Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 6288 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

There is a new umpire here in my area who claims that he has worked NCAA, NAIA, and high school as well as the summer youth scene: JrBR and AMLG.

For those of you that are working college level - would you ever wear a pair of ugly white tennis shoes to work the bases, even if it is summer league ball? Would you ever show up to work a game unshaven or with an untrimmed beard? My reason for asking: this particular gentleman keeps giving some rather interesting rules interps. Examples: (1) AmLg tourney this past weekend, F1 goes to his mouth on the mound: Balk! (Remember that Legion plays straight OBR). After reading an old copy (2000) of the BRD, i am aware that Fedlandia does have a different ruling on the pitcher to the mouth. (2) He also informed us that new AmLg ruling - after the third visit to the same F1 during the game he needs to be replaced. haven't heard that one, perhaps someone out there can speak to this new legion rule. (3) An earlier comment he made stating that his favorite rule was found in section 10. He was alluding to 9.01© The umpire has the right to.......

My initial thoughts - This guy is full of himself and crapola.

What say ye - oh purveyors of umpire excellence? ty

  • Replies 9
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

There is a new umpire here in my area who claims that he has worked NCAA, NAIA, and high school as well as the summer youth scene: JrBR and AMLG.

For those of you that are working college level - would you ever wear a pair of ugly white tennis shoes to work the bases, even if it is summer league ball? Would you ever show up to work a game unshaven or with an untrimmed beard? My reason for asking: this particular gentleman keeps giving some rather interesting rules interps. Examples: (1) AmLg tourney this past weekend, F1 goes to his mouth on the mound: Balk! (Remember that Legion plays straight OBR). After reading an old copy (2000) of the BRD, i am aware that Fedlandia does have a different ruling on the pitcher to the mouth. (2) He also informed us that new AmLg ruling - after the third visit to the same F1 during the game he needs to be replaced. haven't heard that one, perhaps someone out there can speak to this new legion rule. (3) An earlier comment he made stating that his favorite rule was found in section 10. He was alluding to 9.01© The umpire has the right to.......

My initial thoughts - This guy is full of himself and crapola.

What say ye - oh purveyors of umpire excellence? ty

Well, sounds to me like he may have worked them ONCE and was promptly told to go someplace else. Wore out his welcome.:BD:

His rules interpretations allow a lot to be desired as well. F1 going to his mouth and not wiping it is a balk or a ball on the batter if there are no runners. :smachhead:

OBR talks about coaches going to talk with F1.:crybaby2:

Ask him to point out in the OBR exactly what his favorite rule is exactly in section 10. :bang:

Posted

The AL rule is still OBR and second visit he goes. Going to the mouth is a ball. And as you already know it's 9.01c. Sounds like the 1 yr experience x times. Trust me, in some areas if you can make the game you can work college. Not true everywhere but true more than I care to see.

Posted

(3) An earlier comment he made stating that his favorite rule was found in section 10. He was alluding to 9.01© The umpire has the right to.......

I would think that would be any umpire worth his salt's favorite rule as well...

I call it the BIFSS (BIF-US) rule....

"Because I ******* said so!":givebeer:

  • 3 months later...
Posted

There is a new umpire here in my area who claims that he has worked NCAA, NAIA, and high school as well as the summer youth scene: JrBR and AMLG.

For those of you that are working college level - would you ever wear a pair of ugly white tennis shoes to work the bases, even if it is summer league ball? Would you ever show up to work a game unshaven or with an untrimmed beard? My reason for asking: this particular gentleman keeps giving some rather interesting rules interps. Examples: (1) AmLg tourney this past weekend, F1 goes to his mouth on the mound: Balk! (Remember that Legion plays straight OBR). After reading an old copy (2000) of the BRD, i am aware that Fedlandia does have a different ruling on the pitcher to the mouth. (2) He also informed us that new AmLg ruling - after the third visit to the same F1 during the game he needs to be replaced. haven't heard that one, perhaps someone out there can speak to this new legion rule. (3) An earlier comment he made stating that his favorite rule was found in section 10. He was alluding to 9.01© The umpire has the right to.......

My initial thoughts - This guy is full of himself and crapola.

What say ye - oh purveyors of umpire excellence? ty

This umpire has got to be lying. There is no way that an umpire who did college ball, would wear white tennis shoes on the field. That is an amatuer move. I know of no such rule that supports his claim that you mentioned in number two. Now if he was talking about the third visit to the same pitcher in the same inning, then he is right in terms of the rule. But if he is talking in terms of total visits per game, then I believe he is wrong, governing any new rules I do not know about.

Posted

This umpire has got to be lying. There is no way that an umpire who did college ball, would wear white tennis shoes on the field. That is an amatuer move. I know of no such rule that supports his claim that you mentioned in number two. Now if he was talking about the third visit to the same pitcher in the same inning, then he is right in terms of the rule. But if he is talking in terms of total visits per game, then I believe he is wrong, governing any new rules I do not know about.

This umpire has got to be lying. There is no way that an umpire who did college ball, would wear white tennis shoes on the field. That is an amatuer move. I know of no such rule that supports his claim that you mentioned in number two. Now if he was talking about the third visit to the same pitcher in the same inning, then he is right in terms of the rule. But if he is talking in terms of total visits per game, then I believe he is wrong, governing any new rules I do not know about.

nolanadair-

I know this is another old thread you replied to, but OBR, as mentioned by mstaylor, provides that you only get 1 free visit per inning, per pitcher. On the second visit to the same pitcher in a inning you must bring in another pitcher. FED allows 3 total defensive conferences per game with a conference not being charged when you change pitchers (if extra innings you get 1 free conference per inning).

Maybe you are referencing a LL rule as far as visits (I don't do LL, so I'm not up on their rules), but the OP is kinda specific that it's AmerLegion which is OBR (some areas may use modified FED rules for AmerLegion, not sure).

Posted

nolanadair-

I know this is another old thread you replied to, but OBR, as mentioned by mstaylor, provides that you only get 1 free visit per inning, per pitcher. On the second visit to the same pitcher in a inning you must bring in another pitcher. FED allows 3 total defensive conferences per game with a conference not being charged when you change pitchers (if extra innings you get 1 free conference per inning).

Maybe you are referencing a LL rule as far as visits (I don't do LL, so I'm not up on their rules), but the OP is kinda specific that it's AmerLegion which is OBR (some areas may use modified FED rules for AmerLegion, not sure).

Sorry, for the confusion. I was referring to the Little League rule. I misunderstood his post.

Posted

Hey I know that guy, I think he lives here too. every year we get some " umpire " that was the best guy back home but just moved to town and will be the best here also. that guy is usualy not around very long. personaly, I must be a terrible umpire, I have worked somewhere around 3000 games in my 18 plus years of umpiring and I still havent learned everything.

Posted

Your being evaluated in every game. Always look and act your BEST!!

And doesn't matter if it is Rec ball or College, Always give them your 100%.

Allan

There is a new umpire here in my area who claims that he has worked NCAA, NAIA, and high school as well as the summer youth scene: JrBR and AMLG.

For those of you that are working college level - would you ever wear a pair of ugly white tennis shoes to work the bases, even if it is summer league ball? Would you ever show up to work a game unshaven or with an untrimmed beard? My reason for asking: this particular gentleman keeps giving some rather interesting rules interps. Examples: (1) AmLg tourney this past weekend, F1 goes to his mouth on the mound: Balk! (Remember that Legion plays straight OBR). After reading an old copy (2000) of the BRD, i am aware that Fedlandia does have a different ruling on the pitcher to the mouth. (2) He also informed us that new AmLg ruling - after the third visit to the same F1 during the game he needs to be replaced. haven't heard that one, perhaps someone out there can speak to this new legion rule. (3) An earlier comment he made stating that his favorite rule was found in section 10. He was alluding to 9.01© The umpire has the right to.......

My initial thoughts - This guy is full of himself and crapola.

What say ye - oh purveyors of umpire excellence? ty


×
×
  • Create New...