Jump to content
  • 0

Exception Case Play to 6.03(a)1


Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 1632 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

Posted

I remember seeing this come up on a previous thread, but can't find it again. U3K, with the ball deflected onto the plate. RH BR and F2 get tangled for a moment.

6.03(a)1 by normal reading shows this as interference, but there was a case okay quoted in a previous thread from IIRC the 75 World Series, with Fisk behind the plate? The result was a nothing-to-call.

Additionally, there was a two word term given for it I think, but I can't remember it.

 

Can anyone help?  Got a feeling a coach from yesterday is going to make a deal of it today.

8 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted
4 minutes ago, ErichKeane said:

I remember seeing this come up on a previous thread, but can't find it again. U3K, with the ball deflected onto the plate. RH BR and F2 get tangled for a moment.

6.03(a)1 by normal reading shows this as interference, but there was a case okay quoted in a previous thread from IIRC the 75 World Series, with Fisk behind the plate? The result was a nothing-to-call.

Additionally, there was a two word term given for it I think, but I can't remember it.

 

Can anyone help?  Got a feeling a coach from yesterday is going to make a deal of it today.

Tangle/Untangle?

  • Thanks 1
  • 0
Posted
1 minute ago, Tborze said:

Tangle/Untangle?

Yeah looks like that is it! Thanks for the help! I can now Google/get the right reading for this.

  • 0
Posted
13 minutes ago, ErichKeane said:

Yeah looks like that is it! Thanks for the help! I can now Google/get the right reading for this.

You should know that the rule on D3K has changed since then.  It's more likely to be INT now.

 

And, the interp is different in different codes.

  • Thanks 1
  • 0
Posted
9 minutes ago, noumpere said:

You should know that the rule on D3K has changed since then.  It's more likely to be INT now.

 

And, the interp is different in different codes.

Oh? Tangle/untangle doesn't apply to U3k anymore?

We are OBR in this tournament, so that interp is most important right now (though I do a lot of FED, so I should clarify that too...).

  • 0
Posted

I believe the rule now has more liability on the BR. If he delays in his advance it is more likely INT. 

 

  • Thanks 1
  • 0
Posted

The tangle/untangle concept applies on a batted ball. There is a separate rule for uncaught strike three interference—rule 6.01(a)(1) and its following Comment. What Mr. noumpere alluded to was the fact that the rule was amended in 2013 (at the time it was rule 7.09a).

From the 2013 Wendelstedt manual (section 9.3.4, p. 178):

When the batter-runner contacts an uncaught third strike, or hinders the catcher in his attempt to field the ball, the umpire will wait to see whether it has an interfering effect on the play. If the play is clearly interfered with, the umpire will call and signal interference and then call time. He will call out the batter-runner and return all other runners to their original bases.

If the ball is barely affected, there may be no interference, however, if the ball is knocked a considerable distance away, interference is likely. It no longer makes any difference whether the interference was avoidable. All that matters is whether interference clearly occurred. There is no “both players doing their job” exception as with batted balls out front of the plate.

R2, no outs, 2-2 count. The batter swings and misses the next pitch in the dirt. The catcher blocks the ball and it is deflected out in front of the plate. As the BR starts out of the box towards first base, (a) the ball accidentally glances off of him and rolls a couple feet away. The catcher picks up the ball and throws into right field. R2 scores and the BR ends up at second base. (b) the ball is accidentally kicked towards the dugout. The catcher chases after the ball, however, cannot make a play. R2 advances to third, and the BR reaches first base safely.

Ruling:  The umpire should wait and see whether the batter’s actions interfered with the catcher making a play. In (a), he should then signal that it’s nothing when the catcher is able to make the play. The play stands. In (b), he should then signal interference and then call time when the catcher cannot make the play. The BR is out, and R2 returns to second base.

From the 2021 Minor League Baseball Umpire Manual (section 6.3, p. 96) concerning batter interference after a third strike not caught: 

NOTE:  It does not matter if the batter-runner is in the vicinity of home plate or up the first baseline when the infraction occurs. The location of the batter-runner is not relevant.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • 0
Posted

Awesome, thank you all! The change in interp (or clarification) in 2013 is really helpful and completes my understanding here.

Looks like we got the call right, for the wrong reason :) catcher and batter bumped into each other right over the plate, then F2 was able to pick the ball up and tag out BR.

OHC came over, "I'm not arguing the call, but you got that one wrong!" (He lied, and was mistaken :)), And told us it should be obstruction.

I roundabout defended my answer with tangle/untangle, but looks like I should have done delayed interference instead.

×
×
  • Create New...