Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4137 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

A player goes into a base and lets say into 3rd. He slides into 3rd and puts his hand up to call time (to get up), but I haven't given him time yet, the throw comes in late and goes past the base, can the player advance? 

Does it kill the play when that player calls time? Can he advance anymore after putting his hand up to call time?

Posted (edited)

If they're still throwing it around, then to me, the initial play is going on and I'm not granting time. Once it's all done and play is pretty much relaxed, sure.

Edited by scrounge
Posted

Where I see this most is when the player goes back head first and the player just stands there holding the glove on them.  Sometimes it is quicker to call time and get them up then to not grant it and wait for base runner to walk it up or fielder to stop holding the tag.  It must be requested by the player though.  One time I had a coach tell his kid to request time when the kid was holding the tag.  The only problem was the kid raised the only hand that was on the bag.  Sorry out son.

Posted

Where I see this most is when the player goes back head first and the player just stands there holding the glove on them.  Sometimes it is quicker to call time and get them up then to not grant it and wait for base runner to walk it up or fielder to stop holding the tag.  It must be requested by the player though.  One time I had a coach tell his kid to request time when the kid was holding the tag.  The only problem was the kid raised the only hand that was on the bag.  Sorry out son.

​If you heard the coach tell him to request time, and you intended on granting it, why didn't you just call it when you heard the coach say it?

Posted

​If you heard the coach tell him to request time, and you intended on granting it, why didn't you just call it when you heard the coach say it?

Yup, or even retroactively, as sometimes happens in basketball.

That out is too cheap for me, and likely to cause more trouble than it's worth.

  • Like 2
Posted

I need to clarify I only found out the coach told him after.  R1 and R3 I was in B he said it and it was a windy day so I never heard it then kid put up hand.  It was only later that my partner said he heard the coach tell him to call time.  I would have granted the coach if I would have heard it.  Surprisingly the coach didn't say a word.

Posted (edited)

I also tell the kids to climb up and I tell the the fielder to throw it in. Unless he took a face full of dirt or something like that, I don't like to call time. Fielder needs to learn how to throw the ball to the pitcher. So many times, the fielder makes a bad throw, ball is live and runners may try to advance - but they can't if we call time. That's part of the game. 

Edited by Umpirechick1
  • Like 1
Posted

So your partner heard it? And he didn't grant time? Hmmmmm

​No, he didn't hear it, I am just talking in general terms when a kid slides into a base and puts his hand up for time but the play is not over yet since the ball is in route to that base he is at and passes him. Does that mean it kills the play when the player calls time? Or would I have to grant time for the player, but if I granted time and the ball passes then it kills it all right? 

Posted

​No, he didn't hear it, I am just talking in general terms when a kid slides into a base and puts his hand up for time but the play is not over yet since the ball is in route to that base he is at and passes him. Does that mean it kills the play when the player calls time? Or would I have to grant time for the player, but if I granted time and the ball passes then it kills it all right? 

No, a kid putting his hand up does NOT kill the play. IF, you chose to grant time, wait until action has stopped (relaxed). I suggest only granting time if you see they are hurt or taken a mouth of dirt or some such thing. If you tell them "No, walk it up" the coach will convey that to the rest of the team and you won't have to deal with it the rest of the game. 

  • Like 1
Posted

In general terms,... a player putting his hand up means nothing.......he can not call time, he can request it from you, and you may grant it......or not....in general terms do not grant time until all playing action is relaxed...........once you grant time, its a bell you cant un-ring.....

Posted

In general terms,... a player putting his hand up means nothing.......he can not call time, he can request it from you, and you may grant it......or not....in general terms do not grant time until all playing action is relaxed...........once you grant time, its a bell you cant un-ring.....

​Never thought it of that way. I forget sometimes how much power I have out there. 

×
×
  • Create New...