Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 3778 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I guess, maybe, that since he starts with his feet in a hybrid stance and it doesn't look like anyone's on base, it's like an allowed double pump or something? But I can't imagine he can do that with a runner on. Can he?

Posted

I would think with a runner on, one it could easily be a balk (?), however, his time to plate would be atrocious and steal city.

Posted

If he does this with a runner on, there doesn't seem to be any stop, I don't have a balk (something is moving throughout the motion), but like above a runners dream. Many of those guys have odd deliveries -

Posted
4 hours ago, maineump said:

If he does this with a runner on, there doesn't seem to be any stop, I don't have a balk (something is moving throughout the motion), but like above a runners dream. Many of those guys have odd deliveries -

That's a windup so he could do it with a runner on. I doubt his pitching coach wants him to windup like that with R3. Seems like begging for a steal or squeeze. He does have a fairly normal set delivery though and used it with R1 in that game.

Posted
17 minutes ago, Jimurray said:

That's a windup so he could do it with a runner on. I doubt his pitching coach wants him to windup like that with R3. Seems like begging for a steal or squeeze. He does have a fairly normal set delivery though and used it with R1 in that game.

just found a vid w/ runners on - like you said, normal set/stretch delivery

 

http://m.mlb.com/video/topic/26271672/v545737083/?query=john%2Bgant

Posted
2 hours ago, Jimurray said:

That's a windup so he could do it with a runner on. I doubt his pitching coach wants him to windup like that with R3. Seems like begging for a steal or squeeze. He does have a fairly normal set delivery though and used it with R1 in that game.

I totally agree, this is the hybrid wind-up. It is amazing what some of the guys come up with

Posted
1 hour ago, maineump said:

I totally agree, this is the hybrid wind-up. It is amazing what some of the guys come up with

I have a normal windup stance with a transition into a sideways stance. Some pitchers do this but a lot smother and continuously. I have TOP as first move from the normal foot position.

  • Like 1
Posted

He pitched in last night's game - we were there. It was his ML debut. As soon as I saw it, I commented on it. My son - also an umpire as well as former HS pitcher - was very intrigued. 

And yes, he did it with runners on base  

 

Posted
12 hours ago, Jimurray said:

I have a normal windup stance with a transition into a sideways stance. Some pitchers do this but a lot smother and continuously. I have TOP as first move from the normal foot position.

The video angle looks like his non-pivot foot is ahead of his pivot foot. But no matter,

Posted
9 hours ago, Umpirechick1 said:

He pitched in last night's game - we were there. It was his ML debut. As soon as I saw it, I commented on it. My son - also an umpire as well as former HS pitcher - was very intrigued. 

And yes, he did it with runners on base  

 

there's no way he did that with runners on ..........

Posted

@Thunderheads It goes along with everyone getting a trophy...... even the worst player on the worst team is special... a snowflake... the twinkle in Mommy & Daddy's eyes.

hugtoilet.jpg

 

  • Like 1
Posted
41 minutes ago, noumpere said:

That means nothing in OBR and NCAA rules.

I totally agree, but FED would have a bird. :) 

Posted
3 hours ago, Thunderheads said:

there's no way he did that with runners on ..........

Yes, he did. We watched the runner at 1st flinch the first time. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Umpirechick1 said:

Yes, he did. We watched the runner at 1st flinch the first time. 

then they must have called a start stop balk, because you can't do that ......

Posted
10 minutes ago, Thunderheads said:

then they must have called a start stop balk, because you can't do that ......

the right leg never stops moving, if one considers the "bounce" in that leg, so would that still apply?

Posted
1 hour ago, Umpirechick1 said:

Yes, he did. We watched the runner at 1st flinch the first time. 

He pitched from the set with R1, the only runner he had in the inning. He has a "normal" MLB stretch which has a slight stutter step. Certainly continuous motion to a stop.

If he wound up R1 would have been on 2B.

Posted
On 04/08/2016 at 10:00 PM, Umpirechick1 said:

He pitched in last night's game - we were there. It was his ML debut. As soon as I saw it, I commented on it. My son - also an umpire as well as former HS pitcher - was very intrigued. 

And yes, he did it with runners on base  

 

I watched him tonight.  He lifts the leg high while stretching into the set position. Then does the "toe tap" once or twice while his arms keep moving before he comes set.

×
×
  • Create New...