Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 5701 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey guys,

I've been reading all of the obstruction commentary lately and just wanted to make sure that I understand the basic premise.

OBR

OBSTRUCTION is the act of a fielder who, while not in possession of the ball and

not in the act of fielding the ball, impedes the progress of any runner.

Impedes: be a hindrance or obstacle to

Question: If a fielder moves through the base path (not making a play, not fielding throw etc..) and causes the runner to break stride (No contact) then that should be called obstruction, correct?

  • Replies 13
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Hey guys,

I've been reading all of the obstruction commentary lately and just wanted to make sure that I understand the basic premise.

OBR

OBSTRUCTION is the act of a fielder who, while not in possession of the ball and

not in the act of fielding the ball, impedes the progress of any runner.

Impedes: be a hindrance or obstacle to

Question: If a fielder moves through the base path (not making a play, not fielding throw etc..) and causes the runner to break stride (No contact) then that should be called obstruction, correct?

Yes.

Posted

Hey guys,

I've been reading all of the obstruction commentary lately and just wanted to make sure that I understand the basic premise.

OBR

OBSTRUCTION is the act of a fielder who, while not in possession of the ball and

not in the act of fielding the ball, impedes the progress of any runner.

Impedes: be a hindrance or obstacle to

Question: If a fielder moves through the base path (not making a play, not fielding throw etc..) and causes the runner to break stride (No contact) then that should be called obstruction, correct?

There is probably no contact in this clip. Yet Dan Bellino makes a great OBS B call.

http://mlb.mlb.com/video/play.jsp?content_id=8725303

Posted

Great call, poor announcer (again).

Y'know, the more I watch these so-called "color" announcers butcher the rules, the more I like the idea of Fox/MLBChannel, etc., doing what the NFL does now: have an official sitting in a studio somewhere, to explain the rules after one of these calls. I would imagine the McCarvers and Harrelsons of the world wouldn't like it, because it would make them look like idiots. But, it would make us look better in the eyes of the fans.

Posted

bpate,

To further reinforce what other have already said, the following is an excerpt from the JEA discsuuion of Obstruction:

...Fielders may obstruct runners without actually touching them. For instance, an infielder who is not in the act of

fielding a thrown ball cannot stand in the runner's projected base path forcing him to "go around" the fielder to avoid

contact. This would be obstruction. ...

BTW, Dan Bellino is an "alum" of the association FVBump, FVB9, and I all belong to. We are all quite proud of him and happy for his success.

I've met him a couple of times (he probably wouldn't know me from Adam) and he's a great guy. Has regularly come back to help out with our pre-season clinics over the years, even though there's "nothing in it for him" other than helping out his fellow blues who are trying to get better.

JM

Posted

there is a team in my area that like to use their pitcher to back up the throw to first base well of course the pitcher has to run across the baseline in front of the batter/runner

just holding my breath and waiting to make that obstuction call

Posted

Just remember when you are judging obstruction, they have to actually obstruct to get a call. In other words the potential is there, you may even announce it but it may not produce an award.

Posted

Here's where it's a little cloudy for me. Take the same play as in the video except instead of R1 going from 1st to 3rd on a passed ball make it a basehit to F9 with the BR trying to go to 2B on the throw to third. What do you do with the call on the obstructed runner at 3B. Do you kill it on the play at 3B and judge where to place the BR or do you make the out call at 3B, let it play out at 2B and then go back and get the obstruction call at third ?

Posted

Here's where it's a little cloudy for me. Take the same play as in the video except instead of R1 going from 1st to 3rd on a passed ball make it a basehit to F9 with the BR trying to go to 2B on the throw to third. What do you do with the call on the obstructed runner at 3B. Do you kill it on the play at 3B and judge where to place the BR or do you make the out call at 3B, let it play out at 2B and then go back and get the obstruction call at third ?

It depends on your rule set. In FED, you wait until all playing action is complete and then you award bases. In LL, the rule on Type B OBS reads, "the play shall proceed until no further action is possible", but the RIM gives a casebook play where R1 is obstructed by the SS and then gets thrown out at 3rd (your exact play). They say call time as soon as the play at 3rd happens, irrespective of other potential plays. OBR does not comment specifically on this, so I'd be interested in an official interpretation, but it seems I've read the same thing for OBR in other discussions on this board.

Posted

Here's where it's a little cloudy for me. Take the same play as in the video except instead of R1 going from 1st to 3rd on a passed ball make it a basehit to F9 with the BR trying to go to 2B on the throw to third. What do you do with the call on the obstructed runner at 3B. Do you kill it on the play at 3B and judge where to place the BR or do you make the out call at 3B, let it play out at 2B and then go back and get the obstruction call at third ?

It depends on your rule set. In FED, you wait until all playing action is complete and then you award bases. In LL, the rule on Type B OBS reads, "the play shall proceed until no further action is possible", but the RIM gives a casebook play where R1 is obstructed by the SS and then gets thrown out at 3rd (your exact play). They say call time as soon as the play at 3rd happens, irrespective of other potential plays. OBR does not comment specifically on this, so I'd be interested in an official interpretation, but it seems I've read the same thing for OBR in other discussions on this board.

The LL ruling comes from the MLBUM which covers OBR.

On type b obstruction play conntinues until no action is possible OR the obstructed runner is called out.

Posted

So say thr BR was thrown out a 2B.

In Fed. Play ends with play at 2B, R1 is awarded 3B and out stands at 2B.

( Do you still make the out call at 3B here? )

In LL. The ball is dead with R1 being out at 3B but he is rewarded 3B due to obstruction and BR is probably sent back to1B but it will be a judgement call.

If R1 is safe at 3B, let the play continue and out stands at 2B.

Is this correct ?

Posted

So say thr BR was thrown out a 2B.

In Fed. Play ends with play at 2B, R1 is awarded 3B and out stands at 2B.

( Do you still make the out call at 3B here? )

In LL. The ball is dead with R1 being out at 3B but he is rewarded 3B due to obstruction and BR is probably sent back to1B but it will be a judgement call.

If R1 is safe at 3B, let the play continue and out stands at 2B.

Is this correct ?

FED: If you know your going to award the runner third then dont make the out call, make some call like "safe on obstruction". The out at second stands

OBR: I think an earlier post was wrong. You kill it as soon as the obstructed runner is played on, not whether or if hes put out. So the out at second never happens in OBR either way.

Posted

So say thr BR was thrown out a 2B.

In Fed. Play ends with play at 2B, R1 is awarded 3B and out stands at 2B.

( Do you still make the out call at 3B here? )

In LL. The ball is dead with R1 being out at 3B but he is rewarded 3B due to obstruction and BR is probably sent back to1B but it will be a judgement call.

If R1 is safe at 3B, let the play continue and out stands at 2B.

Is this correct ?

FED: If you know your going to award the runner third then dont make the out call, make some call like "safe on obstruction". The out at second stands

OBR: I think an earlier post was wrong. You kill it as soon as the obstructed runner is played on, not whether or if hes put out. So the out at second never happens in OBR either way.

In OBR/NCAA, you only kill it if the obstructed runner, being played on, would have been called out. If the obstructed runner is safe, you let the play continue.


×
×
  • Create New...