Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 5236 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have granted exactly 3 requests to "get help" in 25 years. I get the feeling it happens way too often in the baseball world. I'm getting a heckuva look at the feet and at swipe tags by moving quickly across the diamond towards the 45' line and coming set.

If I honestly think I missed something, I'll get help. Otherwise, I tell the coach that (1) I had a good look at it and (2) no, I won't ask the plate umpire.

I have no problem with assistants until they get loud or leave the coach's box.

The only argument I have with you here is from "C" position on a grounder to the left side you are somewhat limited to how close you can get because you have to consider the position of the fielder and his throwing lane. Most first basemen put their foot to the side of the bag, pressed up against it. On any low throw and thus stretch there is going to be a chance of the foot leaving it's contact point with the bag, and you CANNOT see that . You can see it if it moves substantially but it could barely lose contact and you would not know.

If I am in C the plate ump had best be watching whats going on at home, not at first.... just sayin

Posted

I have granted exactly 3 requests to "get help" in 25 years. I get the feeling it happens way too often in the baseball world. I'm getting a heckuva look at the feet and at swipe tags by moving quickly across the diamond towards the 45' line and coming set.

If I honestly think I missed something, I'll get help. Otherwise, I tell the coach that (1) I had a good look at it and (2) no, I won't ask the plate umpire.

I have no problem with assistants until they get loud or leave the coach's box.

The only argument I have with you here is from "C" position on a grounder to the left side you are somewhat limited to how close you can get because you have to consider the position of the fielder and his throwing lane. Most first basemen put their foot to the side of the bag, pressed up against it. On any low throw and thus stretch there is going to be a chance of the foot leaving it's contact point with the bag, and you CANNOT see that . You can see it if it moves substantially but it could barely lose contact and you would not know.

If I am in C the plate ump had best be watching whats going on at home, not at first.... just sayin

Well what if there are two outs and a runner on second. Ground ball to the SS. He is going to charge the ball and then throw to first. That is the priority play. If I'm PU I think that my responsibility is to come out from around the plate and go up the third base line a little but not much. I'm going to have two responsibilities (watching the foot of the first baseman, and watching the runner touching third). Now this may be due to my softball background, but as a PU I'm always watching that first baseman's foot, and for a potential swipe tag.

Posted

Scott

That is by the book in NSA ISA ASA ISF AND NCAA Softball

I sent the whole thread to the Head Umpire For Big 12 Division 1 Softball

He read about not cleaning bases and Not giving up Appeals.

He said he now knows who he will not be hiring.

Posted

I completely understand why the Big 12 assigner would say this, it is the norm for softball. I have friends working SEC,ACC and other big D1 college conferences and I would get the same responses on the baseball side. As we have said many times, do what your group says do.

Posted

And don't try to integrate softball stuff into baseball. Completely different game. You don't expect soccer guys to throw flags instead of flash cards. Apples and oranges.

Posted

And don't try to integrate softball stuff into baseball. Completely different game. You don't expect soccer guys to throw flags instead of flash cards. Apples and oranges.

I agree that they are two different sports, but it's more like tangerines and oranges not apples and oranges. There are far more people that umpire both softball and baseball than soccer and baseball. So I do think that it is only natural that with softball's increase in popularity that some of the mechanics would merge a little. Just like JaxRolo unabashedly refuses to bring a brush on the field when he umpires softball, if my UIC's have no problem with it then I should really not be chastised for cleaning the bases in baseball. And while I do understand that cleaning the bases is not part of the culture of baseball umpiring, I don't think it can be argued that it would be better if it were. There may not be a great reason for keeping the bases clean, but there is no great reason for not cleaning them.

As for the pulled foot appeal, a bunch of baseball coaches must coach or watch a bunch of softball. Because my experience is that they certainly expect that I go to the PU for an appeal on the pulled foot. If that appeal was honored as infrequently as I'm being lead to believe on this board then I would assume that the coaches would not ask for it as frequently. But then again coaches don't always act in a way that logic would dictate. :D

Posted

This is from the ISF National Director in Plant City Florida

Governing Body for International Softball and Olympic Softball

So?

Don't know if this has been addressed yet, by anyone else, but I'm still catching up.

Nothing more aggravating that a PU telling a FU that, for instance, "I didn't see the play, I was watching the player touch home plate". Who cares about the runner touching home plate? If they were happening simultaneously (play @ 1st and runner touching home plate), the runner at home was OBVIOUSLY safe, and the play at first takes precedence.

Sorry, but this "Softball God" just lost me here.

Who cares about the runner touching HP? Well, me. Why? Because I'd like to know if the run actually counts or not. If that runner doesn't touch HP, if the defensive team is any good at all, SOMEONE was watching for it. So unless that out at 1st is the 3rd out of an inning, you may have a crap-storm at the plate, if they appeal it, and the PU says "duhh, I don't know - I was too busy doing the BU's job for him!"

I understand softballers do different things than us, and that's all well and fine - they've got their 'thing' and we have ours - but that's just so wrong, it's not funny

Posted

I don't clean a base very often. When I do I always leave some dirt on it. The reason is if I can't tell if he touched the base, as he goes by, if I see dirt move on the base he touched the base. Especially 1st base.

Posted

Scott

That is by the book in NSA ISA ASA ISF AND NCAA Softball

I sent the whole thread to the Head Umpire For Big 12 Division 1 Softball

He read about not cleaning bases and Not giving up Appeals.

He said he now knows who he will not be hiring.

Good for him!!

FFS, what's the matter with you? Aside from being Scott, but with a different user ID?

I mean, why on Earth do you continue to back up your arguments from the softball standpoint, when we're discussing BASEball?

If the head of Big 12 Softball wants to make strike calls looking like a doof, clean bases, call 'Dead Ball,' good for him. I, on the other hand, would think that any assignor that wouldn't hire RichMSN is a f---wit.

(And please, save the argument about pulling the foot. If FP 1st basemen are pulling their feet, it's because they're too scared to stay in there. It ain't like they have their feet covering 75% of the bag.)

Posted

Because my experience is that they certainly expect that I go to the PU for an appeal on the pulled foot. If that appeal was honored as infrequently as I'm being lead to believe on this board then I would assume that the coaches would not ask for it as frequently.

It's because you're training them to do so. And making it worse for the rest of us.

Coaches and players will work an angle, just to see what they can get. And it's well known that they're not asking because they think you were wrong - and coaches have openly admitted that - it's because they want to see if you're weak enough to not stand up for you own call.

Make your calls. Own your calls. Tell the coach "No" once in a while. (Except on check swings. That's in the (OBR-based) rules.)

Posted

Scott

It is easy to see which umpires are working and which are not.

This may be another baseball vs softball thing

And even then a fast pitch vs slow pitch thing

First basemen in baseball come off the bag way fast not wanting to get spiked.

Spikes are Illegal in slow pitch.

And we have the safety bag at first

If I am in the A or B slot and I have a good look at the play at first and the coach asks for the appeal

I say coach I had a pretty good look and I thought the foot was good.

If he still insists then give up the appeal.

C slot pulled foot appeal at first Coach you got it every time.

Some of these Umpires should come down to Florida and see if Don Stratton will hire them for ISA softball.

But make sure you tell Don that you have only given up 3 appeals in 25 years

They can then go see Disney and have a quick trip home....

I don't know who Don Stratton is and don't care. I don't need games from him or any other softball assigner.

Keep your goofy softball mechanics to yourself and keep working your softball games. I am tired of hearing about softball garbage on this board, from you and from Scott. If you are working baseball and don't want to look like a Smitty (Softball umpire), then quit cleaning bases and asking for help EVERY time a coach throws a hissy fit.

Furthermore "Sam", I don't need to keep anyone happy to keep their money coming in for tournaments. That is the most asinine thing I have ever heard.

Warren, this "Ask the Umpire" thing has turned into a circus side show.

Posted

And don't try to integrate softball stuff into baseball. Completely different game. You don't expect soccer guys to throw flags instead of flash cards. Apples and oranges.

I agree that they are two different sports, but it's more like tangerines and oranges not apples and oranges. There are far more people that umpire both softball and baseball than soccer and baseball. So I do think that it is only natural that with softball's increase in popularity that some of the mechanics would merge a little. Just like JaxRolo unabashedly refuses to bring a brush on the field when he umpires softball, if my UIC's have no problem with it then I should really not be chastised for cleaning the bases in baseball. And while I do understand that cleaning the bases is not part of the culture of baseball umpiring, I don't think it can be argued that it would be better if it were. There may not be a great reason for keeping the bases clean, but there is no great reason for not cleaning them.

As for the pulled foot appeal, a bunch of baseball coaches must coach or watch a bunch of softball. Because my experience is that they certainly expect that I go to the PU for an appeal on the pulled foot. If that appeal was honored as infrequently as I'm being lead to believe on this board then I would assume that the coaches would not ask for it as frequently. But then again coaches don't always act in a way that logic would dictate. :D

I worked about 20 high school games and probably 40 or so college games this spring and I don't think I had ONE request to get help from the PU on a pulled foot/swipe tag at first, whether it was from the middle or on the line.

Posted

umpire-scott, as you move from level to level the coaches, for the most part, don't worry about "ticky-tack" calls.They know that,usually, if you couldn't umpire at that level you wouldn't be there. It sounds like from your posts you think too much. A baseball game has a different flow than a softball game. Two different mindsets. The game can call itself if you don't go looking for SH*#. Hence the name "Plumber". Your job on the baseball field is to maintain the integrity of baseball and not to make sure coaches, fans, players, etc. like you.Some guys umpire because they love baseball. I started out like that. Somewhere along the line I realized love to umpire instead. Decide which you LOVE and focus on that. As mstaylor has said " 80% of the game is played with 20% of the rules".

Posted

And don't try to integrate softball stuff into baseball. Completely different game. You don't expect soccer guys to throw flags instead of flash cards. Apples and oranges.

I agree that they are two different sports, but it's more like tangerines and oranges not apples and oranges. There are far more people that umpire both softball and baseball than soccer and baseball. So I do think that it is only natural that with softball's increase in popularity that some of the mechanics would merge a little. Just like JaxRolo unabashedly refuses to bring a brush on the field when he umpires softball, if my UIC's have no problem with it then I should really not be chastised for cleaning the bases in baseball. And while I do understand that cleaning the bases is not part of the culture of baseball umpiring, I don't think it can be argued that it would be better if it were. There may not be a great reason for keeping the bases clean, but there is no great reason for not cleaning them.

As for the pulled foot appeal, a bunch of baseball coaches must coach or watch a bunch of softball. Because my experience is that they certainly expect that I go to the PU for an appeal on the pulled foot. If that appeal was honored as infrequently as I'm being lead to believe on this board then I would assume that the coaches would not ask for it as frequently. But then again coaches don't always act in a way that logic would dictate. :D

I worked about 20 high school games and probably 40 or so college games this spring and I don't think I had ONE request to get help from the PU on a pulled foot/swipe tag at first, whether it was from the middle or on the line.

Well clearly the level of play is going to dictate that. High school and college players are far less likely to throw poorly and cause the pulled foot. High school and college first baseman are far more adept at securing the base and knowing how to stretch for a throw. Most of the umpiring I'm doing right now is 16U and under tournaments. It happens much more frequently at that level. It's also worth noting that the UIC's at these tournaments do want the paying managers to be satisfied with the umpires. So they are more likely to support us going for help if asked.

I do think that a lot of these "disagreements" we've had may have a lot to do with the level of play we are umpiring. At this point in my life I have no desire to umpire anything higher than high school ball. Both my UIC's responded to my question about cleaning the bases the exact same way. They both said it's not that common, but they have worked with umpires that did it. They said that if I wanted to that was fine. For the level that I'm doing, a clean base takes precedence over not being a laughingstock. And I know that I would not be a laughingstock anyway.

I worked today with an umpire that has been umpiring high school ball in Illinois or 8 years. He was chosen to do regional playoff games based on his performance. He is a pretty respected umpire around this area. He kick cleaned a base a few times today, and I asked him about the accepted IHSA mechanic in baseball for OBS, and he said they hold out their fist with no verbal signal. For what it's worth he also said I was one of the better umpires he had worked with and said my zone was exceptional.

My point in all this is that Michael is correct when he says 80% of the games are played with 20% of the rules. Within those parameters and at the level I umpire, I'm a very good umpire. I have good judgment, I sell my calls, I have a very consistent good strike zone, and I hustle. Would I be able to umpire college ball? Absolutely not. I'm in no way confident enough to do that. But for the level I do umpire I'm very confident and better than most of the guys out there when all things are taken into consideration.

Posted

This has gotten ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS. Do what you do. Who gives a f**k. Jeez... I called 6 plates and 1 base today. 16u and 18u. Not once did anyone ask for an appeal. That's 49 innings. TODAY.

Posted

I work all levels starting at 9/10s. I will do what I do at any level I work. If I think I need to check with my partner I will, but for the most part, no. What I will absolutely not do for any reason is ask just to make a coach happy. If he thinks the ball hit the batter in the box and my partner didn't kill it, then I will say no. By not killing it he has already told me he doesn't have it. If I have a fair/foul on the LF line and my partner is in A, I am not asking, he is watching first. If he is going to third to cover a first to third, I am not asking on a pulled foot. If my partner has been trained by me or a similar experienced person, I know what he is looking at and when and whether there is a chance he might have help. Coaches call ask all they want, I will not ask unless I believe he has a chance to give me something.

Posted

Scott

That is by the book in NSA ISA ASA ISF AND NCAA Softball

I sent the whole thread to the Head Umpire For Big 12 Division 1 Softball

He read about not cleaning bases and Not giving up Appeals.

He said he now knows who he will not be hiring.

It would be a cold day in you-know-where before I would want to work the Big 12 (or any other level) in *softball*. I'm a *baseball* umpire.

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't clean a base very often. When I do I always leave some dirt on it. The reason is if I can't tell if he touched the base, as he goes by, if I see dirt move on the base he touched the base. Especially 1st base.

Did you hear this from Jim Evans? I did. And he's right. A pristinely clean base offers up no such clues.

Posted

No. Read it somewhere and the light turned on! :nod:

Posted

I was managing at the sports complex today. I was taking care of the soccer/baseball end and another guy was taking care of the SP softball end. I was talking to him about this thread, he is a softball trainer in our area. Basically I asked which he would pay more attention to, the runner scoring or the foot pull at first? He said absolutely the foot at first. So it is obvious that philosophical difference between softball and baseball is huge. All the more reason to not mix them.

×
×
  • Create New...