Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4119 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

http://m.mlb.com/video/v125416783/?query=bogaerts edited 10:23pm

Could interference be ignored on this because the ball didn't prevent a defensive player from being able to field it cleanly, since Rosales was pretty much at 2nd base? Or could it be that slowed the ball down, preventing the outfield from possible having a chance to throw him out at 3rd?

Edited by jpperez14
  • Replies 12
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Posted

I can't see the video. Link brings me to the U-E home page...Anyway, once a batted ball hits the runner in front of a fielder, it's a dead ball. There can be no further play. 

Posted

it is an interesting play in that it demonstrates the case play in the MLBUM that this is INT even though f4 was not in position to field the ball, the ball had not gone "through or by" an infielder, therefore, INT. 

Posted

Just to piggy back on this,,,,,Would this be "PLAY ON", no INT in FED if F3 was in on the grass? (String theory? )

Posted

interference pic.png

Based on F4's position, I would say no. To not get interference in a Fed game, fielders would have to be obviously in front of the runner. YMMV 

 

Posted

I agree with ricka -- INT in all codes, even if F3 is playing in.

 

And, it's very hard to see this as U2 / BU  when you are turning / etc.  Good job by the crew getting together.

Posted

did U2 miss that because of his initial turn?

​These are sneaky and can happened as you're stepping up to turn.  In the two man system, plate umpire needs to step up and do what he can on a play like this.

  • Like 1
Posted

​These are sneaky and can happened as you're stepping up to turn.  In the two man system, plate umpire needs to step up and do what he can on a play like this.

​looking again....it looks like it gets his cleat!

Posted

​These are sneaky and can happened as you're stepping up to turn.  In the two man system, plate umpire needs to step up and do what he can on a play like this.

​Doubtful: we'd be moving back to cover the steal of 2B, and might get a step forward when the ball was hit. This is a fluke play, and the crew is lucky there were 4 of them. A 2-umpire crew could easily miss this.

Watch the ball, glance at runners.

Posted (edited)

​Doubtful: we'd be moving back to cover the steal of 2B, and might get a step forward when the ball was hit. This is a fluke play, and the crew is lucky there were 4 of them. A 2-umpire crew could easily miss this.

Watch the ball, glance at runners.

​Doubtful?  Sure.  Possible?  Yes.

Edited by johnnyg08
×
×
  • Create New...