Holy Crap is that close!!!!!!!!!

[Thunderheads]

http://mlb.mlb.com/video/play.jsp?content_id=26573383&topic_id=9782246&c_id=mlb&tcid=vpp_copy_26573383&v=3

 

[benrosen]

That is close. I don't think he beats the ball so correct call.

[bam]

Definitely out.  Definitely! 

[carolinablue]

It was close enough to be an out.

[KLAH316]

Tie goes to the runner!! 

[Mudder]

It was close enough to be an out.

Definitely a banger that nobody will argue with either way, but I got him safe.  If you look at .36 you can see the ball is not quite in the glove yet (you can see white outside the glove), while the runner's foot is clearly "deep" in the bag.

[carolinablue]

Tie goes to the runner!! 

 

 

Klah, they changed that rule this year, didn't you know that.

[johnnyg08]

Tie goes to the runner!! 

 

That's a kickball rule coach.

 

It was close enough to be an out.

Definitely a banger that nobody will argue with either way, but I got him safe.  If you look at .36 you can see the ball is not quite in the glove yet (you can see white outside the glove), while the runner's foot is clearly "deep" in the bag.

 

 

 

With the benefit of replay, I think he's safe.  Real time, I'm sure I call an out there.

[Thunderheads]

 

It was close enough to be an out.

Definitely a banger that nobody will argue with either way, but I got him safe.  If you look at .36 you can see the ball is not quite in the glove yet (you can see white outside the glove), while the runner's foot is clearly "deep" in the bag.

 

but there was an argument .....Bud Black came out ..........

 

Super slo mo looks safe to me also.........

[Thunderheads]

 

Tie goes to the runner!! 

 

That's a kickball rule coach.

 

It was close enough to be an out.

Definitely a banger that nobody will argue with either way, but I got him safe.  If you look at .36 you can see the ball is not quite in the glove yet (you can see white outside the glove), while the runner's foot is clearly "deep" in the bag.

 

 

 

With the benefit of replay, I think he's safe.  Real time, I'm sure I call an out there.

 

Depends on what you hear

[KLAH316]

 

Tie goes to the runner!! 

 

 

Klah, they changed that rule this year, didn't you know that.

 

Oh, ok.... Let me look it up!  Do you know the code off hand?? 

[maven]

but there was an argument .....Bud Black came out ..........

The appearance of the RIC is not evidence of an argument, which requires reason and logic.

 

If Black's team had been on defense and exactly the same play ruled "Safe," not only would he have come out, but he'd have been ejected. See the difference?

[Thunderheads]

 

but there was an argument .....Bud Black came out ..........

The appearance of the RIC is not evidence of an argument, which requires reason and logic.

 

If Black's team had been on defense and exactly the same play ruled "Safe," not only would he have come out, but he'd have been ejected. See the difference?

 

All I was poining out is that BB came out after the play ........ I didn't see it,....just heard that "Black was coming out" ..........

[IABlue]

 

It was close enough to be an out.

Definitely a banger that nobody will argue with either way, but I got him safe.  If you look at .36 you can see the ball is not quite in the glove yet (you can see white outside the glove), while the runner's foot is clearly "deep" in the bag.

 

Yeah, go ahead and bring that slo-mo camera with you on the field.

 

That is an OUT at every single level of ball.  I even had this one as an out at live speed.