Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 5287 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

2 Situations, looking for input. (OBR Please)

1. Batter hits ball to fence and is looking for a double. F3 stands on TOP of 1st base and obstructs the runner. DDB obstruction is signaled. Runner, because of the obstruction misses first and continues to 2nd where he is safe without a play. Question: Does the runner still have to touch 1st base if in the mind of the umpire, the miss was caused by the obstruction? -- 1st base can be a little different by rule.

2. Similar situation but occurs at 2nd instead of 1st. (miss 2nd due to obstruction) Same question.

The umpire shall then call “Time†and impose such

penalties, if any, as in his judgment will nullify the act of obstruction.

  • Replies 13
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

bpate;

I'm going to take a quick stab at this! :D

No, in both. He missed due to the OBS (in you judgement). So, even if the defense appeals, it's moot.

Stay tuned for others because I VERY WELL may be wrong ;)

Posted

Bam-

"The umpire shall then call “Time†and impose such

penalties, if any, as in his judgment will nullify the act of obstruction."

IMO, the act of obstruction caused the miss of the base, am I not suppose to nullify the act of obstruction by ignoring the miss?

Posted

I would add that the runner has to make an attempt to touch the base. If he sees the base obstructed and veers off his basepath several feet I would not protect him from an appeal.

Having said that, since he did not legally touch the base, now to which base are you protecting? Are you assuming the touch and protecting to the next base?

And further, this would differ by ruleset.

Posted

bpate;

I'm going to take a quick stab at this! :D

No, in both. He missed due to the OBS (in you judgement). So, even if the defense appeals, it's moot.

Stay tuned for others because I VERY WELL may be wrong ;)

Your right as you should be on this becuase this question seems to get asked a lot and a lot more than I would of expected since Ive never seen this play happen.

Posted

For clarification, the runner was attempting to touch 1st. The collision caused him to step over first.

Saw this play happen last night so it does happen from time to time.

Posted

The runner still must run the bases correctly, OBS or no OBS.

So all F3 has to do is lie on first base and voila - no one can ever get past first base because they can't touch it. And once F3 gets the ball it's no longer obstruction so just tag the sucker or appeal the miss.

Brilliant!

Posted

I would add that the runner has to make an attempt to touch the base. If he sees the base obstructed and veers off his basepath several feet I would not protect him from an appeal.

Having said that, since he did not legally touch the base, now to which base are you protecting? Are you assuming the touch and protecting to the next base?

And further, this would differ by ruleset.

If the obstruction prevents the touch it can get ignored. Period. No additional woulda shouldas.

You can protect him to whatever base you think he would reach without the obstruction. In FED it's a MINIMUM of one base. In OBR it's to wherever - including no advance base.

Posted

The runner still must run the bases correctly, OBS or no OBS.

So all F3 has to do is lie on first base and voila - no one can ever get past first base because they can't touch it. And once F3 gets the ball it's no longer obstruction so just tag the sucker or appeal the miss.

Brilliant!

LOL-- I'm gonna start teaching this 12U.

×
×
  • Create New...