RefMag Play 2

[noumpere]

I know RefMag sometimes gets plays wrong, and I also know I'm not up on all the recent rules changes.  So (plays paraphrased),

R1 stealing.  Batted ball to F6.  Throw to second is too late to retire R1.  F4 throws the ball in the stands.  BR has NOT reached first at time of throw.

a.  R1 stays at second, BR stays at first.

b. R1 to third, B1 to second

c. R1 scores, B1 to second

d. R1 scores, B1 to third

(FED, NCAA and OBR rulings, please.)

[yawetag]

Don't have the books in front of me, but C in all rule codes.

The throw that went OOP wasn't the first play in the infield, so it's 2 bases from TOT.

[noumpere]

15 minutes ago, yawetag said:

Don't have the books in front of me, but C in all rule codes.

The throw that went OOP wasn't the first play in the infield, so it's 2 bases from TOT.

That's also what I had.  RefMag had "B" in all rules codes.

[Aging_Arbiter]

possibly AT THE TOT, R1 had not reached 2nd......................but did before the ball arrived?  Only way I cab see B as an answer

[Jimurray]

1 hour ago, Aging_Arbiter said:

possibly AT THE TOT, R1 had not reached 2nd......................but did before the ball arrived?  Only way I cab see B as an answer

That might be true for the first throw but we are concerned with the TOT of the second throw. 

[Rich Ives]

1 hour ago, Aging_Arbiter said:

possibly AT THE TOT, R1 had not reached 2nd......................but did before the ball arrived?  Only way I cab see B as an answer

Then he'd be out wouldn't he. He was safe at 2B   ("Throw to second is too late to retire R1")   so he had to have reached it.

[Aging_Arbiter]

I stand corrected.  I was thinking 1st throw in my comment (as the 2nd)