Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4057 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

It's all about what the moderators tolerate.  Just as in officiating, when you let something go without saying anything, you've now sanctioned it.  

I will say that I love U-E because it's very civil.  The moderators do a great job of shutting shenanigans down pretty quickly. 

  • Like 4
Posted

Speaking for Warren and the other moderators, Warren started the Umpire-Empire because of all the flaming and other rudeness on the other sites. I am proud to be a part of the site and grateful to Warren for asking me to join it. 

Are we perfect?  Far from it but we are committed to making it a positive experience and a good resource for umpires. That's why we're so aggressive with flaming and perceived bad behavior. 

  • Like 6
Posted

I enjoy being a member here, but those who think Officiating.com is full of flaming, I'm not sure what you're talking about. Have you been there in the last year or two? I adminster that forum along with 6 other members -- and while discussions sometimes get spirited, I will not hesitate to pull out a knife to excise nonsense.. I've also swung the ban hammer a few times for people who just can't help themselves,, despite past warnings. I'm here cause it's a great baseball forum, but if you work other sports, give us another try -- forum.officiating.com.

Posted

I went to officiating.com over the weekend and read a little bit in various forums (not all).  I didn't see any "assholes".  So, I'm wondering to whom some of the posts in this thread are referring?

 

I do see that it has a lot less "social" content than here -- and for me, that's a good thing. (I recognize that others have different opinions, and I appreciate that a lot of the social stuff is on specific forums I choose not to read here)

Posted

I enjoy being a member here, but those who think Officiating.com is full of flaming, I'm not sure what you're talking about. Have you been there in the last year or two? I adminster that forum along with 6 other members -- and while discussions sometimes get spirited, I will not hesitate to pull out a knife to excise nonsense.. I've also swung the ban hammer a few times for people who just can't help themselves,, despite past warnings. I'm here cause it's a great baseball forum, but if you work other sports, give us another try -- forum.officiating.com.

I would echo that, especially for basketball. It does come across at times as a closed, long-time-members-only club but i suppose any online community can at times.

Posted

@RichMSN @noumpere @scrounge

Thanks for the updates guys.  

Admittedly I have not been to them in at least a couple of years.  I do remember getting beat up pretty badly there at first which didn't bother me but made me wonder WTF! Why would fellow umpires be so rude to other umpires.  TimC sticks in my mind for some reason.  I eventually learned that this is just how some people are and shrugged it off.

 

Glad to hear it's not assholish (my made up word) anymore.

  • Like 2
Posted

TimC still posts very rarely...but I'll delete it if it's in bad form. As I will with anyone else who causes trouble. The guy that imitated me here and gave another poster a hard time tried to show his face there and I swung the ban hammer immediately.

Posted

Here's my two cents on internet forums in general regardless of the topic. 

They all ebb and flow in terms of the flaming, quality of content, membership etc...

As Dave mentioned I started this little experiment in 2008 and at that time I perceived the other sites as having a flaming problem. It appears the flaming has gone down from those points since then and as we all know we've had our issues here too. 

Moderating the sites is a fine line. You have your blatant flamers, spammers and trolls. Those are an easy call; gone. Then you have a mix of those who:

  • Possibly don't realize how their posts are received and their intent does not come through.
  • "Ask questions" -- but are not trolling, and are looking for a comment to latch on to and make into a bigger deal.
  • Very opinionated (imagine that) and and defend their opinion for better or worse to the death.
  • Have hot topic buttons and the very mention gets them pretty excited.
  • Are Know-it-all's,  their information is good, but that information can be either:
    • Not broken down to be easily digestible be the average reader 
    • Seen as condescending by other members
  • Personality conflicts. We're people we're predisposed to naturally bond with some people and not others.

These type situations can cause bigger issues on the forum and are tougher to moderate. My theory to handle these situations is to involve the offenders and directly tell them what the problem I am having is and what I expect. I will be there if they have questions I'll help, but I really hate banning those with these type of issues. When there is an issue I go back and look at all of that person's posts and try to determine what's going on. I'll give that person suggestions as to help themselves. 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Here's my two cents on internet forums in general regardless of the topic. 

They all ebb and flow in terms of the flaming, quality of content, membership etc...

As Dave mentioned I started this little experiment in 2008 and at that time I perceived the other sites as having a flaming problem. It appears the flaming has gone down from those points since then and as we all know we've had our issues here too. 

Moderating the sites is a fine line. You have your blatant flamers, spammers and trolls. Those are an easy call; gone. Then you have a mix of those who:

  • Possibly don't realize how their posts are received and their intent does not come through.
  • "Ask questions" -- but are not trolling, and are looking for a comment to latch on to and make into a bigger deal.
  • Very opinionated (imagine that) and and defend their opinion for better or worse to the death.
  • Have hot topic buttons and the very mention gets them pretty excited.
  • Are Know-it-all's,  their information is good, but that information can be either:
    • Not broken down to be easily digestible be the average reader 
    • Seen as condescending by other members
  • Personality conflicts. We're people we're predisposed to naturally bond with some people and not others.

These type situations can cause bigger issues on the forum and are tougher to moderate. My theory to handle these situations is to involve the offenders and directly tell them what the problem I am having is and what I expect. I will be there if they have questions I'll help, but I really hate banning those with these type of issues. When there is an issue I go back and look at all of that person's posts and try to determine what's going on. I'll give that person suggestions as to help themselves. 

 

great post Warren ...........and ............  I can't speak for everyone, but ........ moderating is not as easy as it may appear ......

Posted

This is a great site that Thunderheads and administrators should be proud of.

 

Posted

I went to officiating.com over the weekend and read a little bit in various forums (not all).  I didn't see any "assholes".  So, I'm wondering to whom some of the posts in this thread are referring?

It's a reputation they had for years.

It maybe be better now but people do not forget the past.

Posted

This is a great site that Thunderheads  Warren (Umpire in Chief) and administrators should be proud of.

 

fixed!! ....   thanks, but ....credit needs due where it needs due! :nod: 

  • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...