Jump to content

"acceptable" arguements/conversations?


Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 6098 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

This question comes from watching my son's varsity basketball game last night. Maybe answers can help me heading to year no. 2 as an umpire. What looked to be a foul was called a jump ball. Most of the gym was screaming for a foul ( I don't know how you basketball refs do it! ), and ball was taken to baseline for inbounding. The player who went to inbound asked the ref how the play result was not a foul and conversation, breif- conversation, started. After a bit of conversation the ref said "thats enough son" ,the players response was "I'm not your son" and was promtly given a tech. foul. The player messed up by talking to the ref might have done better by just saying "that's enough". For full disclosure the the player and I share the same height, hair color (when mine was not grey ),address and last name! MST I think you know him! Yes I'm venting, and I explained how he messed up but I do want some feedback pn what kind of discussions are ok.

  • Replies 13
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

I don't see a problem with an official using the term son although I prefer sir. I call a lot of kids sir, love the look. That said, I wouldn't have T'd him for objecting to being called son, but just said, " Ler's play." I don't know what else went on during the game or what tension level had been reached but you shouldn't penalize a player when objecting to being called something besides his name unless it was done in an unreasonable level or manner.

Just so everyone understands, when Wayne says his son shares his size that means really big. Let me know who the official was when I see at the rules clinic Sunday. Good to see you posting.

Posted

I will start off by agreeing that the player should not have received a technical for that. I hoping the official learned from that and will maybe drop the extra words and leave it at, "That's enough"

As an official you have to watch what you say. I'm learning here through discussions that what you don't say can't get you into trouble but what you do say can.

It's like some bench bosses don't like to be called coach.:D

"I'm the F$%#@ing manager!!!

An argument can ramp up prety quickly just by using that one little word

Posted

I work four sports (not basketball) and the level of acceptable discussion varies widely. The "T" could be related to a number of things, including the ref being an a$$.

I like to call them sir, not son. In softball, it's ma'am or ladies.

Posted

If it's one or more, I'll refer to them as "gents" or "gentlemen".

If it's one, I use sir.

If I'm pissed off at him, I use the universal middle name: "You".

Or their number.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

One would be wise to consider a bit of advice a former college prof. gave to me, prior to starting my teaching career. "Never say anything to a student, that you would not say if their parents were present." ty

Posted
One would be wise to consider a bit of advice a former college prof. gave to me, prior to starting my teaching career. "Never say anything to a student, that you would not say if their parents were present." ty
THAT is good stuff!
Posted

What looked to be a foul was called a jump ball. Most of the gym was screaming for a foul ( I don't know how you basketball refs do it! ), and ball was taken to baseline for inbounding. The player who went to inbound asked the ref how the play result was not a foul and conversation, breif- conversation, started. After a bit of conversation the ref said "thats enough son" ,the players response was "I'm not your son" and was promtly given a tech. foul. The player messed up by talking to the ref might have done better by just saying "that's enough". For full disclosure the the player and I share the same height, hair color (when mine was not grey ),address and last name! MST I think you know him! Yes I'm venting, and I explained how he messed up but I do want some feedback pn what kind of discussions are ok
.

This is an officials Forum so I tend to side with the officials UNLESS I witness first hand. Here is what we do not know and a conversation, breif- conversation, started

What was said in this "brief conversation"? Perhaps the referree gave the kid "a break during this brief conversation" and then the ref said "that's enough son" to which the player responded I'm not your son The player was now being a wise you know what and just added insult to injury.

The referee allowed the player to have his say and then it's time to play ball. The player "kept it going" by saying I'm not your son.

It's similar to the following

Coach is questioning balls / strikes. The first one most of us "let go" but if it continues we say "skip that's enough" and NOW if the coach continues by saying something like "Pete you been missing them all day" or something along those lines then it's bye bye time otherwise you lose credibility.

Once as an official you say "THAT'S ENOUGH" that's EXACTLY what it means otherwise do not say it at all. It means Coach I hear you but it is NOW time to play.

In a nutshell we do not know what was said BUT the referee did allow the player to have a conversation. Therefore, it's difficult to say a T was or was NOT warrented. I tend to think it was because the player was being a wise you know what and IMO received what he had coming to him.

Pete Booth

Posted

Along this same line. Another question for the learned among us. I have had at times a coach, say to me, after a perceived miss call (his perception not mine) something to the effect of " that's two you owe me" I have been giving him my best "crucifixion by sight" glare. (developed from 28 yrs of teaching) EJ or ignore?? tyennie

Posted

Along this same line. Another question for the learned among us. I have had at times a coach, say to me, after a perceived miss call (his perception not mine) something to the effect of " that's two you owe me" I have been giving him my best "crucifixion by sight" glare. (developed from 28 yrs of teaching) EJ or ignore?? tyennie

Why don't you tell us what you did, instead of asking what we (collective) might do?

I'm betting I know what you didn't do...

Posted

Along this same line. Another question for the learned among us. I have had at times a coach, say to me, after a perceived miss call (his perception not mine) something to the effect of " that's two you owe me" I have been giving him my best "crucifixion by sight" glare. (developed from 28 yrs of teaching) EJ or ignore?? tyennie

Counting is an automatic :mad:

I had a couch count on my partner once:

Coach: "Thats two ...."

Partner: "The thirds in the parking lot. Go get it!"

Posted

Why don't you tell us what you did, instead of asking what we (collective) might do?

I'm betting I know what you didn't do...

Well you are correct in that i did not send him packing. but you did miss what i did do which was give him the STFU! Look.

for those that have advised: "So Long, Farewell, See Ya!" thanks for your assistance. This year he shant be counting pitches for me.

Posted

"you" is the magic word for me. Drop that on me, and we have a problem.

In watching local HS basketball, I would eject most coaches within five minutes of every game if their behavior came on a baseball field. No way I could do basketball, 'cause they'd be no coaches left. Nobody yells at me like that. Not in a sporting venue, nor at the Costco. Why it's okay with vertical stripes on is beyond me.

Football and basketball guys, please explain why you let grown men turn red in the face as you let them vent three feet from your noggin.


×
×
  • Create New...