Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4672 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

I go down to a knee when the catcher squeezes me. I prefer not to though.

@Moe

 

Basically when he sets up inside?

 

Ya. I stand in the slot, but when a catcher goes to far inside, I go down to one knee.

Posted

I'll go to more of a bastardized version of a scissor stance. As BBUC head instructor Billy Haze told us at the BBUC weekend clinic in Redding, CA last year, "do what you need to do to get into the slot."

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I would go on 2 hands on my knees...in a set position over the catcher's head in a situation like this.

only issue is that going over the top of F2 leaves you exposed. They say with the Davis Stance... go back and up to see the zone. So step back and raise your eye level...

Posted

I've still failed to ever hear a compelling reason why it is wrong to go outside when the catcher squeezes inside.  I know that camp and evaluators say that it is wrong...that if the catcher won't work with you, just call balls until he gives you a window.  But  aside from that "philosophy", what is different about going outside of a catcher who is set up way inside on a lefty...versus being in the slot on an 0-2 pitch with him set up well outside?  The position of the batter doesn't affect your view in either situation.  Is it that we are more likely to eat a foul ball?  

 

I agree that we need to get the catcher to give us a look inside, and we need to make sure that we call the inside strike when he does.  But in the rare instance when he doesn't, I don't think going outside for a pitch or two is a Cardinal sin.  I'm open to hearing why it might be though!

Posted

You will get killed if you go outside!!!

C'mon man! Think about it!!! :wave:

Posted

There is a diagram floating around that will give you that compelling reason.

Posted

I've still failed to ever hear a compelling reason why it is wrong to go outside when the catcher squeezes inside... Is it that we are more likely to eat a foul ball?  

 

yes, it is a safety issue. If you count the number of foul balls whizzing past your right ear for RHB and add to that, the number of foul balls whizzing past your left ear for LHB, you should be able to find your compelling reason.

 

...that if the catcher won't work with you, just call balls until he gives you a window.  But  aside from that "philosophy"... 

 

That philosophy needs to die. F2 is doing his job. Either he has been coached to be where he is or thinks that is where he needs to be to get strikes/outs. I don't ask F2 to move. Umpires need to adjust and not cheat the defense by balling strikes. I raise my head height if F2 is squeezing inside unless B is squeezing me too...then I adjust to whereever I need to.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I've still failed to ever hear a compelling reason why it is wrong to go outside when the catcher squeezes inside... Is it that we are more likely to eat a foul ball?  

 

yes, it is a safety issue. If you count the number of foul balls whizzing past your right ear for RHB and add to that, the number of foul balls whizzing past your left ear for LHB, you should be able to find your compelling reason.

 

...that if the catcher won't work with you, just call balls until he gives you a window.  But  aside from that "philosophy"... 

 

That philosophy needs to die. F2 is doing his job. Either he has been coached to be where he is or thinks that is where he needs to be to get strikes/outs. I don't ask F2 to move. Umpires need to adjust and not cheat the defense by balling strikes. I raise my head height if F2 is squeezing inside unless B is squeezing me too...then I adjust to whereever I need to.

 

 

I agree.  Get the best look you can (without going outside) and call all the strikes you can.  That said, there have been times that I missed a strike (based on F2 asking me where it missed) because I just couldn't track it well.  I have to say, though, that often when this happens, it's the batter's hands getting in my line of vision than F2 squeezing me.

Posted

Can someone smarter than me (insert comments here) find that Diagram with the Percentages of getting hit?

 

 

 

 

 

Edit: Nevermind I found it. I must be smarter than I look!

 

 

hot.jpg

 

 

If you move outside this is what will happen!!

 

umpirekerwindanleydowninatlantavNatsSunM

  • Like 1
Posted

Can someone smarter than me (insert comments here) find that Diagram with the Percentages of getting hit?

 

 

 

 

 

Edit: Nevermind I found it. I must be smarter than I look!

 

 

hot.jpg

 

 

 

 

This "danger zone" diagram was posted on the UE site a couple of years ago and made me change my thinking. I get hit a lot less by not going outside.

Posted

Because of the many current lawsuits, I have moved about 3' behind the catcher at lower levels so that there

is no chance of any implications.  Our society is bringing about many changes -- how do we react or act with them?

This is my choice.  And, what I have I chosen to do. And, it is tough for me after decades of umpiring. 

Posted

Because of the many current lawsuits, I have moved about 3' behind the catcher at lower levels so that there

is no chance of any implications.  Our society is bringing about many changes -- how do we react or act with them?

This is my choice.  And, what I have I chosen to do. And, it is tough for me after decades of umpiring. 

:HS

Posted

Because of the many current lawsuits, I have moved about 3' behind the catcher at lower levels so that there

is no chance of any implications. Our society is bringing about many changes -- how do we react or act with them?

This is my choice. And, what I have I chosen to do. And, it is tough for me after decades of umpiring.

Wow

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Because of the many current lawsuits, I have moved about 3' behind the catcher at lower levels so that there

is no chance of any implications. Our society is bringing about many changes -- how do we react or act with them?

This is my choice. And, what I have I chosen to do. And, it is tough for me after decades of umpiring.

Wow

 

NO crap WOW?! What on earth are you talking about @seashols?

  • Like 1
Posted

Um, @seashols, I think your idea of "getting into the slot" is not the same as what is being discussed

sounds like he comes from the "end of career" school of Joe Brinkman umpiring.

×
×
  • Create New...