Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4820 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

What a (insert insulting name here)!

 

He got five games for the incident with Rob Drake... At the SEMUC camp, James Hoye actually specifically mentioned in our clinic that among the MLB umpires, there was extreme discontent and anger that he only got five games.

 

With this in mind, and knowing he is a repeat offender, I think he may get a decently long term suspension for this.

Posted

Big leagues or not that behavior has to stop. Kids see it and leads to problems with us.

Posted

Throw your helmet out of disgust at yourself, you might get a little rope if the coach takes care of it right then and there. But, if you've already got a rep for tossing equipment, especially at another umpire, then you get nothing.

Posted

And why protest at anything........... You're a MLB all-star catcher that's been around long enough to know when you've been thrown out at first?!  Hell, I threw a kid out on a play this weekend very similar, ...a banger at first .....NOT A PEEP from anyone .........  the kid knew it, the 1B coach knew it, ....  why?  Hey Yadi,....you're out, go sit down!  What a d-bag! :shakehead:

  • Like 1
Posted

I saw an article on this where he said the out call was correct, and that he thought an EJ was not warranted here.   :WTF

 

Big boys should know you throw equipment (especially within a few feet of an umpire who just made a call against you), you're gone...

Posted

1) Good toss.

2) love how all the StL coaches are blaming Fagan (needs a feel for the game/situation, he was looking for something, blah blah blah) yet they never acknowledge the player going complete off the wall. Give a YGTBSM (see: Greinke/Holbrook) look and let the manager go ballistic.

3) good thing it was the last game of the series, could've been some interesting convos the next night between Fagan and Yadi.

Posted

I will bet that he doesn't get more than 5 games.

I'll bet he gets nothing. They'll chalk it up to "being frustrated at himself" and a "rookie umpire taking it the wrong way and trying to make a name for himself."

Posted

This what I posted on the comments section.

 

It would be nice if fans had a clue before they post. Molina was thrown out on a nice play by the SS. The umpire made the correct call. Imagine that, the replay clearly shows it was correct, Molina says it was correct. Then he slams his helmet, clearly a violation according to established MLB rules and practices, for that he was tossed, again a correct call by the umpire. He has no idea, nor should he, whether Molina was mad at himself or the umpire. The simple fact is, if you throw equipment like that you will get tossed. The accepted mechanic is not to have further discussion with the player if possible. Manager comes out, has his say, said the wrong thing and got tossed, again accepted practice. So what we have here is three judgments by the umpire, all correct, two three actions by the player/manager, incorrect and two tosses. If Molina had taken his punishment like a man instead of a petulant child he would have been out of that game and no talk of suspensions. The manager may or may not have gone far enough to get tossed, likely not. So there is no room for them to be mad. It has absolutely nothing to do with a young umpire trying to make a name. As a matter of fact, ejections, or the wrong kinds, will get you released. 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

"That's not how you want to make a name"...WTF?@#%#% Don't want to make a name for yourself by making the dead-on correct call? Don't want to make a name by staying completely calm in the face of an apoplectic superstar? Don't want to make a name by being everyone's punching bag for being RIGHT?

  • Like 2
Posted

I just went over to the St. Louis Cardinals email contact page and sent them a nice little message that what Molina and Mattheny did Sunday was reprehensible. I also mentioned to them that kids mimic their actions and what they did in a few seconds can take weeks or months to correct and deal with. I also told them Molina and Mattheny should immediately apologize publicly to the umpires and to fans everywhere. This type of behavior has to stop. Just because you are a millionaire does not mean you get to treat people with disrespect!

 

Here is the email link. I urge all of you reading this to do the same and send them a nice little email complaining. Stick to the facts and let them know it is not acceptable. Like it or not, they are role models and they are exhibiting poor behavior.

 

http://stlouis.cardinals.mlb.com/help/email.jsp?c_id=stl&primarySubject=The%20Cardinals&secondarySubject=other&dest=community@cardinals.mlb.com

  • Like 2
Posted

 

I will bet that he doesn't get more than 5 games.

I'll bet he gets nothing. They'll chalk it up to "being frustrated at himself" and a "rookie umpire taking it the wrong way and trying to make a name for himself."

 

 

 

If he doesn't I hope a few FU calls are in order.

Posted

He got a ONE game suspension. 

 

Of course he is appealing it so he's playing right now against the D'Backs......

Posted

Ok, ....admit,....the call was right ......good boy ..........admitting he was frustrated with himself ......good boy .....

 

BUT DON'T say you were trying to hold on to the helmet, .....please ..........

 

http://wapc.mlb.com/play?content_id=27703789

Posted

What a crock only 1 game? And He initiated contact with both Everett & Cederstrom and only gets 1 game. 

 

They are not going to learn a lesson w/ the weak fines & suspensions. 

  • Like 1
Posted

All this will do is encourage others to act the same way, especially when his appeal is upheld.

 

Maybe after the all the stories lately and Angel's replay issue, this is an FU call from the MLB office to the union...

Posted

 

All this will do is encourage others to act the same way, especially when his appeal is upheld.

 

Maybe after the all the stories lately and Angel's replay issue, this is an FU call from the MLB office to the union...

 

 

Let's hope not.

Posted

They are not going to learn a lesson w/ the weak fines & suspensions. 

I respectfully disagree. Judging by how the behavior is getting, I'd say a lesson is definitely being learned. That is, do whatever you want. Nothing is going to happen to you.

Posted

 

They are not going to learn a lesson w/ the weak fines & suspensions. 

I respectfully disagree. Judging by how the behavior is getting, I'd say a lesson is definitely being learned. That is, do whatever you want. Nothing is going to happen to you.

 

 

Bingo. The message is loud and clear.

×
×
  • Create New...