Jump to content
  • 0

Runner interference


Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 3176 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

Guest Scott
Posted

We had a situation where there were runners on 3rd and 2nd base, ball hit up the middle.  The shortstop started to react to the ball and was run over by the girl going 2nd to 3rd.  Interference was called and runner ruled out. 

1 team argued the runner is entitled to the base line while the other argued the fielder has to be given the opportunity to make a play on the ball.  Was the right call made or should the runner been allowed to advance if it were ruled the fielder was in the baseline while attempting to field the ball?

9 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 1
Posted

Your reference to "the girl going 2nd to 3rd" suggests (but doesn't guarantee) softball. If so, and if the softball rule is the same as baseball, the fielder who is in the best position to field a batted ball has absolute right of way. If that was the ruling, it was correctly called INT: the ball is dead, the interfering runner is out, other runners return to their last base, and the BR is awarded 1B (other runners advance if forced).

That said, it is also relevant that only ONE fielder may be protected (from liability for OBS, since ordinarily the runner does have right of way). On a ball hit up the middle, the umpire must judge who has a better chance to play on the ball, F6 or F4, and protect that fielder. In this play, if the ball was hit to the right side, where F4 would have a clearly better play, then F6 would not be protected, and we would have OBS and not INT. I would rule this way only where F4's play on the ball was clearly better than F6's (and maybe F4 fielded the ball). Otherwise, it defeats the purpose of the rule to ignore it on plays where F6 and F4 have about equally good plays.

  • 0
Posted

I would add that one thing to consider is if the ball had passed the fielder, if so, the right to field the ball is no longer valid and OBS should be called.

  • 0
Posted

I'll throw one more out at ya...

Here's one I've had happen a few times on the softball field. Runner on second base. Batter hits line drive over the pitcher's head, straight up the middle. Runner is heading to third.

Generally, in softball the infielders will be playing fairly shallow. The runner will often be running behind the fielder, which means that the fielder won't really see the runner or have any idea where she is.

F6 turns and takes about one step in the general direction of the ball, and right into the runner's path. BAM! Big collision!

The defensive coach will always argue for an interference call. But that only applies if the fielder was in the act of fielding the batted ball. With this being a line drive, at the instant the players collided the ball was about eight feet off the ground, just about over second base, and leaving the infield. In short, there was NO WAY that F6 was going to get this ball, or even get close to it for that matter.

Umpire judgment here...but simply moving toward the batted ball is NOT the same thing as fielding the batted ball. If you judge that F6 was not in the act of fielding the ball, then this becomes obstruction.

And be prepared for some blow back from the defensive coach!

  • Like 1
  • 0
Posted
42 minutes ago, BretMan said:

The defensive coach will always argue for an interference call. But that only applies if the fielder was in the act of fielding the batted ball. With this being a line drive, at the instant the players collided the ball was about eight feet off the ground, just about over second base, and leaving the infield. In short, there was NO WAY that F6 was going to get this ball, or even get close to it for that matter.

Umpire judgment here...but simply moving toward the batted ball is NOT the same thing as fielding the batted ball. If you judge that F6 was not in the act of fielding the ball, then this becomes obstruction.

And be prepared for some blow back from the defensive coach!

Is that the softball wording?  I ask because it is NOT the baseball wording.  In baseball, it needs to be the protected fielder, but he does not need to be "in the act of fielding."  I agree that in the play you discuss (infield in; line drive over second) that F6 is not the protected fielder and the contact is OBS.

  • 0
Posted
47 minutes ago, noumpere said:

Is that the softball wording?  I ask because it is NOT the baseball wording.  In baseball, it needs to be the protected fielder, but he does not need to be "in the act of fielding."  I agree that in the play you discuss (infield in; line drive over second) that F6 is not the protected fielder and the contact is OBS.

 

4 hours ago, maven said:

If so, and if the softball rule is the same as baseball

Softball uses the same language as OBR  " attempting to field a batted ball,":

The only difference is OBR puts in specific language that only one fielder can be protected by this rule at a time.  Softball doesn't have that specific language but I believe that is how umpires are instructed.

In either case, in laymen's terms, "the act of fielding a batted ball" may be considered synonymous to some as "attempting to field a batted ball". 

  • 0
Posted
10 minutes ago, beerguy55 said:

In either case, in laymen's terms, "the act of fielding a batted ball" may be considered synonymous to some as "attempting to field a batted ball". 

We're not laymen, we're umpires, and the wording matters. These concepts are distinct and the terms are not synonymous.

The act of fielding the ball is a success term: the fielder is (successfully) fielding a batted ball. (Whether the fielder succeeds in securing the ball is another matter, about the outcome not the activity).

"Attempting to field a batted ball" is not a success term: a fielder could have lost the ball in the sun, or stumbled and fallen, or otherwise be doing something other than actually fielding the ball, and still be attempting to do that.

The latter kind of fielder is still protected. I don't know whether this distinction is precisely what noumpere had in mind by mentioning it.

  • 0
Posted
26 minutes ago, maven said:

We're not laymen

No, but the rest of the world is, and when you're on the field, everyone else except for your partner is likely a layman.

My comment was simply meant to convey that some of your audience may see them as synonymous, not that they are.

  • 0
Posted
17 hours ago, beerguy55 said:

No, but the rest of the world is, and when you're on the field, everyone else except for your partner is likely a layman.

My comment was simply meant to convey that some of your audience may see them as synonymous, not that they are.

I agree that everyone else is (likely) a layman.  That doesn't mean we shouldn't use the correct terms -- when we misspeak on the field, the terms get mis-interpreted and applied in situaions where they shouldn't -- and then the coach is confused because the situation perfectly fits the mis-used term.

  • Like 1
  • 0
Posted

NFHS softball calls it "making the initial play on a batted ball".

USA softball uses the term "in the act of fielding a batted ball".

×
×
  • Create New...