dumbdumb
Established Member-
Posts
3,529 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
29
Everything posted by dumbdumb
-
per mlbu media guide umpires for WC and DS are to be notified 1 week before the last game of the regular season which it looks like is Sunday the 28th. so, that means all the DS guys that are notified Sunday know they are in the hunt for a WS. The WC guys know the are in the hunt for a LCS. now, does someone get the WS on their first try in the WC or DS? usually there is a build from WC or DS to LCS and then WS per what the past records show. and being in replay counts. hopefully nobody has one of those negative thingamabobits or what some call a clostraduck during this last weekend that riles the world of baseball up, (but that clostra could also be a positive) and also that nobody who is really in the hunt, gets dinged in the mask, and has to go on concussion protocol for 15 days with just pure bad luck timing. believe that has happened before. good luck to all.
-
The night my eyes were blessed...a true official's story
dumbdumb replied to SeeingEyeDog's topic in Free For All
from watching sports at the local high school every once in a while and some free reading and listening to moms who use to play make comments, i would say there is much less animosity/adversarialistness/ attitude towards officials in volleyball (and there is only womens volleyball in my area), swimming and even though i have not been in a long time, track & field. and you do not have to worry about getting out so quick in your career with mobility issues or injury issues. in volleyball, if you can learn what the libero can and cannot do and a few illegal positioning/screens/setups/ by the defense prior to the serve and dont call the ponytail touching the net a net violation, and make sure a backline player stays behind the line if spiking a ball 'above the net', you can go a long way..of course handling the ball violations is another area just like palming in hoops. and yes, there is much more to it than that, but if you learned baseball you can learn the others. i think yawtag on here a while ago went the volleyball route and i would hope is doing well. in swimming, if you do stroke and turn(legal/illegal for both), and can figure out what a badly performed legal stroke is from a well performed illegal stroke (benefit of doubt goes to the swimmer), you can work a lot there as well, as well as know all the rules and be a starter, making sure your cadence can't be taken advantage of, and checking for leaving to soon (like tag up in baseball and leaning with the body before the foot leaves the blocks does not count as leaving too soon, only when foot is off too soon is there a penalty) on relays (foot off the blocks before swimmer in water touches wall/pad). and track would seem to be a lot like swimming, but would have its nuances also. volleyball and swimming are all indoors, no protective clothing needed and of course there are travel ball like teams in each sport. and should you want to try for the most dinero, there are d1,2,3 opportunities for each as well as olympic opportunities in both mens and womens. ps- good luck with water polo, have never even come close to figuring that one out. where is johnny weissmuller when you need him, but it is an indoor sport, ie no rainouts. added- gonna need more officials due to growth for high school boys playing teams now. https://www.usatoday.com/story/life/health-wellness/2025/09/08/is-volleyball-good-for-you/85986035007/?tbref=hp -
and an old article mentioning former age restrictions on officials. cuzzi's last ejection had a comment in ccs about a 70 year old umpire making an ejection. not that there could not be others out there but Cuzzi seems to be the first MLBU (August 29, 1955), to work an on the field regular season game at 70 (will there be a year end special event or not--even if no WS, maybe an LCS, DCS, or Wild Card, and the two nfl guys mentioned in the below article and former NBA Dick Bavetta, and Jack Nies. some guys did not get a long career since they went up so late. and of course the Ben Dreith case (another guy taking it in the shorts after filing the lawsuit which help others out but not Ben). things started changing just not for the one who sues. hmmm isn't that just like Curt Flood. others after him received the advantages but not Curt. oh well, time marches on. https://www.footballzebras.com/2021/11/tony-corrente-turns-70-a-rare-milestone-for-an-active-official/
-
will speculate on this one-- maybe all the vacations might be done and the regulars would be back for the home stretch so to speak or in replay, and graduations, etc and summer vacation for their personal week would be over. and make sure those in consideration for playoffs are working. good time to bring up some that are being up for the first time to get some games, especially if they are moving some rovers around for teams that are still in the hunt or positioning for playoffs, and let some of the young ones get less pressure games with teams out of the hunt. same things as amateur player assignors would probably do.
-
maybe this league will have a casebook of demonstrations for the situation in the ccs area concerning the runner being hit in the llws topic. https://www.womensprobaseballleague.com/
-
https://www.mlb.com/news/how-the-mlb-call-up-umpire-list-works?msockid=1b06be4519d8678c3767a81618256671
-
thanks to all of you
-
Pawol to make history as MLB's first female umpire
dumbdumb replied to Velho's topic in Professional
segunda base - pittsburgh - LAA - Colorado -
Pawol to make history as MLB's first female umpire
dumbdumb replied to Velho's topic in Professional
well, she did better than 3 others that day (10th), although all of them were in the 92 with a decimal after, and she did better than 4 yesterday (11th), including 2 that had scores of 89.02 and 88 respectively. but as time goes on, she should have some higher scores and lower scores than her opening score, just like everyone else. -
Pawol to make history as MLB's first female umpire
dumbdumb replied to Velho's topic in Professional
here we go umpstu- as beerguy55 said they are "jills" or pelvic protectors. 2 kinds i found are below. https://www.purehockey.com/product/bauer-jill-pelvic-protector-womens/itm/15499-44/ https://hockey.elitesportsgroup.com/en/pro-jill-pelvic-protector/ nothing with you u.s. just a chance 2 mention ncaa has done a horrible job of recruiting women just like mlb, nfl, and nba until recently, (and no hiring violet palmer and dee kantner in 1997 with kantner getting fired)and then no one else for 17 years till lauren holtcamp in 2014 doesnt count ) and ncaa is now way behind. i never see super 5 Conference having any women on weekend games, on bases, much less the plate. dont even see them on non con either and there are tons more teams than mlb. now if they have turned mens down when asked all the time to work softball, thats fine as long as they are being asked to give baseball a try. and on pairity if they are doing softball. baseball is giving $100 per inning or $900 per game. is softball giving $100 per inning and $700 per game. and in baseball with 4 man 1 guy doesnt even work the plate on weekends so he is just being paid to be a base umpire. seems like some women could be hired to just be base umps, 3rd to second to first on weekends like the men do. and this goes for super Conference basketball and football. -
Pawol to make history as MLB's first female umpire
dumbdumb replied to Velho's topic in Professional
serious answer: tell me all the names of the ones in the power 5 Conference game weekend list and i will go ask them when they work a game in my area. -
Pawol to make history as MLB's first female umpire
dumbdumb replied to Velho's topic in Professional
and for the critics that will come out, here are some of the individual umpiring statistics for full time staff or call up staff, with the lowest 20 scores so far this year for an umpire working the plate and the highest 20 scores for an umpire working the plate so far this year. courtesy of umpscorecards. 82.31, 86.67, 86.99, 87.23, 87.36, 87.42, 87.59, 87.71, 87.84, 88.02, 88.07, 88.17, 88.19, 88.24, 88.29, 88.31, 88.33, 88.36, 88.41, 88.49. 100, 100, 99.45, 99.39, 99.28, 99.22, 99.21, 99.21, 99.19, 99.19, 99.16, 99.12, 98.85, 98.81, 98.71, 98.62, 98.61, 98.58, 98.56, 98.56. -
just for you - enjoy
-
Jeff Gosney - New National Coordinator of Umpires
dumbdumb replied to johnnyg08's topic in Collegiate
who was the former ACC supervisor to start with. scratching my head on that one, as to the leaving part. -
Pawol to make history as MLB's first female umpire
dumbdumb replied to Velho's topic in Professional
congrats for you gear people - a picture with a mask, sunglasses, scully/helmet/whatchamacallit, no hat. https://fansided.com/mlb/everything-fans-need-to-know-about-jen-pawol-mlb-s-first-woman-umpire old article https://apnews.com/article/woman-umpire-jen-pawol-1afd32aa83b5d2c074489993cd9c2adf -
are we sure there is not some solution that either someone on here, or out there (wherever there is) keeps to themselves and just laughs at us, rather than sharing. can we take the problem to Oz and see the wizard (and no not ozzie smith).
-
formerly mentioned west scared to death--and was he so off in his being scared statement. olde ccs article below, and then recent article in deadspin. https://www.closecallsports.com/2018/05/gambling-ban-reversal-has-joe-west.html https://deadspin.com/mlbs-gambling-crisis-is-an-existential-threat-and-rob-manfred-isnt-taking-it-seriously/
- 1 reply
-
- 1
-
-
pretty much (not saying one was missed) in more recent times no umpire working 140 or more games in a season has not been hired at some point, ie tomlinson during 2024 after a 140 + season. and of the 2 you mentioned with hanahan looking like being more of the phenom, who have also been up all year, it would be just a matter of time hopefully, although there are no guarantees on anything. it is not where you start but where you finish that counts. and dont forget mr knight started as a callup in 2001 and 675 games later in 2011 went full tlme after having a 150 game call up season in 2009. and checking opening day march 27 in washington and marquez with the only TBA for a 4th crew member showing on the early preseason crew charts, and it ending up being Ramos, was that a prelude/planned/tell sign (james bond)? to what 'might' be going to happen later this season. only the shadow knows.
-
now you are getting into a specific area that could be like the discussion going on about 'how did we get here' in mechanics section, but specifically on the who, what, when, where why of ejection competence. maybe the umpire would have, but there is a 'keep them in the game' undercurrent/underpinning to all level of sports now, where the tie goes to the (player, and on up the heirarchy AC, HC/manager) with issues of deportment, compared to the bad old days of egotistical, headline seeking, force yourself into the game umpire. the game is not about you the umpire, it is about everyone else on the field. once again, there is an inflection point in all deportment--visual/showing you up, verbal (personal profanity), and time (length of argument) limits in which for better or worse, you just have to umpire, when a casebook play just cannot be written up or the casebook would be so big/voluminous (is that a word?), you could never get out of the classroom and onto the field to even play or umpire an athletic event, because you are playing, 'but what if' all your life.
-
1-by the MLB rule and interpretations 2-by NCAA rule and interpretations 3-former/present umpires that were catchers and well known for their hitting exploits please respond 4-former/present umpires that were pitchers and well known for both their pitching exploits and pitching and hitting exploits please respond. and remember, no matter how great the words-smiths and linguistics and lawyer umpires on this sight could write up a perfectly definitive rule, at some point, no matter the definitive definition, there is an inflection point in every call made that, you just have to umpire. and the umpire did not did not eject a first time to the rodeo player by a long shot. https://www.espn.com/watch/player?id=45882802
-
https://www.mlb.com/press-release/press-release-charlie-ramos-promoted-to-major-league-staff
-
just remember, at lower levels with amateur players, these player/coach/manager personnel with parents and fans confrontations, and spewing their venom, is losing potential umpires who might would try to become future MLB umpires, and maybe be top notch, 95% or higher (and yes i know, anything below 100% perfect you should just be fired, like all the other 350 million people out there that are all 100% perfect at their jobs and never make a mistake or they immediately get fired), ratings on both base judgments and plate judgments even without ABS and replay, but we will never know since they walk away early.
-
remember all those articles of umpires should be sent down, or my favorite ' fans call for umpires dismissal/firing pretty much several times a week. what's good for the goose is good for the gander. let's see the punishment, fine, suspension, sent down to MiLB for announcing retraining, or do they handle it behind closed doors, that everyone tends to hate rather than publicly announcing the punishment or non punishment. https://www.si.com/mlb/athletics-announcer-responds-after-brutally-botching-home-run-call-he-thought-was-foul
