- 0
MYTAB on purpose.
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 397 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question
beerguy55
If you determine/believe a team tried to bat out of order intentionally, is there additional recourse?
Eg. Bottom of last inning, down a run, 7, 8 and 9 are due up, and they're collectively 0/15 and have a combined "Bingo" average of .071 on the season (but they're better than your bench) - your top five hitters are where all your offense comes from - they're 28/30 in the game. OC sends the leadoff batter up - thinking risk/reward is in his favor. Possible outcomes:
- DC acts right away and gets 7 up to bat - no risk for OC
- DC waits until 1 gets out, then since he got out, decides to continue to pitch to 2, making 1's at bat legal - somewhat ideal outcome; yes, one out, but 2 and 3 coming up.
- DC waits until 1 gets out, appeals, 7 is ruled out and 8 is up. Very little risk, 7 was going to get out anyway
- DC waits until 1 gets on base, appeals, 1 is removed, 7 is out, 8 is up - same same.
- DC doesn't notice in time - jackpot
OC could do the same starting with 9, offering him as a sacrificial lamb, trying to get the leadoff batter up with one out.
Seems there's all reward, no risk to attempting this. If DC notices, no harm no foul...if he doesn't....woohoo!! If DC comes out and says "come on Blue, that's a pretty blatant batting order screwup, anyone can see it was intentional" can you really do anything? What if you somehow KNEW it was intentional? Does this fall under the same category as the bunt play where R2 misses third base by 30 feet?
Top Posters For This Question
3
2
1
1
Popular Days
Oct 15
4
Oct 14
3
Oct 8
2
Oct 12
1
Top Posters For This Question
beerguy55 3 posts
Velho 2 posts
noumpere 1 post
jimurrayalterego 1 post
Popular Days
Oct 15 2025
4 posts
Oct 14 2025
3 posts
Oct 8 2025
2 posts
Oct 12 2025
1 post
Popular Posts
beerguy55
I don't disagree - the real problem here is, under the objective of fair play, there's no real risk to the offense to continue to try to get one by the defense. Beyond wasting a lot of time with all t
flyingron
We are all honorable men here. We do not have to give each other assurances as if we were lawyers.
Velho
Nice pitcher you got there coach. Be a shame if anything happened to his strike zone...
9 answers to this question
Recommended Posts