Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4241 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

22 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted

Runners on first and second. Ground ball to 3B. 3B steps on third and throws the ball out of play towards first. What bases are awarded?

 

Two bases from their physical position at the time of the throw.  (The step on 3B was the first play by an infielder)

  • 0
Posted

Agreed with Rich. As a practical matter, TOP and TOT will almost always be the same in this play.

I'm curious is someone called it differently in the OP's game

I awarded 2nd and 3rd and was 99% sure but the coach argued that they should've been awarded 3rd and home due to it being the 2nd play. The ball went out through an opening underneath the fence and sort of dribbled out and the runner would've scored easily. When I sent them back, everyone went ape SH*#. Glad that I got it right. There was a big crowd and it was a big district game.
  • 0
Posted

 

Agreed with Rich. As a practical matter, TOP and TOT will almost always be the same in this play.

I'm curious is someone called it differently in the OP's game

I awarded 2nd and 3rd and was 99% sure but the coach argued that they should've been awarded 3rd and home due to it being the 2nd play. The ball went out through an opening underneath the fence and sort of dribbled out and the runner would've scored easily. When I sent them back, everyone went ape SH*#. Glad that I got it right. There was a big crowd and it was a big district game.

 

 

Did you ask why he thought it should be 3rd and HP? They get an extra base for it being the 2nd play?

 

"Coach, you're right that it being the 2nd play makes a difference [start with a win for coach], but I had R1 between 1B and 2B at the TOT, so he gets 3B, and the BR 2B."

  • Like 3
  • 0
Posted

That's @maven. Always looking for the teachable moment.

Tough to do and not get into a conversation or a argument if they vehemently disagree with you but definitely a great way to handle it if you have the mental and verbal agility to do it properly and quickly.

  • Like 1
  • 0
Posted

 

Agreed with Rich. As a practical matter, TOP and TOT will almost always be the same in this play.

I'm curious is someone called it differently in the OP's game

I awarded 2nd and 3rd and was 99% sure but the coach argued that they should've been awarded 3rd and home due to it being the 2nd play. The ball went out through an opening underneath the fence and sort of dribbled out and the runner would've scored easily. When I sent them back, everyone went ape SH*#. Glad that I got it right. There was a big crowd and it was a big district game.

 

To clarify, BR on second, R1(runner from first) on third? R2(runner from second) scores.

  • 0
Posted

Agreed with Rich. As a practical matter, TOP and TOT will almost always be the same in this play.

I'm curious is someone called it differently in the OP's game

I awarded 2nd and 3rd and was 99% sure but the coach argued that they should've been awarded 3rd and home due to it being the 2nd play. The ball went out through an opening underneath the fence and sort of dribbled out and the runner would've scored easily. When I sent them back, everyone went ape SH*#. Glad that I got it right. There was a big crowd and it was a big district game.

 

Did you ask why he thought it should be 3rd and HP? They get an extra base for it being the 2nd play?

 

"Coach, you're right that it being the 2nd play makes a difference [start with a win for coach], but I had R1 between 1B and 2B at the TOT, so he gets 3B, and the BR 2B."

He was just trying to get a call. I guess since the runner would've scored easily.

  • 0
Posted

Agreed with Rich. As a practical matter, TOP and TOT will almost always be the same in this play.

I'm curious is someone called it differently in the OP's game

I awarded 2nd and 3rd and was 99% sure but the coach argued that they should've been awarded 3rd and home due to it being the 2nd play. The ball went out through an opening underneath the fence and sort of dribbled out and the runner would've scored easily. When I sent them back, everyone went ape SH*#. Glad that I got it right. There was a big crowd and it was a big district game.

To clarify, BR on second, R1(runner from first) on third? R2(runner from second) scores.

R2 out on force play.

  • 0
Posted

My guess is that many / most thought the award is based on the tome the ball went OOP, not TOT.

That's it. ....I find this a common myth....."My runner was past 2nd base when the ball went out of play :blah "

  • Like 1
  • 0
Posted

OFF TOPIC...Runner on 2nd base is in a run down after a pick off attempt. Whose call is it at 3rd?

 

 

Since I work all solo at the HS level.. Mine!

  • 0
Posted

 

OFF TOPIC...Runner on 2nd base is in a run down after a pick off attempt. Whose call is it at 3rd?

 

 

Since I work all solo at the HS level.. Mine!

 

solo in HS?  yikes

1 base on the overthrow!  :wave:

That sounds like a local rule that we used to have in order to keep kids from scoring on bunts.

  • 0
Posted

How about 2 bases from the time of pitch for a first play by an infielder.  And 2 bases from time of throw on any subsequent play made by an infielder (like the original post) and 2 bases from time of throw from the OF.  Yeah... check your rule book and know the situations. 

  • 0
Posted

 

 

1 base on the overthrow!  :wave:

I hope you are kidding.

 

Thought it'd be obvious.  My bad!

 

No problem.  It just confused me to see a response from an umpire I know to be knowledgeable post an incorrect answer.

×
×
  • Create New...