Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 5560 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

First and foremost, I hope that the pitcher will be ok.

1-2, 2 out. After the checked swing, PU immediately turns and goes to 1BU as he's done a thousand times before. As he does, he misses everything else. Batter does stick his foot out and trip F2. It looks like PU says something to F2 afterwards, perhaps that he didn't see anything. By not waiting for the play to finish, he didn't get a good look at it.

I have batter INT. But it's so easy to see it on vid from the CF camera. Did the crew get together after the play? All due respect to these guys for truly earning their way into regionals, but if I saw it, INT. On purpose or inadevertent, injury notwithstanding, the foot was up & out there and impeded the throw.

(Thumbed on Droid)

Posted

I do not have any sources to cite but was watching the following game and the pitcher was suited up and smiling, looks like he's going to be ok. Tough to watch though. Can't imagine watching that if I was his parent.

Posted

Agreed. No BI here. Catcher was just clumsy on this play. Don't go looking to penalize an unusual event. Let play continue and then tend to fallen pitcher. That's exactly what happened here.

Posted

Agreed. No BI here. Catcher was just clumsy on this play. Don't go looking to penalize an unusual event. Let play continue and then tend to fallen pitcher. That's exactly what happened here.

Disagree, catcher was not clumsy.

Catcher did his job, batter did his, pitcher did his and a weird throw occured.

Sorry, I'm an ex-catcher, have to stand up for him, he did NOTHING wrong.

Posted

Agreed. No BI here. Catcher was just clumsy on this play. Don't go looking to penalize an unusual event. Let play continue and then tend to fallen pitcher. That's exactly what happened here.

Disagree, catcher was not clumsy.

Catcher did his job, batter did his, pitcher did his and a weird throw occured.

Sorry, I'm an ex-catcher, have to stand up for him, he did NOTHING wrong.

I thought the catcher tripped on his own. I see nothing wrong on this play.

Posted

Agreed. No BI here. Catcher was just clumsy on this play. Don't go looking to penalize an unusual event. Let play continue and then tend to fallen pitcher. That's exactly what happened here.

Disagree, catcher was not clumsy.

Catcher did his job, batter did his, pitcher did his and a weird throw occured.

Sorry, I'm an ex-catcher, have to stand up for him, he did NOTHING wrong.

I have to slightly disagree. F1 did not do his job completely. What is the Number 1 rule in baseball? Watch the ball and know where it is. As an ex-catcher and pitcher, I never looked at 2B until I knew where the ball was going. I had my share of almost hitting a pitcher or 2 (mainly b/c they were very tall and ended up higher than most) and they were looking at 2B but I missed.

But, F2 did his job the best he could under the circumstances. But, as for the play, no BI.

×
×
  • Create New...