Review at First

[Thunderheads]

...NY must have had some better views, because what's seen here sure isn't showing he had the bag .......

 

http://m.mlb.com/video/topic/63817564/v36480961

[noumpere]

The announcers said the play stands -- not enough evidence to overturn.  And, I think that's correct.

[JaxRolo]

Dang!

[bam]

Is that the Arizona broadcast?  Good Lord they're terrible.  First the play by play guy says there's a "glaring need" for replay, then 30 seconds later he says "I hate replay".  The color guy said F3 was "a foot and a half" off the bag, then is trying to analyze toe cleat length. 

 

He sure is right when he says "Some guys are good at their jobs, other guys not so much"

[JaxRolo]

"umpires continually make mistakes"

[grayhawk]

Those plays where the fielder looks off the bag are always closer on replay than they appear in real time.  Good learning tool for our games.  Unless you are 100% sure he's off the bag, he's probably not.

[Thunderheads]

Those plays where the fielder looks off the bag are always closer on replay than they appear in real time.  Good learning tool for our games.  Unless you are 100% sure he's off the bag, he's probably not.

while true ... I can guarantee you no one is calling this safe in any of our games......  my .02