Another one at first Tigers/Indians

[Thunderheads]

http://www.mlb.com/v...831645&c_id=mlb

http://mlb.mlb.com/video/play.jsp?content_id=24831645&topic_id=&c_id=mlb&tcid=vpp_copy_24831645&v=3

[Dannytheman]

Fielder did tag him on the back, but Runner was already on the bag. Good call, great position to see the entire play. Fielder should have been tossed for the tantrum.

[Thunderheads]

Fielder did tag him on the back, but Runner was already on the bag. Good call, great position to see the entire play. Fielder should have been tossed for the tantrum.

Uhm...watch again.........

[Dannytheman]

OK, R1s heel is on first before glove hits his lower back. That is what I see. I even put on my glasses. :nod:

[Thunderheads]

OK, R1s heel is on first before glove hits his lower back. That is what I see. I even put on my glasses.

Nope!

[Dannytheman]

That angle does not show me glove laying on his back. (I'm sticking to my initial statement.)

But I do appreciate the time you have spent with me. LOL

[Thunderheads]

That angle does not show me glove laying on his back. (I'm sticking to my initial statement.)

But I do appreciate the time you have spent with me. LOL

There were other angles on the Tiger broadcast that showed it clearly ....trust me Danny ...he got him....

Have you ever seen Fielder react like that ?!

No .... that's clue 1 .....

And I'll give Knight credit, ...he got the other 2 bangers earlier....

[noumpere]

Hard call to make and notice that the umpire was moving a lot at the time of the tag/notag. Good to adjust unlike some of the other video shown but this shows how adjusting doesnt always help either.

[Dannytheman]

I am busy looking for another angle. Thunderheads swears he's out, and I would like to support him, but I still don't see obvious evidence at this point.

[Mr Umpire]

Tough play, tough call. I wasn't sure of a tag in real time so I would definitely go with U1's call. But, it does appear he tagged him after slow-mo and freeze frame. Good "no reversal" call.

[JaxRolo]

Knight was way late in reacting. What took him so long to get in the proper angle?

I also have not seen a good angle that shows he was out.

[Thunderheads]

Knight was way late in reacting. What took him so long to get in the proper angle?

I also have not seen a good angle that shows he was out.

Remember folks, ...I live in Detroit ....local FSN carries the games .... tons of replays you're never going to see on the national scene

[BRUMP]

Anyone else find the candy comparison funny considering it was Prince?

[Umpkc7]

Knight missed that one too, I feel like he also missed one of the bangers before that too. no reason to throw prince out here, he treats umpire really well and only says his mind when he knows hes right.

[JaxRolo]

Knight was way late in reacting. What took him so long to get in the proper angle?

I also have not seen a good angle that shows he was out.

Remember folks, ...I live in Detroit ....local FSN carries the games .... tons of replays you're never going to see on the national scene

Oh I See! You are a Detroit fan so that's why you see the out! :wave:

[cyclonehokiece]

Prince does have a bit of a temper. He shows it rarely, but when he does, look out. Remember when he tried to get in the opposing clubhouse while he was still in Milwaukee? When Prince gets pi$$ed, he gets pi$$ed.

[Thunderheads]

Knight was way late in reacting. What took him so long to get in the proper angle?

I also have not seen a good angle that shows he was out.

Remember folks, ...I live in Detroit ....local FSN carries the games .... tons of replays you're never going to see on the national scene

Oh I See! You are a Detroit fan so that's why you see the out!

I didn't say I was a fan, I said I live here .....

Of course I want to see them succeed, but actually that's not the reason, .... joking or not ........