Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4138 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

No... not hands are part of the bat question.

 

OBR

 

3rd strike swinging and it's inside and hits the batter in the hands and rolls into fair territory.  Regardless as to where it rolls, it's a dead ball strike for an out? Or just a foul ball?  Rule?

Thanks

  • Replies 15
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

No... not hands are part of the bat question.

 

OBR

 

3rd strike swinging and it's inside and hits the batter in the hands and rolls into fair territory.  Regardless as to where it rolls, it's a dead ball strike for an out? Or just a foul ball?  Rule?

Thanks

 

Can't cite now, but ....see the bold

Posted

Strike on the swing.

 

Dead ball when it hits the batter (assuming it did not hit the bat first).

 

Where the dead ball goes is irrelevant.

 

If strike 3, the batter is out, and since the ball is dead, he may not advance to 1B (he's really out).

Posted

And when that does happen, and you have to call it as strike 3, be prepared for someone to come unglued. I actually had it happen last weekend in a 14u game it and wasn't pleasant - all because one or more on the field and in the stands has no clue.

Posted

Any part of the batters body that is hit in the strike zone is a dead ball strike. 2.0 6.0.5 f

 

It doesn't have to be in the strike zone if it is a swinging strike. 

Posted

This is REALLY a question?

 

Below HS baseball, I bet this (Along with several other situations) is a clusterf*ck. 

Posted

No... not hands are part of the bat question.

 

OBR

 

3rd strike swinging and it's inside and hits the batter in the hands and rolls into fair territory.  Regardless as to where it rolls, it's a dead ball strike for an out? Or just a foul ball?  Rule?

Thanks

I guess I was trying to get to the highlighted.  If you have the highlighted, you have a STRIKE, period.

Posted

This is REALLY a question?

Below HS baseball, I bet this (Along with several other situations) is a clusterf*ck.

It's definitely can be! I had a kid hit a ball of an evo shield wrist guard. Ball went all the way to the outfield. Kid takes off for first, I'm yelling "dead ball" with my hands up walking out in front of the plate. Kid got to third before coaches and the crowd even noticed I was making a call. That was definitely a clusterf***

Posted

 

 

This is REALLY a question?

Below HS baseball, I bet this (Along with several other situations) is a clusterf*ck.

 

It's definitely can be! I had a kid hit a ball of an evo shield wrist guard. Ball went all the way to the outfield. Kid takes off for first, I'm yelling "dead ball" with my hands up walking out in front of the plate. Kid got to third before coaches and the crowd even noticed I was making a call. That was definitely a clusterf***

 

 

Hint: Just call "time". 

  • Like 1
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

As a follow up (this happened over the weekend)... on a situation where you've got a swing and the ball hits the bat (you hear the ping of the bat) and the hands (batter is shaking his hands) you've just have to decide what got hit first?

Thanks

 

Posted

You're making this too complicated, @stl_ump. If it's a swing, and you're hearing the sound of ball-on-bat merge with ball-on-fleshy-human, then you may as well get a high-speed camera review of it for all the good it will do you. You've got a bat "ping" you say? And... where'd the ball go? Foul? Fair? Go with that. A batter is just as likely to be shaking their hands on a "buzzer" (the bat vibrates wildly) as they are a merged impact (ball on hands and bat simultaneously).

Again, this is when you have a swing.

Posted

You're making this too complicated, @stl_ump. If it's a swing, and you're hearing the sound of ball-on-bat merge with ball-on-fleshy-human, then you may as well get a high-speed camera review of it for all the good it will do you. You've got a bat "ping" you say? And... where'd the ball go? Foul? Fair? Go with that. A batter is just as likely to be shaking their hands on a "buzzer" (the bat vibrates wildly) as they are a merged impact (ball on hands and bat simultaneously).

Again, this is when you have a swing.

​OK... thanks.  I'll keep that in mind.

×
×
  • Create New...