Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4277 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Nice job Johnny. Definitely an exception to the general guidance Carl Childress gives in BRD about the throw needing to come from behind the runner. But, in this case it really looks to me like the BR interfered.

 

That, if anything, is what I'd go with here. It's ordinary runner INT, not RLI. The contact was right at the base, which ordinarily takes RLI off the table.

 

Since the enforcement is the same, and the call can be made by any umpire, are we sure the call on the field was RLI?

Posted

Good point.  I wasn't clear but I was thinking primarily plain ol' "I" not RLI.  Either way the result is the same.  It looked like RLI, because the camera shows the PU walking back to the plate area that he made the call but that is not known for sure.

 

It just happened to be potential RLI as well because it was a BR at 1B being hit by a throw but not clear.  The exception on BR being in fair territory for RLI to not apply is the last step though.  This BR was a no doubt all the way in fair, all the way to the bag.

 

@johnnyg08   Any thoughts?  Not that it would help but what did the audio say, if you bothered listening to it?

Posted

When running at full speed and the defensive player wants the space you're in, it is instinctive to raise an arm to lessen the collision and prevent injury. Dropping a shoulder to brace for contact is another self preservation technique often mistaken for MC in lower levels. .

 

I don't see any interference (RLI or otherwise)...shocked that it was called at this level.

Posted

Where was BR running?  Inside the line/not in the RL ALL the way to the bag.  Did he cause the throw to not be caught and/or prevent F3 from making a catch of the throw?  Yes.  

 

If he had been in the lane F3 could have caught that ball.  BR may have been safe as well as it was a long throw to make after a play at third.  I believe he wanted to be where he was and he paid the price.

Posted

Has anybody ever run in the lane when they hit the ball to the infield or bunt?  Especially a right-handed batter.

Posted

Has anybody ever run in the lane when they hit the ball to the infield or bunt?  Especially a right-handed batter.

RHBs almost never run in the RL on a batted ball. It's never an issue unless he interferes. But I think it is over-officious to call RLI on a throw from 3B. It is definitely not the expected call. When this kind of unexpected call is made, both coaches eye the umpire crew with suspicion. Games often turn into a crap fest after this kind of call is made.

×
×
  • Create New...