Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4492 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I wouldn't recommend it unless you're working with more than 2 umpires.  A close play turns to sh!t and you've got to get off your knee and now you've lost steps on a runner and will be behind a play.

  • Like 2
Posted

I'll add in it might be ok in 2 man if its the batter runner sliding in at third base because no other play is really possible that would be under your jurisdiction 

Posted

I'll add in it might be ok in 2 man if its the batter runner sliding in at third base because no other play is really possible that would be under your jurisdiction

I work with a few old school minor league guys and they all go to their knee with a play into 3rd.

Posted

Only if you know a good dry cleaner in the area that can get the grass stain out of the polywool afterward. :wave:

Or cover your pants in shrink wrap :)
Posted

I'll add in it might be ok in 2 man if its the batter runner sliding in at third base because no other play is really possible that would be under your jurisdiction 

 

To be set and ready for a play, you have to be on a knee before the play happens. If you are on a knee, then you can't adjust your position if something other than what is expected happens. What advantage is there to be resting on one knee that bending both knees doesn't give you ?

  • Like 1
Posted

 

What advantage is there to be resting on one knee that bending both knees doesn't give you ?

It looks cool.  And, for way too many umpires, that's advantage enough.

Posted

 

 

What advantage is there to be resting on one knee that bending both knees doesn't give you ?

It looks cool.  And, for way too many umpires, that's advantage enough.

 

You'll look cooler if you take a knee for a play with a Nike mask (powder coated of course) with a Japanese throat guard, Fonzie mask pads, Power CP, and Unequal shin guards.  :stir

  • Like 6
Posted

I'll add in it might be ok in 2 man if its the batter runner sliding in at third base because no other play is really possible that would be under your jurisdiction

To be set and ready for a play, you have to be on a knee before the play happens. If you are on a knee, then you can't adjust your position if something other than what is expected happens. What advantage is there to be resting on one knee that bending both knees doesn't give you ?I dont see one, I said it "might be ok" did not recommend it

Posted

What advantage is there to be resting on one knee that bending both knees doesn't give you ?

It looks cool.  And, for way too many umpires, that's advantage enough.

You'll look cooler if you take a knee for a play with a Nike mask (powder coated of course) with a Japanese throat guard, Fonzie mask pads, Power CP, and Unequal shin guards.  :stir

And Honig's P/W slacks
Posted

Angel seems very pleased with the out!

I almost never drop all the way down, but I often take calls on the bases from something like a scissor position with both hands on one knee.

Someone please tell me if there is anything wrong with that.

@MidAmUmp?

Posted

I've only seen it done once. But wow. It was suh-weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet !

  • Like 1
Posted

Angel seems very pleased with the out!

I almost never drop all the way down, but I often take calls on the bases from something like a scissor position with both hands on one knee.

Someone please tell me if there is anything wrong with that.

@MidAmUmp?

I lean in/forward like that with my hands dropping down below my knees. Nothing wrong with either.

Posted

IMHO.....I wouldnt do it..... much for the same reason as MIdAMUmp states...if the play goes bad and if you have any further runner responsibilitioes you could find yourself behnd the play trying to recover from the one knee position ....

 

and further.....

 

I think of this much the same as I do about the one knee stance for calling balls and strikes......If you get the call right or have a good zone , no one will care if you went down on one knee.......If you get it wrong or have strike zone isues, you will just be accused of being lazy by coaches and fans......

 

and further.....

 

Im too short to work the knee at any decent level of baseball and too OCD about my PW's to get them dirty on purpose........ :P 

  • Like 3
Posted

I was working bases the other day and we had a ball go back to the backstop with R2. R2 broke for third. I moved over to cover and stumbled on my way. I ended up on my right knee and made a close call at third. My partner said to me after the game that I looked really good making that call from one knee. I fessed up that it was all blind luck.

  • Like 2
Posted

..., but I often take calls on the bases from something like a scissor position with both hands on one knee.

 

 

One of top dogs in our chapter uses this technique as a timing aid. One hand holding down the other hand keeps him from coming up too early...timing, timing, timing.  

Posted

..., but I often take calls on the bases from something like a scissor position with both hands on one knee.<br /><br />

<br /><br />One of top dogs in our chapter uses this technique as a timing aid. One hand holding down the other hand keeps him from coming up too early...timing, timing, timing. A top dog should have already learned or committed timing to memory(second nature). Not have to rely on hand techniques. :wave: just messin with ya!
Posted

 

 

..., but I often take calls on the bases from something like a scissor position with both hands on one knee.<br /><br />

<br /><br />One of top dogs in our chapter uses this technique as a timing aid. One hand holding down the other hand keeps him from coming up too early...timing, timing, timing. A top dog should have already learned or committed timing to memory(second nature). Not have to rely on hand techniques. :wave: just messin with ya!

No worries. I think this technique is one of the reasons that he's become a top dog. He has found a good habit that support good umpiring. He teaches this technique to newbies (who often have problem with timing)...so he practices what he preaches.

  • Like 1
Posted
..., but I often take calls on the bases from something like a scissor position with both hands on one knee.
One of top dogs in our chapter uses this technique as a timing aid. One hand holding down the other hand keeps him from coming up too early...timing, timing, timing.
A top dog should have already learned or committed timing to memory(second nature). Not have to rely on hand techniques. :wave: just messin with ya!
No worries. I think this technique is one of the reasons that he's become a top dog. He has found a good habit that support good umpiring. He teaches this technique to newbies (who often have problem with timing)...so he practices what he preaches.
I agree. Anything that will help!By now you should know when to take me serious or not.I try not to offend anyone unless provoked.
  • Like 4
Posted

I had to make one from a knee the other day.

I was in C with 2 out and R1/R2.

Routine grounder to F6...I was expecting him to make the easy toss to F4, but instead he threw a seed to F3.

Just about took my head off.

 

No matter what you "expect" always get out of the way of a throw to first.  You won't be in the way of any (first) throws to second (or probably third). 

×
×
  • Create New...