Jump to content
  • 0
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 3786 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

6 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted

As you know, there are 19 ways to balk (I made up that number). You're right, he didn't balk in the way you mention (throwing to an unoccupied base). He balked in one of the other 18 ways.

The rule requires stepping and throwing/feinting to a base. Throwing to a fielder who is away from the base — not in a position to make a play — is by interpretation feinting a throw to the base.

So when F1 threw to F3 away from the base, he was guilty of feinting a throw to 1B. Yes, he threw the ball, so he didn't feint a throw; but by throwing to the fielder away from the base, he feinted a throw to the base. Since the base in question is 1B, such a feint is a balk.

You might ask whether the throw to F3 wasn't also in line with 1B, so technically an "intercepted" throw to the base. By interpretation, it doesn't matter: F3 must be in position to make a play, or the throw counts as feinting a throw to a base. F1 gets the same advantage with F3 playing in as he does with F3 playing back, and both are treated as feints.

  • Like 3
  • 0
Posted
13 minutes ago, maven said:

You might ask whether the throw to F3 wasn't also in line with 1B, so technically an "intercepted" throw to the base. By interpretation, it doesn't matter: F3 must be in position to make a play, or the throw counts as feinting a throw to a base. F1 gets the same advantage with F3 playing in as he does with F3 playing back, and both are treated as feints.

To clarify, I think these comments apply only when the throw is intercepted.  If F1 throws to a base and no one is there, it is not a feint per Evans.  It is, however, usually irrelevant whether a balk is called (under OBR) when the ball sails into right field.

 

 

  • 0
Posted
1 minute ago, basejester said:

To clarify, I think these comments apply only when the throw is intercepted.  If F1 throws to a base and no one is there, it is not a feint per Evans.  It is, however, usually irrelevant whether a balk is called (under OBR) when the ball sails into right field.

I agree: when not intercepted — the ball rolls or flies over the base and into foul, or bounces around — F1 gains no advantage, and generally disadvantages himself. In that case, we would not rule a balk (and wouldn't need to, as the runners will likely move up on their own).

I have also never seen or heard of such a throw (except in the Evans video). In contrast, throwing to F3 away from the base happens fairly regularly.

  • Like 1
  • 0
Posted

if F1 is breaking for the base at TOT, either from in front or behind R1, would that make any difference in the call?

  • 0
Posted
3 minutes ago, stkjock said:

if F1 is breaking for the base at TOT, either from in front or behind R1, would that make any difference in the call?

Yes, as long as he breaks before the throw and not in reaction to it.

 

And, FED rules are slightly different -- the fielder must be in a position to reasonably make a play on R1.

×
×
  • Create New...