Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4928 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

Posted

How long does the fielder have to hold onto the ball after tagging the runner to have an out? I had a situation where the fielder tagged the runner and held onto the ball and then he dropped it. What is the right call?

10 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted

plateumpire,

 

In your judgment, why/how did he drop the ball after tagging the runner?

 

JM

I do not really know why he dropped it but it just came out of his glove about five seconds after tagging the runner. 

  • 0
Posted

@plateumpire:  The definition of a tag requires that the ball be held securely in hand or glove. A ball that pops out during a tag attempt provides evidence that it was not held securely, and thus was not a tag.

 

The rule is different from the definition of a catch, and it does NOT require "voluntary release." That's a higher standard than applies to tag attempts. But the fielder must nonetheless hold the ball securely throughout the tag attempt.

 

A runner who intentionally knocks the ball from a fielder's glove or mitt is guilty of interference. Absent intention, a ball that pops out after contact with the runner was not securely held.

 

This is all umpire judgment, throughout.

  • 0
Posted

 

plateumpire,

 

In your judgment, why/how did he drop the ball after tagging the runner?

 

JM

I do not really know why he dropped it but it just came out of his glove about five seconds after tagging the runner. 

 

It's usually a HTBT situation....

If I have a tag with good possession and then the fielder does something else not related to the play and drops the ball, its still a good tag. 

If I have a tag and as the fielder picks his glove up and drops the ball, NO TAG.

 

Again, this is just a guideline and really you have to be able to judge what was going on at the time.

  • 0
Posted

plateumpire,

 

If he held onto it for five seconds after the tag, I'm likely judging he had secure possession throughout the tag, and ruling the tag "good". 5 seconds is a pretty long time in this context.

 

JM

  • Like 2
  • 0
Posted

plateumpire,

 

If he held onto it for five seconds after the tag, I'm likely judging he had secure possession throughout the tag, and ruling the tag "good". 5 seconds is a pretty long time in this context.

 

JM

 

Agreed. After 5 seconds, I'm probably not watching anymore. :)

  • Like 1
  • 0
Posted

plateumpire,

 

If he held onto it for five seconds after the tag, I'm likely judging he had secure possession throughout the tag, and ruling the tag "good". 5 seconds is a pretty long time in this context.

 

JM

@UmpJM I called him out. Should I have reemphasized that he was still out after the ball was dropped? 

  • 0
Posted

 

plateumpire,

 

If he held onto it for five seconds after the tag, I'm likely judging he had secure possession throughout the tag, and ruling the tag "good". 5 seconds is a pretty long time in this context.

 

JM

@UmpJM I called him out. Should I have reemphasized that he was still out after the ball was dropped? 

 

Yes if there was any question about it.  Just like on any "on the transfer" type of call.

 

Note that there might be some subtle differences between the rules codes and if the tag was for example in a rundown and the chasing fielder swiped at the runner and then stumbles for 5 seconds (which is a very long time) and then drops the ball you might have a different answer.

  • 0
Posted

He must have possession before during and after the tag. If he completes the tag and drops it for some other reason, good tag. You should know why he dropped it because you always watch the ball, even if he just throwing back to the pitcher. 

×
×
  • Create New...