Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 6003 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Finally dismissed a coach for arguing balls and strikes. Happened a couple of weeks ago. F1 is throwing a big looping curve, the kind that starts above the batter's shoulders and the catcher gloves it belt high, 2 feet behind the plate. (Ball!) Well the coach starts chirping, I told him, "we were not going to have this discussion." 3 innings later, after another series of big rainbows from F1, he walks and glares at me from dugout to mound. After his conference he yells from the mound "Hey can i ask you a question" (I do not like being yelled at) As he is moving towards me I said " you're gone." At this point we are face to face. All very civilized and adult conversational level.

DC - I can't ask you a question?

Ty - Yes you can, and when our discussion is over you are off the field.

DC - Are you calling those pitches where the batters are standing, or the plate?

Ty - The plate coach, it is a judgment call. Now you are off the field.

DC - You are really going to throw me out of this game?

Ty - Yup.

DC - (A little bit louder now) Well now we are getting home town'd. He continues this rant as he collects his crap from the dugout.

Mind you both teams are from out of town at this tourny. I waited for him to remove himself and continued the game. My partner didn't even know he got tossed.

  • Replies 7
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Finally dismissed a coach for arguing balls and strikes. Happened a couple of weeks ago. F1 is throwing a big looping curve, the kind that starts above the batter's shoulders and the catcher gloves it belt high, 2 feet behind the plate. (Ball!) Well the coach starts chirping, I told him, "we were not going to have this discussion." 3 innings later, after another series of big rainbows from F1, he walks and glares at me from dugout to mound. After his conference he yells from the mound "Hey can i ask you a question" (I do not like being yelled at) As he is moving towards me I said " you're gone." At this point we are face to face. All very civilized and adult conversational level.

DC - I can't ask you a question?

Ty - Yes you can, and when our discussion is over you are off the field.

DC - Are you calling those pitches where the batters are standing, or the plate?

Ty - The plate coach, it is a judgment call. Now you are off the field.

DC - You are really going to throw me out of this game?

Ty - Yup.

DC - (A little bit louder now) Well now we are getting home town'd. He continues this rant as he collects his crap from the dugout.

Mind you both teams are from out of town at this tourny. I waited for him to remove himself and continued the game. My partner didn't even know he got tossed.

OK here's what you did wrong:

1) The purpose of his mound visit was to talk to you. That is why he walked from the dugout to the mound without taking his eyes off you. When this happens, forgo whatever timing mechanism you have when a coach makes a trip to the mound, and head right out. Chin up, return his stare, but keep your posture relaxed. Walk around the mound so when you step on, you are facing him. Then say something like "I'm not out here to discuss balls or strikes."

2) You ejected him for absolutely nothing. Your response should've been something like "sure, just come over here to do it please." Then if he wants to bring up the strike zone, you have an issue.

After that, you were fine.

Posted

I see nothing you could EJ him for as ump_24 stated.

Try to keep them in the game not look for EJs.

Posted

I see nothing you could EJ him for as ump_24 stated.

I like ump_24's post, too. I don't know that I would do it his way, but I like what he wrote.

Try to keep them in the game not look for EJs.

I'm not as big of fan of this line, though. I guess I understand the concept behind it - don't be a red-ass - but "try to keep them in the game" is a Tournament Director/Coach/Rat concept. And if we DO try to keep 'em in the game too much, we leave a mess for others to clean.

My EJ for this year (it's one a year so far): LL Major, and this league wants just one-man during the regular season. (It's their money, they make the decisions.) And they want the one-man behind the mound. So a problem can be fair/foul calls.

In about the 2nd, HT had a player flair it over F5 and 3B. Ball hits well off the line in my judgment, but there's still a puff of dirt (fields are REAL dry). I call foul; of course, a daddy in the stands wants to yell about the "chalk" cloud. Coaches might have grumbled, but nothing I can remember now.

Move to bottom-6. The HT has turned a 9-7 deficit at 5 to a 14-7 deficit, thanks to poor defense and some okay hitting, so their mood is dark. They have one out, and a liner is hit. This one may not have been as obvious as the first, but in the VERY short moment I have, I see it foul. So I call it that.

I'm between the mound and the 3B line, looking back to tell the BR to return, since he's got a coach still telling him to run. I turn back towards the 3B box, and the head coach says "That's two, blue!"

Whoosh.

Not really a 2nd thought about it. I've had some suggest I pop a warning first. And it's a fair point. But here's the thing: don't count calls on an umpire. Ever. Those that suggested a warning said "he might not know that." Well, one learns by doing, and he's learned now.

Thing is, I think he probably DID know. After I gave the arm motion to dump him, I said "you don't count calls on an umpire." His reply wasn't anything like "I didn't know that," or some other comment that would imply, or let him pretend, ignorance. Instead, he said "I wasn't counting."

Really? So, the word "two" in your area isn't a word in the number system, but is, maybe, a color? A vegetable?

So I might get ripped here, but I either a) taught a coach one of the unwritten rules for arguing, or :wow: caught him in behaviour he'd learned and stuck with, and might make him think twice about it. Slept like a baby.

Posted

I like ump_24's post, too. I don't know that I would do it his way, but I like what he wrote.

I'm not as big of fan of this line, though. I guess I understand the concept behind it - don't be a red-ass - but "try to keep them in the game" is a Tournament Director/Coach/Rat concept. And if we DO try to keep 'em in the game too much, we leave a mess for others to clean.

My EJ for this year (it's one a year so far): LL Major, and this league wants just one-man during the regular season. (It's their money, they make the decisions.) And they want the one-man behind the mound. So a problem can be fair/foul calls.

In about the 2nd, HT had a player flair it over F5 and 3B. Ball hits well off the line in my judgment, but there's still a puff of dirt (fields are REAL dry). I call foul; of course, a daddy in the stands wants to yell about the "chalk" cloud. Coaches might have grumbled, but nothing I can remember now.

Move to bottom-6. The HT has turned a 9-7 deficit at 5 to a 14-7 deficit, thanks to poor defense and some okay hitting, so their mood is dark. They have one out, and a liner is hit. This one may not have been as obvious as the first, but in the VERY short moment I have, I see it foul. So I call it that.

I'm between the mound and the 3B line, looking back to tell the BR to return, since he's got a coach still telling him to run. I turn back towards the 3B box, and the head coach says "That's two, blue!"

Whoosh.

Not really a 2nd thought about it. I've had some suggest I pop a warning first. And it's a fair point. But here's the thing: don't count calls on an umpire. Ever. Those that suggested a warning said "he might not know that." Well, one learns by doing, and he's learned now.

Thing is, I think he probably DID know. After I gave the arm motion to dump him, I said "you don't count calls on an umpire." His reply wasn't anything like "I didn't know that," or some other comment that would imply, or let him pretend, ignorance. Instead, he said "I wasn't counting."

Really? So, the word "two" in your area isn't a word in the number system, but is, maybe, a color? A vegetable?

So I might get ripped here, but I either a) taught a coach one of the unwritten rules for arguing, or :no: caught him in behaviour he'd learned and stuck with, and might make him think twice about it. Slept like a baby.

I agree with you. Don't call my calls that your thought I missed. I don't call out how many times you made a dumb call and got a runner thrown out or how many times you left a pitcher in for a half inning to long, do I?

To the OP, you got a little dump happy(something my wifes says I get alot but that is a different post.) You got to wait for him to get on your butt a little more then that.

Posted

Hokie, good toss. Counting calls is showing you up just like a batter drawing a line.

Tyennie: probably would have had to go anyway but use an approach more like suggested. When you know the only reason he went out was to talk to then go talk. As suggested make sure you are facing him on the mound and ask if he is staying with the pitcher. If he asks where is he missing, tell him and start to walk away saying "Let's go!" If he asks anymore questions or follows you then he now goes away.

Posted

What I try to do is the first time the coach comes to argue I talk to him in a civilized manner in a low tone of voice so only he can hear me and make it very clear that is the last time. If he elects to continue I tell him firmly to walk away. If he starts to yell. :cheers::wave:

Some say I am to quick to EJ but I don't have time for arguments.

So far it has worked for me. I have developed a reputation with the coaches. They know that if they want to argue they must talk to me like a man not a child. And they only get one chance.

If they want to talk about a particular ruling I will talk to them all day. Judment calls NO NO. :nod:


×
×
  • Create New...