Jump to content
  • 0
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4230 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

Posted

With runner on 1st, batter hits a short fly ball to right field that lands in fair territory and bounces towards the right. The fielder catches the ball and falls out of play with the ball. At the time, the batter had already rounded first and the the runner had rounded second. I awarded home and third. Was I right?

6 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted

I can't find anything in OBR that covers this particular situation.  The one base award with a fielder falling out of play only applies to a catch which this isn't because the ball bounced. I would call this a deflection and award two bases from time of pitch.  Don't currently have my manual, can anyone cite an official interpretation to treat this more like a throw?

  • 0
Posted

This isn't a deflection where the fielder never had possession of the ball.  I would treat this like a ball thrown out of play.  2 bases TOT.  I think you got it right.

  • Like 1
  • 0
Posted

With runner on 1st, batter hits a short fly ball to right field that lands in fair territory and bounces towards the right. The fielder catches the ball and falls out of play with the ball. At the time, the batter had already rounded first and the the runner had rounded second. I awarded home and third. Was I right?

What rules code?

 

Anyway, I have this as carrying a batted ball OOP.  One base from the fall in NCAA and OBR..  One base from the carry in FED (and some local youth leagues add this and do not allow a fielder to carry a ball into DBT and throw -- they treat it as an automatic "fall")

  • 0
Posted

With runner on 1st, batter hits a short fly ball to right field that lands in fair territory and bounces towards the right. The fielder catches the ball and falls out of play with the ball. At the time, the batter had already rounded first and the the runner had rounded second. I awarded home and third. Was I right?

What rules code?

Anyway, I have this as carrying a batted ball OOP. One base from the fall in NCAA and OBR.. One base from the carry in FED (and some local youth leagues add this and do not allow a fielder to carry a ball into DBT and throw -- they treat it as an automatic "fall")

Can we define this as an 'unintentional catch and carry' in FED? There was no catch by def'n was there?

  • 0
Posted

 

 

With runner on 1st, batter hits a short fly ball to right field that lands in fair territory and bounces towards the right. The fielder catches the ball and falls out of play with the ball. At the time, the batter had already rounded first and the the runner had rounded second. I awarded home and third. Was I right?

What rules code?

Anyway, I have this as carrying a batted ball OOP. One base from the fall in NCAA and OBR.. One base from the carry in FED (and some local youth leagues add this and do not allow a fielder to carry a ball into DBT and throw -- they treat it as an automatic "fall")

 

Can we define this as an 'unintentional catch and carry' in FED? There was no catch by def'n was there?

 

 

You are correct.  You have to have a catch to have catch and carry.  The OP is not a catch.

  • 0
Posted

With runner on 1st, batter hits a short fly ball to right field that lands in fair territory and bounces towards the right. The fielder catches the ball and falls out of play with the ball. At the time, the batter had already rounded first and the the runner had rounded second. I awarded home and third. Was I right?

What rules code?

Anyway, I have this as carrying a batted ball OOP. One base from the fall in NCAA and OBR.. One base from the carry in FED (and some local youth leagues add this and do not allow a fielder to carry a ball into DBT and throw -- they treat it as an automatic "fall") Can we define this as an 'unintentional catch and carry' in FED? There was no catch by def'n was there?

Not a catch.

×
×
  • Create New...