Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 3869 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

So I have this adult league game today and the guys are chirping all game.  Basically harmless like "I disagree with you" and "that was outside".  No warnings were warranted nor issued.  However, in the 6th inning I call a third strike on a pitch on the outside corner.  As the batter heads back to the dugout he draws the line.  I say, "You should know better than that.  You're gone"...  The ejected player goes crazy and gets in my face.  I walk away toward his manager and tell him that if he doesn't leave that I will forfeit the game.  The coach apologizes on his behalf and controls the player for the most part.  Two pitches later, the ejected player is behind me commenting on my calls.  I forfeit the game.  Now almost everyone is shocked as apparently this has never happened before but I stand my ground and announce that the game is over.  I called my assigner on my way home and explained what happened.

I probably won't be called again but the bottom line for me is that I don't even care if I don't do any more of their games as a result of my decision.  

 

Thoughts?

Posted

Dang, dude.  Seems like an over-reaction to me.  Why not let the league handle this guy's fate?  You EJ'd him, and if you felt the coach didn't take care of it well enough, take it up with him.  If the league rules are that an EJ'd person has to leave the facility, that's something the league should police after you put it in your report.  Or if the player won't leave, don't resume the game until he does.  Just seems like there are a number of options at your disposal than packing up and going home.

Why the jaded perspective of not caring if you do any more of their games?  Is there something else going on here?

  • Like 1
Posted

Dang, dude.  Seems like an over-reaction to me.  Why not let the league handle this guy's fate?  You EJ'd him, and if you felt the coach didn't take care of it well enough, take it up with him.  If the league rules are that an EJ'd person has to leave the facility, that's something the league should police after you put it in your report.  Or if the player won't leave, don't resume the game until he does.  Just seems like there are a number of options at your disposal than packing up and going home.

Why the jaded perspective of not caring if you do any more of their games?  Is there something else going on here?

Agreed.  How many innings?  If it's only seven it seems to be a lot of an over reaction.  Just get the coach to handle it.  Seems like you made the game about yourself.

 

Posted

Thank you for the input.  The games are nine innings.  I do not feel jaded.  I umpire for fun and I sacrifice a lot doing a game on a Sunday morning, giving up family time.  I forfeited the game because the player was asked numerous times to leave and refused too.  When he came back to continue to argue, I had had enough.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Perhaps everyone was in shock because it appeared that you just didn't want to be there anymore...perception is reality for the perceivers.  Just keep cool. Don't respond to any of his BS. Just let it be known that you're not restarting the game until he's out of sight/ear-shot. 

Posted

I was actually extremely cool and never raised my voice.  However, that very well may be the case but I think that other umpires accept the abuse and/or make idle threats.  I just want to reiterate that I had warned the head coach that I was about to end the game.  In my judgement, both the player and coach did not heed my warning.

I think that I could've handled it better, you are right.  With every game that I do my goal is to improve.  I love to umpire.

  • Like 2
Posted

Here's a good rule of thumb: do not forfeit a game. Whatever the reason, even if it is a forfeit by rule, suspend it. Let the governing body sort it out. Forfeit has a permanence and a "death-penalty" feel to it, whereas suspension sounds like a less-unilateral decree.

In this case, if you had told HC "If he doesn't leave, I will be suspending a game and sending the details to the league for action," he probably would have had some leverage. That's putting any consequences on him, the player, and the league--you're just the facilitator. It also means that if he complies, you can resume the game at any time, which is an option you don't have with a declared forfeit.

  • Like 1
Posted

Here's a good rule of thumb: do not forfeit a game. Whatever the reason, even if it is a forfeit by rule, suspend it. Let the governing body sort it out. Forfeit has a permanence and a "death-penalty" feel to it, whereas suspension sounds like a less-unilateral decree.

In this case, if you had told HC "If he doesn't leave, I will be suspending a game and sending the details to the league for action," he probably would have had some leverage. That's putting any consequences on him, the player, and the league--you're just the facilitator. It also means that if he complies, you can resume the game at any time, which is an option you don't have with a declared forfeit.

That is a good point.  For what it's worth, I don't know how the league is going to deal with the forfeit.  They may very well continue the game which I would be totally ok with.  By the way, I was doing the game solo because my partner never showed up.  

Posted

http://m.mlb.com/video/v6458903/atlfla-cox-is-ejected-for-arguing-with-the-umpire

Everyone likes to watch this video because the viewer can hear basically everything that is said between the umpire, Jim Wolfe, and the manager, Bobby Cox.  I post it here for another reason:  watch how Jim refuses to re-start the game until Bobby leaves.  He just remains calm and says, "you gotta go, Bobby".  He just won't start the game again until Bobby leaves.

In your case, since the ejected party was a player, all you need to do is say "coach, he's gotta go."  You don't need to do anything further other than calmly say, "we're not going to restart until he leaves."  Then say nothing more.  Just keep your calm and stand there and refuse to start the game until the EJ'd party is out of sight and sound.

I've never had this not work; it works every time.  If, however, the player fails to leave and the coach is doing nothing about it, then calmly say, "if he doesn't leave the game is going to be suspended and this will be reported to the league to deal with."  Say it calmly and non-threateningly.  Do NOT give the player (or team) a time period in which the player has to leave.  (Such as 60 seconds).  Just use good judgment.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

http://m.mlb.com/video/v6458903/atlfla-cox-is-ejected-for-arguing-with-the-umpire

Everyone likes to watch this video because the viewer can hear basically everything that is said between the umpire, Jim Wolfe, and the manager, Bobby Cox.  I post it here for another reason:  watch how Jim refuses to re-start the game until Bobby leaves.  He just remains calm and says, "you gotta go, Bobby".  He just won't start the game again until Bobby leaves.

In your case, since the ejected party was a player, all you need to do is say "coach, he's gotta go."  You don't need to do anything further other than calmly say, "we're not going to restart until he leaves."  Then say nothing more.  Just keep your calm and stand there and refuse to start the game until the EJ'd party is out of sight and sound.

I've never had this not work; it works every time.  If, however, the player fails to leave and the coach is doing nothing about it, then calmly say, "if he doesn't leave the game is going to be suspended and this will be reported to the league to deal with."  Say it calmly and non-threateningly.  Do NOT give the player (or team) a time period in which the player has to leave.  (Such as 60 seconds).  Just use good judgment.

 

 

Was the passive voice in your statement to the HC intentional?

Posted

No need to be aggressive.  But one could say, "I'm going to suspend this game and report this to the league if he doesn't leave," and that's fine, too.  The last time I used this technique, I said (to the assistant coach...who was now acting head coach, since the head coach was tossed), "he's gotta go.  We're not starting 'till he's gone.  He can go on the bus or in the school, but he ain't staying anywhere near here."  Then I just shut up and stood on the third base line and stared into the dugout until he left.

The point is, there is no need to throw gas on the fire.  Try to get cooperation...you've already taken a drastic step (ejection).  If they don't cooperate, then terminate (suspend) the game.  You've already done everything you can do.

Posted

Was the passive voice in your statement to the HC intentional?

An alternative: "if he doesn't leave the game, then I will have to suspend the game and report it to the league for further action." The player's actions leave us no choice.

Posted

 

http://m.mlb.com/video/v6458903/atlfla-cox-is-ejected-for-arguing-with-the-umpire

Everyone likes to watch this video because the viewer can hear basically everything that is said between the umpire, Jim Wolfe, and the manager, Bobby Cox.  I post it here for another reason:  watch how Jim refuses to re-start the game until Bobby leaves.  He just remains calm and says, "you gotta go, Bobby".  He just won't start the game again until Bobby leaves.

In your case, since the ejected party was a player, all you need to do is say "coach, he's gotta go."  You don't need to do anything further other than calmly say, "we're not going to restart until he leaves."  Then say nothing more.  Just keep your calm and stand there and refuse to start the game until the EJ'd party is out of sight and sound.

I've never had this not work; it works every time.  If, however, the player fails to leave and the coach is doing nothing about it, then calmly say, "if he doesn't leave the game is going to be suspended and this will be reported to the league to deal with."  Say it calmly and non-threateningly.  Do NOT give the player (or team) a time period in which the player has to leave.  (Such as 60 seconds).  Just use good judgment.

 

 

What gives with letting Girardi and Papelbon stay in the dugout after being ejected? Is it sometimes better to keep the game going and let the league deal with it? 

Posted

What gives with letting Girardi and Papelbon stay in the dugout after being ejected? Is it sometimes better to keep the game going and let the league deal with it? 

Yep. Note it in the report, deal with the situation if they become issues.

Posted

In pro ball, each ejection is unique.  There is no "one size fits all".  If the ejection is "routine" (and there is actually a box on the MiLB/MLB ejection report that asks if the ejection was "routine/offensive/very offensive") and wasn't very personal, the umpires know that the ejected personnel will leave fairly quickly...so they just get the game going again.  Every pro umpire has as their #1 goal during a non-routine situation to "get the game going again."

Bobby Cox, in his ejection I posted above, decided to be his normal POS self and make the ejection personal after being tossed ("you're the worst F'n umpire in the F'n history of baseball," and on-and-on) so Jim Wolfe decided to wait him out.  If a guy comes out to argue balls-and-strikes and gets tossed for arguing balls-and-strikes without getting too personal...the umpires are going to get the game going again with the expectation that the EJ'd party will leave.  They'll stop the game if they see that the EJ'd person doesn't leave.  This is something one learns to feel (as to what course of action is appropriate post-ejection) with experience.

On a personal level, I had ejections in pro ball where once I ejected the player they were stunned into silence (they acted as if they had never been ejected before, or like they did not know I could eject them).  Once they were ejected, they just shut up and packed their stuff and left.  In those cases, there is no need for me to wait until they pack their stuff.  I can get the game going while they do that.

On the other hand, I've ejected players/managers who then proceeded to throw helmets and/or bats onto the field from the dugout.  I also had games where the manager either kicked dirt on me and/or covered home plate in dirt.  I can assure you that those games did not re-start until the EJ'd party was gone.

  • 6 months later...
Posted

@aiber said: "I umpire for fun and I sacrifice a lot doing a game on a Sunday morning, giving up family time".  

If the league is not happy with this they can find some smitty that will call games for these testosterone kings.

You sent a message to all involved.

Ejected people should be out sight and out of earshot.

When I tossed I would not restart the game until the person was way far away.

If they remain around the field this will always happen.

GOOD KILL!

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I quit doing men's league because, by and large, the guys playing are nuts.  I called a pitch in the 18+ league that was at belly button right down the middle of the plate and player lost it.  Saying that is not a strike in pro or college ball.  I had to remind him it was a rec league played by OBR rules and that it was a strike.

I mean I have tossed more guys from men's league than other rec, travel, middle school, high school, and college ball combined.  And I've probably done about 1/4 the amount of men's games as all others combined.  Four leagues in Indy too, 18+, 28+, 35+, and 45+.  My current association does not assign them as the league is perceived as a joke.

Posted
1 hour ago, indianaumpire15 said:

I quit doing men's league because, by and large, the guys playing are nuts.  I called a pitch in the 18+ league that was at belly button right down the middle of the plate and player lost it.  Saying that is not a strike in pro or college ball.  I had to remind him it was a rec league played by OBR rules and that it was a strike.

I mean I have tossed more guys from men's league than other rec, travel, middle school, high school, and college ball combined.  And I've probably done about 1/4 the amount of men's games as all others combined.  Four leagues in Indy too, 18+, 28+, 35+, and 45+.  My current association does not assign them as the league is perceived as a joke.

I love doing men's league. Love it, love it, love it. I agree with your assessment. Yes, they're nuttier then fruitcakes. But that's what I love about it. These guys are hilarious. The things they complain about make me giggle. Yesterday I was calling a 40+ division and one of the pitcher's was horrible. Every pitch was in he dirt. Every. Pitch. I kept calling ball after ball after ball. I see the pitcher getting frustrated. He's kicking at the mound like a little kid, and I'm rather entertained by it.

Finally after I call his ninth ball in a row he loses it and I have to keep a smile at bay. He steps off the mound, raises his hands at his sides and yells, "You're giving me a zone the size of a keyhole! Come on!"

Three things. One, he looks like a cartoon character, which is comical enough. Two, this is the first inning.  And three, his team only has nine guys. I said to him, "You're arguing balls and strikes already? I don't think your team can afford to lose a guy today."

The catcher says to me, "I'll calm him down," and goes out to the mound.

An inning goes by and the pitcher comes up to me and says apologetically, "Sorry I lost it. I'm struggling today and I shouldn't have said that." And the rest of the game was fine.

You'll learn more about managing the game and its personalities in men's league than anywhere else. And if nothing else, for that it's invaluable.

Posted
1 hour ago, ElkOil said:

I love doing men's league. Love it, love it, love it. I agree with your assessment. Yes, they're nuttier then fruitcakes. But that's what I love about it. These guys are hilarious. The things they complain about make me giggle. Yesterday I was calling a 40+ division and one of the pitcher's was horrible. Every pitch was in he dirt. Every. Pitch. I kept calling ball after ball after ball. I see the pitcher getting frustrated. He's kicking at the mound like a little kid, and I'm rather entertained by it.

Finally after I call his ninth ball in a row he loses it and I have to keep a smile at bay. He steps off the mound, raises his hands at his sides and yells, "You're giving me a zone the size of a keyhole! Come on!"

Three things. One, he looks like a cartoon character, which is comical enough. Two, this is the first inning.  And three, his team only has nine guys. I said to him, "You're arguing balls and strikes already? I don't think your team can afford to lose a guy today."

The catcher says to me, "I'll calm him down," and goes out to the mound.

An inning goes by and the pitcher comes up to me and says apologetically, "Sorry I lost it. I'm struggling today and I shouldn't have said that." And the rest of the game was fine.

You'll learn more about managing the game and its personalities in men's league than anywhere else. And if nothing else, for that it's invaluable.

Totally agree that you will learn more about game management and encounter more situations doing men's league games than you ever will in high school. Some of the reactions that I have gotten from relatively routine calls are the most memorable if my short umpiring career. The fact of the matter is that most of them are testosterone filled guys who think they should be in the major leagues. Some are also college players who think they are better than the guys who are only playing because they want to keep playing baseball. A select few are well managed players who don't cause trouble, but I learned early on that the arguments and theatrics was just going to be part of the game.

I know many guys I've worked with said they won't touch a men's league game with a 40 foot pole because of how nuts they are and I simply reply, more games for me. Plus the leagues around here have pretty good ball, so it does prepare you for some high school games and it let's you slow it all down when you get the good high school assignments. At the very least, the more games you work, the more experience you get! 

Posted
43 minutes ago, LittleBlue said:

Totally agree that you will learn more about game management and encounter more situations doing men's league games than you ever will in high school. Some of the reactions that I have gotten from relatively routine calls are the most memorable if my short umpiring career. The fact of the matter is that most of them are testosterone filled guys who think they should be in the major leagues. Some are also college players who think they are better than the guys who are only playing because they want to keep playing baseball. A select few are well managed players who don't cause trouble, but I learned early on that the arguments and theatrics was just going to be part of the game.

I know many guys I've worked with said they won't touch a men's league game with a 40 foot pole because of how nuts they are and I simply reply, more games for me. Plus the leagues around here have pretty good ball, so it does prepare you for some high school games and it let's you slow it all down when you get the good high school assignments. At the very least, the more games you work, the more experience you get! 

I think the same thing. And you're right about some good players. A few of our 18+ teams have some excellent players on them and the games are very good. A couple of teams have some former AAA guys who still have some serious talent. I did three games yesterday, and the first two were outstanding -- great pitching, good fielding and close games all the way through. We even had a small crowd of about three dozen people show up to watch, so there were people actually cheering and adding some energy... which isn't typical of men's league, especially when the older guys play.

And on the business side, our contract with them is a good one and puts some serious coin in my pocket.

Posted

@ElkOil yep, our contract is good too. It beats doing a travel level DH. We usually don't get much of a crowd, except for some of the Hispanic teams, who bring their family to the game, or the All Star game, which is to be expected. No matter what level you call, there are going to be games that make you want to pull your hair out, but that's just part of the job. 

  • Like 1
Posted
On ‎4‎/‎11‎/‎2016 at 2:53 PM, ElkOil said:

I love doing men's league. Love it, love it, love it. I agree with your assessment. Yes, they're nuttier then fruitcakes. But that's what I love about it. These guys are hilarious. The things they complain about make me giggle.

I agree that you get some characters.   I worked a different chapter of a men's league last year.  Obviously, they guys playing for a while new most of the umpires.  one F3 asks, so, are you new?  I asked him to define new.  He then asked if many coaches have ridden me yet.  I replied that after 20 years of umpiring, That's the closes I've come to being called a horses ass.  Is that how we're going to start this season?  He looked at me in dis-belief and I can hear him try to tell his F4 ...... "Nope, he's not new".

  • Like 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, Aging_Arbiter said:

I agree that you get some characters.   I worked a different chapter of a men's league last year.  Obviously, they guys playing for a while new most of the umpires.  one F3 asks, so, are you new?  I asked him to define new.  He then asked if many coaches have ridden me yet.  I replied that after 20 years of umpiring, That's the closes I've come to being called a horses ass.  Is that how we're going to start this season?  He looked at me in dis-belief and I can hear him try to tell his F4 ...... "Nope, he's not new".

Men's league is the closest thing to a wolf pack I've ever experienced. They need to know you're the alpha dog -- fair, in charge, confident and good at your job. When they smell weakness, it's all over for you. Having said that, they're a forgiving bunch.  When I first started, I had a lot to learn and they rode me like a rented mule. But as I improved, the trust and respect grew and now I no longer have any problems with even the most volatile among them. And they give me a lot of compliments, which is a complete 180 from when I first began.

×
×
  • Create New...