Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4183 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Had a Freshman pitcher tonight who would be in the windup and his first movement was his PIVOT foot to the front of the rubber parallel....for the push off.

I asked the coach if he planned to fix it and he questioned whether it was a balk.   I thought it was, per FED rule 6-2, the last sentence:

"During delivery, he may lift his non-pivot foot in a step...........but he shall not otherwise lift either foot."

I've never seen anything like this.  What's the correct interp?

Posted

I'm pretty sure it's illegal.  If he was pitching from the wind up, were there runners on?  If not, call time and award the batter a ball.

 

Posted

What makes this illegal?

​Lifting the pivot foot.  My understanding of the rule is that a pitcher may only lift his non-pivot foot, and as it states, "he shall not otherwise lift either foot."

Posted

You might be OOO'ing this. The pivot foot has to move sometime in the delivery right? From what you say he is not stepping forward and replanting the pivot foot in front of the rubber (i.e. out of the hole in front of it) he is sliding it into the spot he needs to push off from. It is a screwy move, but I don't believe its illegal. when he is a Sophomore somebody will fix his delivery I hope.

Posted

Because of the condition of some pitching mound/rubber, you have to give F1's some latitude to position/reposition the pivot foot to safely deliver a pitch FOR A STRIKE.

Posted

I'm pretty sure it's illegal.  If he was pitching from the wind up, were there runners on?  If not, call time and award the batter a ball.

 

​99% of the pitchers lift the pivot foot to reposition it.  They (typically) step back or to the side with the non-pivot, put their weight on the non-pivot, lift and turn the pivot foot, put there weight on the pivot foot, then lift the non-pivot and stride to the plate.

 

In the OP, as I read it, the pitcher is doing all of that except the first.  He's just shifting his weight to the non-pivot without a step.

 

Legal. (or, at least, universally ignored without exception)

  • Like 1
Posted

If he's raising it a centimeter in order to pivot.....well, he didn't raise it. I can't imagine traveling over a mile of dollar bills to pick up that penny. Now, if he raises it above his ankle or tries to pull a sneaky boy and step forward a good bit, sure...but I've never seen it and I sure wouldn't nitpick it. No need to be a Philistine over this one.

Posted

I should add to my reply above that, iirc, the restriction was put in to prevent pitchers from "running in to the pitch".  They used to pitch from a "pitcher's box" and could move forward.  then, when they added the rubber, some would stand behind the rubber and get a "running start" to put the pivot foot on the rubber and then step with the other foot to pitch (think of the restriction on a base runner tagging up -- it's similar).  If the pitcher isn't doing that, let it go.

Posted

Thanks guys.  I thought I might be knit-picking this.   It just looked SOOOO awkward and unorthodox. 

So here's how the delivery went from the windup, do this in your living room and you'll see what I'm saying......pivot foot moves parallel to the rubber, non-pivot takes a step to the side, then that same foot/knee gets raised and extended to home for the delivery.  wacky.

Posted

Well stop the raveling and ties the ends up! Stitch again!

Posted

 ​​I acknowledge the total hijack and willingly promote its tangent....... cleave means to cling to and to separate. Therefore, if one cleaves to their misunderstanding of the rules they may be cleaved from higher level assignments.   

×
×
  • Create New...