Foul ...no wait, ....Fair?

[Thunderheads]

what in the hell ?  

http://m.mlb.com/video/v989893283/?query=umpire

[stkjock]

nutty!  That's two odd ball plays you've found!

[Rich Ives]

Where was the ball when touched? Who had the best look? They agreed U3 and thus on his assessment of fair.

B-R had 1B made so changing the call didn't really affect runner placement.

[Stk004]

28 minutes ago, Thunderheads said:

what in the hell ?  

http://m.mlb.com/video/v989893283/?query=umpire

Looks like they had it right the first time. 

[Thunderheads]

Kulpa was the "over-ruler" so ....like Rich said, he had the better look ....WHICH, if you watch the video again, you can see Salvy in Chris Conroy's way ....the camera angle however is askew,...it must be because according to it ...it looks foul

[Stk004]

1 minute ago, Thunderheads said:

Kulpa was the "over-ruler" so ....like Rich said, he had the better look ....WHICH, if you watch the video again, you can see Salvy in Chris Conroy's way ....the camera angle however is askew,...it must be because according to it ...it looks foul

I did see Conroy watching around Salvy but did he make the call? I know it was in slow motion but I didn't see a signal from him after it was touched or after it hit the ground. 

[Thunderheads]

2 minutes ago, Stk004 said:

I did see Conroy watching around Salvy but did he make the call? I know it was in slow motion but I didn't see a signal from him after it was touched or after it hit the ground. 

He made the initial call........

[noumpere]

It's still a little strange because this call "belong" to PU, and not U3.

But, it does point out the difference between the OBR rule / interp and FED (and NCAA)