alex7

Is it the slimmer look, a comfort aspect, both?

Have you tried Hokas? Wow comfort. Cost a little more but you feel the difference

There are 3 versions. You're recommending the 3.0 or 2.0?

I can confirm they DID take the preseason video info into consideration for the test. Avoiding collisions takes precedence, even if they didn't fit that caveat into the rule book

On the double base question, the preseason video stated a runner could use the white base if a throw pulled the first baseman towards the file side Did the test makers have time to include that? Rule book only gives you dropped third strike as the caveat for BR using the white bag on an initial play

https://a.co/d/03PHKAb I bought these Hoka Clifton 8s and enjoyed them on a turf field. Soles did not have that huge chunky look, while the comfort was wow.

Hard to go wrong with Hoka shoes as well for comfort on the bases.

I have one for you. Missing the big shoulder pads (foam part) and side pads. PM me the shipping zip code so I can estimate the shipping cost.

Purchased bag from @The Short Umpire Timely communication, quick shipping 👍

One of those possibly poorly written questions asks when a pitcher must be removed. It lists among the options when a coach illegally makes a visit after having used up all of his team's allotment, or after the coach's three visits. The answer it wants is "all of the above." However, by rule, you would NOT change the P at that point, since that's what the coach wanted to do, illegally. Obviously we wait until the AB is finished, then the P is removed. But he must pitch to the batter first. So it seemed like a possibly poorly written question, imo.

Ask a nerd! Decently written test, would say only 2-3 were written ambiguously or possibly incorrect unless you understand what the writer was thinking.

To expand on SH0101's great point - most of the 2-man guys I work with (HS and NCAA) focus on umpiring the most likely play. On that OP scenario, as PU I head to the 1st base side of the mound, where I can: Still have a good look at the slide legality at 2b Help with pulled foot at 1st Help with swipe tag at 1st Help with overthrow rulings so my BU can get inside ahead of the runner All those things are going to happen I'd say 1000 times more often than R1 beating the throw at 2nd, AND going to 3rd, AND my BU not being able to make the call at 1st, take a few steps towards the mound, and angle-over-distance the call at 3rd.

I wear size 10.5 shoes. I have size 11 New Balances and Rebook Zigs that are comfortable on the bases, both with the small nubs on the bottom. Fit my 10.5 feet perfectly. What's your ZIP code and I'll check the shipping cost if you're interested.

Shawn, an alternative to the ebags, if you don't find one in your price range, is an Amazon dual-deck 32-35 inch travel bag. I went from a traditional umpire bag to one of those a few years ago, and there's been no difference, except the price was about 60% of the traditional umpire bags. They come with your typical side pockets, top pocket, telescope handle, etc, along with the dual decks for separating gear from other stuff.

Like others have said, context matters and as you develop, you'll gain more confidence into reading those situations and making your decision. That said, until then, if you NEED something along the lines of hard-and-fast truths 1) if it's a player or assistant coach 2) if it's loud enough for the fans to hear it it's a good "automatic" threshold to start with. Again, not 100%, but if you need SOMETHING to start with as you develop your feel for situations. If it's a HC, I might go with an immediate and loud warning. If it's personal, then we're back to automatic.