Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 523 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Has anyone seen this? Or seen a case play or memo about it?

With 2 strikes and 1B unoccupied or 2 strikes with R1 and 2 outs, the next pitch is delivered and is uncaught by F2. The umpire rules it a ball. F2 appeals the call of the pitch and the appeal comes back a strike. Presuming he hasn't left the dirt circle, is the batter now eligible to try and advance to 1B?

~Dawg

Posted

I was talking about this with someone. There's a few odd circumstances that could crop up. I don't know if they are addressed anywhere. 

1-2 pitch. 1B empty. pitch on the inside part of the plate, F2 tries to "frame", misses the ball. Umpire calls a ball, batter takes off for 1B. He gets there, taps his head. ABS says strike. 

Posted

First instinct is to treat same as a verrrry late check swing input.

But, the ABS appeal has to be "within 2 seconds" (if I recall what i've read correctly). But 2 seconds of what? The ball/strike call or the conclusion of the play?

Posted

 

18 hours ago, Velho said:

But, the ABS appeal has to be "within 2 seconds" (if I recall what i've read correctly). But 2 seconds of what? The ball/strike call or the conclusion of the play?

I really hope it's after the play.

The other one would be full count, R1 steals.  

Ball four, F2 throws down - he might even get the runner (had it not been a walk).   F2 then taps head.  That's going to be more than two seconds after the ump's call.   And in some cases that could be a double play.

Otherwise, you're forcing the batter to tap his head as he starts running to third, the catcher to tap his head immediately after releasing a throw, or even before the throw, etc.

  • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...