Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 3550 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted
Just now, Thunderheads said:

F

Thats what I figured. But didn't think NCAA would have such an obvious question on the test.

Thought it might be a trick question.

 

Posted

ok, so to stir the pot a little, what is the citation?  I'm just playing devils advocate in a sense that ...........when a ball is stuck in the pitchers webbing, then he removes the glove and throws it to F3 for an out.......how is this play different?  The ball was in the glove and never touched the ground.:stir

Posted
5 minutes ago, Aging_Arbiter said:

ok, so to stir the pot a little, what is the citation?  I'm just playing devils advocate in a sense that ...........when a ball is stuck in the pitchers webbing, then he removes the glove and throws it to F3 for an out.......how is this play different?  The ball was in the glove and never touched the ground.:stir

Because of the redefinition of voluntary release, which now includes two, and only two, situations. This is not one of them.

Posted

Agreed this is not a catch. But I am not totally sure what U2 could have really done different besides maybe changing his "angle of attack" or maybe getting out there further?

Looks like he was shielded off by the injured player. Also it is human nature to check on the injured player. Even during the play. So when he did that, that is when F9 pulls the ball out of the loose glove.

Dollars to donuts, he doesn't miss this call if F8 isn't a piled heap in front of him.

Posted

I agree the answer they want is "F" and that this is NOT a catch.

 

But the question is poor, because it's True that this is the umpire's judgment (no matter how poor that judgment is).

  • Like 2
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted
3 hours ago, ElkOil said:

It's a catch because the umpire said it was. Since it's his judgement, it is what he says it is.

Nope... not at all. He was still wrong. That is why it was false.

Wonder when they will get the videos into rotation on the page.

Posted

Here's the rule in its entirety. I made bold the most relevant part.

 

"Rule 2-16 Catch: The act of a fielder in getting secure possession in the hand or glove of a ball in flight and firmly holding it, providing the fielder does not use the cap, protector, pocket or any other part of the uniform in getting possession.

In establishing the validity of the catch, the fielder shall demonstrate complete control of the ball and that the release of the ball is voluntary and intentional.

Only two circumstances may be interpreted as creating a voluntary and intentional release.

1) When the momentum of the catch is complete; i.e., the fielder has reversed his direction and is running the ball back toward the infield or;

2) When the fielder is reaching for the ball to make a throw.

a. It is not a catch if, simultaneously with or immediately after contact with the ball, the fielder collides with a player or fence or falls down and, as a result, drops the ball.

Art. b.

It is not a catch if a fielder touches a fly ball that then hits a member of the offensive team or an umpire and then is caught by that fielder or another defensive player.

Art. c.

If the fielder has made the catch and drops the ball while in the act of making a throw (i.e., reaching for the ball in the glove) after the catch, the ball shall be judged to have been caught.

Art. d.

It is not a legal catch if either foot is touching dead-ball territory when the catch is made (see 6-1-d-4)."

 

As the rule states, there are only 2 circumstances creating "voluntary release," neither of which occurred in this play, so if an umpire were to make the statement in the question, he would be incorrect (as shown by the correct answer being "False.")

Posted

I understand the voluntary release component of the question/discussion and why the answer is "false" because voluntary release isn't a factor here, but seeing that the ball was still in the glove and never touched the ground, is it a "no catch" because his glove was no longer on his person?  What if he had gone back and picked up his own glove, would it still be a "no catch"?

Posted
1 hour ago, beerguy55 said:

I understand the voluntary release component of the question/discussion and why the answer is "false" because voluntary release isn't a factor here, but seeing that the ball was still in the glove and never touched the ground, is it a "no catch" because his glove was no longer on his person?  What if he had gone back and picked up his own glove, would it still be a "no catch"?

I believe you can think of it as "once the glove fell off, the ball had been released, but not voluntarily."

Posted
6 hours ago, jms1425 said:

 

Only two circumstances may be interpreted as creating a voluntary and intentional release.

1) When the momentum of the catch is complete;

 

Well, I'd say his momentum came to a pretty quick stop. :)

Posted
19 hours ago, BT_Blue said:

Nope... not at all. He was still wrong. That is why it was false.

Wonder when they will get the videos into rotation on the page.

That being the case, they should remove the judgement component of the test question.

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, ElkOil said:

That being the case, they should remove the judgement component of the test question.

At the NCAA meetings this year, a lot of time was spent stressing that umpires are to use the phrase "in my judgement".

  • Like 1
Posted
8 hours ago, beerguy55 said:

I understand the voluntary release component of the question/discussion and why the answer is "false" because voluntary release isn't a factor here, but seeing that the ball was still in the glove and never touched the ground, is it a "no catch" because his glove was no longer on his person?  What if he had gone back and picked up his own glove, would it still be a "no catch"?

Correct - no catch. In that case he would still not meet this portion of the requirement for a catch: "secure possession in the hand or glove of a ball in flight and firmly holding it"

Posted
29 minutes ago, Forest Ump said:

At the NCAA meetings this year, a lot of time was spent stressing that umpires are to use the phrase "in my judgement".

Then in THAT case, I'll stand on my initial statement that it was a catch because the ump said it was. It can't be had both ways that we leave a call up to an ump's judgement, then says he's wrong for expressing it. What I'll agree on is that perhaps the ump's rule interpretation was incorrect if he didn't understand the definition of a catch.

  • Like 1
Posted
10 hours ago, ElkOil said:

Then in THAT case, I'll stand on my initial statement that it was a catch because the ump said it was. It can't be had both ways that we leave a call up to an ump's judgement, then says he's wrong for expressing it. What I'll agree on is that perhaps the ump's rule interpretation was incorrect if he didn't understand the definition of a catch.

exactly.  Even if there only two specific instances for voluntary release they are both still subject to the judgment of the umpire to whether they're achieved.

I once saw a ball land three FEET foul and have an umpire rule it a fair ball.  He knew the rules for fair/foul.  All the players and coaches knew the rules.  In his judgment, it landed fair, and only his judgment matters.  That is just how he saw it, for whatever reason.  In the end, the only thing that makes a ball foul is the umpire saying so. And the only thing that determines a catch is made is the umpire saying so.   It's possible this umpire knows full well the two conditions of voluntary release and in his mind (judgment) he saw either momentum complete, or the fielder reach into his glove.

I've seen strange calls by umpires over the years.  Strikes at the eyes.  Balls at the belt.  Fair and foul balls 18+ inches on the wrong side of the line.  Runners called out when the closest fielder was five feet from the bag.  Safe called on runners who still haven't touched the base.  All based on judgment - not a misunderstanding of the rules. Those umpires saw something that nobody else on the field saw.  And once the umpire says that magic word, you have very little avenue to demonstrate that he is misapplying his judgment against an incorrect rule interpretation.

Unless we're now suggesting that once an umpire says "in my judgment that was a foul ball" the coach then ask the umpire to demonstrate he understands all the definitions behind it.  Because I would suspect that the NCAA is encouraging the use of this statement to reinforce the notion that it's a judgment call, not a technical call, and quash any reason to argue.

This umpire saw voluntary release.  Without discussing with the umpire in further detail, we can't be sure if he misapplied the rule, or simply saw something nobody else saw.

So to answer the original question - yes, it's a trick question...or, at best, a poorly worded one. 

False - it's not a catch, the umpire's judgment was incorrect 

True - the umpire ruled it a catch, so it's a catch

True - the umpire did indeed say those words, verbatim

False - the umpire misapplied the rule he cited

Posted

Honestly guys, I bet if you asked this umpire in question what his thought process was, it was probably "Holy crap..... Is that still a catch?...... Yeah I don't see why not."

  • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...