Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4245 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I was PU. R2 and R3. My partner called a balk (very delayed call) and tried to advance the batter to 1B. I quickly took charge, pointing to runners and saying "you, home, you, third" I think both coaches were in shock.

Posted

Well... 9th grade ball. BU said he called balk because the kid was throwing to an unoccupied base - but he didn't throw the ball. The actual problem was the kid didn't disengage. Then after coach said several times "that's a balk" he finally called it. I couldn't see b/c the mound was so high and I was already locked in. When he pointed to the batter and then 1B, I came up saying "No, no" and I awarded based.

This guy is very inexperienced (he's the same guy who took a thrown ball to the head last week in. JV game) so every game has it's own set of surprises.

Posted

The mound height caused you to lose sight of what? The pitcher? His feet? 

Posted

His feet on the rubber (covered in dirt) and a batter leaning in limited my view of his feet. If my partner is calling a balk, that's fine, if he knows what he's calling and why - sometimes we see (or don't see) the same thing. My problem was him trying to award the batter 1B and seeing both coaches reactions.

Posted

His feet on the rubber (covered in dirt) and a batter leaning in limited my view of his feet. If my partner is calling a balk, that's fine, if he knows what he's calling and why - sometimes we see (or don't see) the same thing. My problem was him trying to award the batter 1B and seeing both coaches reactions.

Yes, that would be an attention getter for sure. 

  • Like 3
Posted

He said he didn't disengage and made a move to 1B but didn't throw.

 

If you had R2 and R3, it would be a balk for feinting/stepping to an unoccupied base. It wouldn't matter if he disengaged or not. 

Posted

Yes, he got the call right (with some help). He was saying it wrong by got the call right. Just a little embarrassing when your partner tries to award the BATTER a base for a balk.

Posted

He said he didn't disengage and made a move to 1B but didn't throw.

 

If you had R2 and R3, it would be a balk for feinting/stepping to an unoccupied base. It wouldn't matter if he disengaged or not.

Run that by me again.

Posted

If you had R2 and R3, it would be a balk for feinting/stepping to an unoccupied base. It wouldn't matter if he disengaged or not.

I know that you know the rule. Why would it be a balk if he disengaged?

Posted

 

He said he didn't disengage and made a move to 1B but didn't throw.

 

If you had R2 and R3, it would be a balk for feinting/stepping to an unoccupied base. It wouldn't matter if he disengaged or not. 

 

 

I'd bet a lot of money that's not what he meant to say. Might have been thinking of a jump step...

Posted

It was the jump step. RH pitcher, jump step, gained no distance to 1B, didn't throw because he realized there wasn't a runner, and... He was screwed no matter what. My partner gets rattled, can't explain it but he really doesn't need to because both coaches knew it. Then he can't figure out base awards. At least when I awarded bases AND kept the batter in the box, both coaches thanked me. ðŸ˜

  • Like 1
Posted

He said he didn't disengage and made a move to 1B but didn't throw.

Gotta love making a move to a base that no one is at, nor attempting to get there.

Posted

 

 

He said he didn't disengage and made a move to 1B but didn't throw.

 

If you had R2 and R3, it would be a balk for feinting/stepping to an unoccupied base. It wouldn't matter if he disengaged or not.

Run that by me again.

 

 

 

 

If you had R2 and R3, it would be a balk for feinting/stepping to an unoccupied base. It wouldn't matter if he disengaged or not.

I know that you know the rule. Why would it be a balk if he disengaged?

 

 

You guys are right, I didn't type that clearly. I was trying to say that stepping to first is a balk with no runner there. I was also trying to make the point that stepping to 2nd or 3rd with runners at either base and not throwing isn't a balk, and that you don't have to disengage to feint to an occupied base. The OP had me confused about why her partner called a balk in the first place. I couldn't figure out if it was for stepping to an occupied base and not throwing or for stepping to first when it was unoccupied. 

 

×
×
  • Create New...