn't pay - I'll take our volunteers over these clowns any day!
    • By Mr_Blue
      Felt like I had to make an account to ask about this situation. Have you ever been asked "Did he go?" while you were standing behind the pitcher? Happened to me.
       
      0-2 count. Batter appeared to obviously offer at a close pitch, his hands looked well in front of the plate and bat also looked like it had went around with his wrists breaking enough that I could say I'm 100 percent sure it was a swing. I'm sure everyone watching the game knew it was a swing, including everyone in the stands and definitely the 3rd base coach who was ejected for arguing after what happened. It looked like one of those calls that are pretty easy to make from where I was standing.
       
      Anyways, I'm waiting on the PU to make the call and he hesitates then points at me and asks if he went. I was so shocked that he was asking me for help on this one that I made a mistake here. I should have just made the call but I looked back at him and just said "It's your call." Now I guess everyone thinks that neither one of us know even though it looked like a pretty obvious call. Now the dugouts are starting to chirp a bit so I call time and we talk for a minute. I tell him what I saw and that it was definitely a swing. I wouldn't call it a swing if it was close but this one wasn't close. We call the kid out. One of the coaches comes to argue, even though I'm sure he had to know we got the call right he wasn't happy with how we made it. He keeps arguing and is warned not to continue and he goes to the dugout. He stops for maybe 10 seconds but is tossed for something he says when he gets to the dugout. Game went okay after that. Then the PU punched out the next batter on the first pitch because I guess he forgot the count wasn't 0-2 anymore. So that didn't help us look any better.
       
      Overall the game went okay after that. We handled the coach okay. Ejection went probably as well as it could have. After the game the PU wanted to switch crews so I worked with a different guy. Then he texted me after the game "Thanks for screwing me today ***hole I pray I never work with you again. This is high school varsity ball not the little bull**** you usually do." Which I thought was a little ridiculous, but oh well. I can't help but feel bad for being caught off guard on that play.
    • By SeanColorado
      12u fastpitch playoff game.  I'm BU.
      Top of first, runners on 1st and 2nd, 2 outs, 2 strikes.  Shortstop says to catcher "if she goes get her at third".  3rd base coach (also HC) says to F6 "yeah you just go ahead and try to throw her out" before pitch is thrown in a taunting tone.  I'm in C and here it clearly.  Strike 3 inning over.  As he's starts walking back to 1st base dugout I tell coach, in a quiet but direct tone, not to speak to the other team's players.  He starts to respond and I say "coach, that's enough, we're not discussing this".
      Bottom of 3, PU calls time and walks out to P for a 10 second conversation.  I'm in A and can't make out what's being said.  HTHC comes out of dugout as PU is walking back to plate asking what that was about.  He was instructing pitcher to not lick fingers and then grab the ball for a pitch.  HTHC as he's walking back yells for the entire neighborhood to hear "oh we're playing by those rules today!".  PU issues a warning telling him to knock it off and "this is your warning".
      Start of bottom of 4, I'm in shallow right and HT is slowly taking the field as HTHC gives them individual fielding positions.  One of the girls is bawling profusely, tears streaming down her face.  About what, I don't know...  PU tells HTHC she can't take the field in that condition for her own safety.  He gets in PU face yelling "you can't tell me who I can play and can't".  PU tosses HC.  PU says "you have 5 minutes to leave the field".  Ugh, I know.  HTHC says "if I have 5 minutes I'm going to make them count".  I play rodeo clown telling him he has to leave and explain to AC he is now the HC.  
      HTHC leaves, but then in the 5th inning comes back and is back in sight.  Technically he is off the property, but the fields are in a basin and he's basically on the street curb.  Equivalent to the upper deck area above his team's dugout.  I didn't notice at first, but I'm in C and VTHC (3BC at the time) points out that he's back and asks for a forfeit.  I said no, we're not calling a forfeit, pause the game, tell new HTHC that he needs to be out of sight and sound.  He argues that he is off the property line.  Again coach, he needs to be gone now.  He calls him and finally makes his way to parking lot.  HT wins 8-7.  
      Feedback welcomed as I've learned so much from this forum.  My real question in all of this is "does PU have the authority within the rules to prevent a player from taking the field for crying?".  In PU's view, she couldn't see creating a safety issue.  Does the warning/conversation in top of 1 seem appropriate?
    • By Umpire in Chief
      http://m.mlb.com/video/v1293296683/texsea-scott-servais-ejected-arguing-a-fair-ball/?query=servais
      This is one of the games I watched this weekend. 
      As an umpire, I knew what was happening. Bucknor properly waited for the play to play itself out, then signaled time as there was some question whether it hit the batter in the box. So, overall Bucknor did the right things here and the ejection was deserved. Now I did not see or notice any communication between Bucknor & Carlson about potentially being hit in the box, but lack of any communication is essentially the same as saying he was not hit. 
      However, I was with my father in law who gets easily fired up about sports and reviles all officials in all sports. He had a minor conniption about this which was fueled on by the announcers (we had a different feed than these announcers).
      Now in my amateur, Monday morning quarterback view here's what he could have possibly have done better (for educational purposes only not to criticize, condemn or otherwise put down any umpire).
      Point the ball fair. -- IMO this simple act could have quite possibly prevented everything. And it wouldn't have made any difference in terms of a potential batter hit in the box situation. Additionally, because it it was so close, emphatically point it fair. Verbalize calling time -- That seemed to be Servais's argument, 'You called foul' and you can read Bucknors lips, 'No, I called time' The other thing that did not go well for Bucknor were the optics of the situation. The first baseman seems to look back at him and ask if it was fair. Then Bucknor doesn't come up with the out call (not shown on this clip) until immediately after the first baseman says something else to him. This is just one of those tough darn-if-you-do, darn-if-you-don't situations, but it just looks bad. 
       
    • By Umpire in Chief
      Legit Ejection... Hor$e$h+ Announcers.
      When Cabrera turns to say something to Angel Hernandez it definitely wasn't "You're the best" 
       
×
×
  • Create New...