I have both of the shinguards that you are inquiring about. I also have the platinum guards that catsbacker mentioned. I am a single knee shinguard guy so I rarely if ever wear the WV Pro Black guards. Matter of fact, they are currently on loan to a beginning umpire. As far as protection, you absolutely cannot beat the Pro Black or the Platinum guards. If the ball hits the guard, you won't even feel a thud. You will hear something, but you won't feel a thing. The one thing you will do is sweat....alot!!! The unequals are considerably lighter. They wrap around the leg and quite honestly you almost forget you have them on. Protection is solid as well. I have only had them for this season so I have only been hit once. To be fair, the hit that I took would have been stopped by any shin guard. I will wear the UE for 99% of the time. They are just extremely comfortable. I do have a game tomorrow with a D1 signee on the mound and an inferior catcher in which I will probably wear the platinum guards. With this catcher, I would prefer to stand behind a fence but I understand that is frowned upon. So long story short, for the ultimate in protection, the Wilsons. For the ultimate in comfort and 99% in protection, the Unequal. If I could only have 1, the Unequals. Hope this helps Major.