Out at first stands

[Thunderheads]

not enough evidence?

 

http://m.mlb.com/video/topic/63817564/v35148487

[scrounge]

I think Len Kaspar had it right, a classic tie. I thought the throw just barely, barely beat him but certainly not enough to overturn - no matter what the call on the field was.

[JaxRolo]

Out by a mile!

[Thunderheads]

Out by a mile!

         

[MadMax]

There are no ties in baseball!

There is nothing in the rules that explains or exposes a tie. It's either catch / no-catch, fair / foul, safe... or out.

(Fine print: Of course my hometown hero The Commish did not help the cause in the 2001 All-Star Game by declaring a Tie in the midsummer classic. Should have made those boneheaded managers play it out.)

[ALStripes17]

There are no ties in baseball!

There is nothing in the rules that explains or exposes a tie. It's either catch / no-catch, fair / foul, safe... or out.

(Fine print: Of course my hometown hero The Commish did not help the cause in the 2001 All-Star Game by declaring a Tie in the midsummer classic. Should have made those boneheaded managers play it out.)

Cue @RichIves :D

[Jimurray]

In this one,http://umpire-empire.com/index.php/topic/59294-safe-at-first-replay/, the PU actually appears to say "it's a tie" to his partner while on the headphones. Call stood as safe.

Tie goes to the umpire.

[BigSimonia]

There are no ties in baseball!

There is nothing in the rules that explains or exposes a tie. It's either catch / no-catch, fair / foul, safe... or out.

(Fine print: Of course my hometown hero The Commish did not help the cause in the 2001 All-Star Game by declaring a Tie in the midsummer classic. Should have made those boneheaded managers play it out.)

6.05(j)

 

Problem is there are 3 possible situations but only 2 possible results

[Lindsay]

Chris Guccione is the only MLB Umpire with a 100% affirmation rate for multiple replay reviews (Guccione: 10/10, Hirschbeck: 1/1).

[BillKen]

13-4...OUT...Go Home!  See you tomorrow!