Play at the plate-Review

[Thunderheads]

Call stands ............

Embed feature not available
http://m.mlb.com/video/topic/63817564/v377376983

[stkjock]

surprised that the call stood.  The center field view certainly looks like the tag got the top of the foot before it was on the plate.

[Thunderheads]

surprised that the call stood.  The center field view certainly looks like the tag got the top of the foot before it was on the plate.

agree.  I'm seeing a shoelace move as the mitt crosses the top of his foot

[stkjock]

agree.  I'm seeing a shoelace move as the mitt crosses the top of his foot

Exactly!

[UmpJeff]

Out!

But, on review, there wasn't enough convincing evidence to over rule.

Edited August 17, 2015 by UmpJeff

[Dbellyflop]

Out. 

Question, should CB be 3blx? 

[maven]

Question, should CB be 3blx? 

I'm not telling a pro umpire where to stand, but I should be 3BLX.

[Thunderheads]

I'm not telling a pro umpire where to stand, but I should be 3BLX.

3blx is being taught everywhere .... good for the goose is good for the gander

[ricka56]

Out!

But, on review, there wasn't enough convincing evidence to over rule.

I'd like to know why NY didn't think the CF camera angle wasn't convincing.

[Thunderheads]

I'd like to know why NY didn't think the CF camera angle wasn't convincing.

questioning NY's judgement? This isn't much different than any other video of a play, but this one is ok to discuss?

Here's a still shot.  I agree with your comment.

[Mizzou2016]

@thunderheads you might be going at that a little too much.

@ricka56 was pretty clear that he wasn't going to question judgement when there was not a good camera angle. There wasn't one in the F/F thread. There is one here.

[Thunderheads]

@thunderheads you might be going at that a little too much.

@ricka56 was pretty clear that he wasn't going to question judgement when there was not a good camera angle. There wasn't one in the F/F thread. There is one here.

....maybe ...... 

Edited August 19, 2015 by Thunderheads