Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 5197 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

RHP from the stretch starts with his pivot foot (right) touching the side of the rubber.

So the front of his foot (toes) was pressed up against the short side of the rubber that faces 1B. He is "in contact" with the rubber, correct?

Posted

Was his foot intentionally touching the rubber?

If by "intentionally" you mean did he intend to put his foot there (vs accidently just standing there not realizing where his foot was)...the answer is yes

He did that every pitch

Posted

I asked that for the sake of the on or astride balk argument. So the toes of his pivot foot were all that ever touched rubber?

Posted

RHP from the stretch starts with his pivot foot (right) touching the side of the rubber.

So the front of his foot (toes) was pressed up against the short side of the rubber that faces 1B. He is "in contact" with the rubber, correct?

In OBR, this is a legal pitching position, provided his free foot is in front of the rubber. In Fed, this is NOT a legal pitching position. His pivot foot must be completely within the edges of the rubber.

Posted

In OBR, this is a legal pitching position, provided his free foot is in front of the rubber.

My situation is OBR, but his free foot was not in front of the rubber, it was beside his pivot foot, so I guess that was not legal then.

Posted

In OBR, this is a legal pitching position, provided his free foot is in front of the rubber.

My situation is OBR, but his free foot was not in front of the rubber, it was beside his pivot foot, so I guess that was not legal then.

Hard to imagine how his free foot wasn't in front of the rubber. If you were to extend the ends of the rubber towards first and third respectively, would his free foot have been in front of the rubber? If so, then it's legal.

Posted

In OBR, this is a legal pitching position, provided his free foot is in front of the rubber.

My situation is OBR, but his free foot was not in front of the rubber, it was beside his pivot foot, so I guess that was not legal then.

Hard to imagine how his free foot wasn't in front of the rubber. If you were to extend the ends of the rubber towards first and third respectively, would his free foot have been in front of the rubber? If so, then it's legal.

Oh yes by that explanation then his free foot was in front of the rubber, I thought when when you said "in front of the rubber" I thought you meant directly in front of the 24" length of the rubber

Posted

The rule is kinda sketchy...

6-1-3 "For the set position........... He shal stand with his entire non-pivot foot in front of a line extending through the front edge of the pitcher's plate and with his entire pivot foot in contact with, or directly in front of the pitcher's plate."

So for Fed, the OP is illegal. Here's the sketchy part. Same paragraph:

".......or he may lift his pivot foot in a step backward off the pitcher's plate which must be in or partially within th 24-inch length of the pitcher's plate."

So must the whole pivot foot be in contact or directly in front of the rubber, or is partially in contact or in front of enough?

To answer the balk question, it's nothing until TOP. Once he commits:

"PENALTY (Art. 1,2,3): the ball is dead immediately when an illegal pitch occurs. If there is no runner, a ball is awarded the batter. If there is a runner, such illegal act is a balk. In both situations, the umpire signals dead ball."

Posted

The rule is kinda sketchy...

6-1-3 "For the set position........... He shal stand with his entire non-pivot foot in front of a line extending through the front edge of the pitcher's plate and with his entire pivot foot in contact with, or directly in front of the pitcher's plate."

So for Fed, the OP is illegal. Here's the sketchy part. Same paragraph:

".......or he may lift his pivot foot in a step backward off the pitcher's plate which must be in or partially within th 24-inch length of the pitcher's plate."

So must the whole pivot foot be in contact or directly in front of the rubber, or is partially in contact or in front of enough?

To answer the balk question, it's nothing until TOP. Once he commits:

"PENALTY (Art. 1,2,3): the ball is dead immediately when an illegal pitch occurs. If there is no runner, a ball is awarded the batter. If there is a runner, such illegal act is a balk. In both situations, the umpire signals dead ball."

In FED by rule the entire foot must be within the edges of the rubber when the pitcher is engaged, but in practice this is often relaxed a bit.

When the pitcher disengages it's then that only part of the foot need be within the edges of the plate, and again this is often relaxed in practice as long as it doesnt look like a step toward first or third with the pivot foot.

And its a balk as soon as he intentionally engages the rubber on the end and begins to act like a pitcher -- by taking signs or coming set etc.

And I think the rule is generally the same at all levels so I am surprised to see the wording above that its okay in Pro ball but I dont have my references handy to check.

Posted

Hang on. I am missing the part of the FED rule that says F1 must have his in-contact foot entirely within the 24" length of the pitchers plate.

I understand that the OP is illegal in FED, however I envision this:

Foot+in+front+of+rubber.JPG

as legal in FED as well.

What did I miss?

Thanks!

Posted

Hang on. I am missing the part of the FED rule that says F1 must have his in-contact foot entirely within the 24" length of the pitchers plate.

I understand that the OP is illegal in FED, however I envision this:

Foot+in+front+of+rubber.JPG

as legal in FED as well.

What did I miss?

Thanks!

Steve, that is NOT legal in Fed. Looking at that picture, is his "entire pivot foot in contact with, or directly in front of the pitcher's plate"? No, so it's not a legal pitching position in Fed. As noumpere said, we are very relaxed about enforcing this. This is one reason why a dirty pitcher's plate is a must-have.

Posted

6-1-3

. . .

Before starting his delivery, he shall stand with his entire non-pivot foot in front of a line extending through the front edge of the pitcher’s plate

and with his entire pivot foot in contact with or directly in front of the pitcher’s

plate.

. . .

Got it. Seemed to contradict itself when I read the rule the first 100 times.

Thanks

Posted

RHP from the stretch starts with his pivot foot (right) touching the side of the rubber.

So the front of his foot (toes) was pressed up against the short side of the rubber that faces 1B. He is "in contact" with the rubber, correct?

In OBR, this is a legal pitching position, provided his free foot is in front of the rubber. In Fed, this is NOT a legal pitching position. His pivot foot must be completely within the edges of the rubber.

As far as FED how many of you enforce this rule?

I just finished my sexing year of HS and been trying to learn from veterans but have never seen it called.

Posted

RHP from the stretch starts with his pivot foot (right) touching the side of the rubber.

So the front of his foot (toes) was pressed up against the short side of the rubber that faces 1B. He is "in contact" with the rubber, correct?

In OBR, this is a legal pitching position, provided his free foot is in front of the rubber. In Fed, this is NOT a legal pitching position. His pivot foot must be completely within the edges of the rubber.

my sexing year

??????????
Posted

Thanks, Salami. I loaned out my OBR and haven't gotten it back yet.

Posted

RHP from the stretch starts with his pivot foot (right) touching the side of the rubber.

So the front of his foot (toes) was pressed up against the short side of the rubber that faces 1B. He is "in contact" with the rubber, correct?

In OBR, this is a legal pitching position, provided his free foot is in front of the rubber. In Fed, this is NOT a legal pitching position. His pivot foot must be completely within the edges of the rubber.

my sexing year

??????????

Stupid iPhone!

Second year.

×
×
  • Create New...