Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 513 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Finding it very impressive for F6 to stick with the throw, and BU to adjust to the speed and direction change...and make the right call despite not having the benefit of hearing the ball hit the glove.

In most amateur settings you are lucky to see either one execute this, let alone both.   The natural reaction is to "give up" once the ball hits the runner.  Kudos to both.

Tigers record out on fortunate ricochet off runner | 04/15/2025 | MLB.com

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted
On 4/16/2025 at 2:58 PM, beerguy55 said:

and BU to adjust to the speed and direction change...and make the right call despite not having the benefit of hearing the ball hit the glove.

It is impressive, and what I’m about to say in no way diminishes that… 

A play and call like this is a part-&-parcel of Video Review being integrated into The Game. The Umpire here can, even if/when achieving the best possible position, call “according to the perceived elements” plus “gut/intuition”, with the knowledge (confidence) that Video Review can confirm it or rectify it. 
Call something, and sort out the bodies (promptly) after. 

The NFL, NHL, and NBA have all adopted similar systems and doctrine. Famously, the NFL officials “let (certain) plays go”, now, such as potential change of possessions, or  boundary touches, or catch/no-catch where the critical event happens so fast, or so obscured to the human eye (in real time), only video review can properly clarify them. 

JV25 and AF49 both had similar plays at their bases wherein the Runner needed to be tagged in a slide attempt at said base. In JV25’s play, Ely De La Cruz stole 3B, and I bet dollars to donuts that 95% of amateur umpires call that as an Out; the ball arrived first, the tag was made, ball secured during the tag, everything. Maybe a higher percentage of Pro and pro umpires make the call of Safe (which JV25 made), partly due to proximity (afforded by being a U3 in D) or true read (actually saw the critical element) – De La Cruz’s right fingers touching the base a split-second before the glove covers them and tags, actually making contact, on the hand itself. Only two vantage points could see it: 1) a/the camera on 3BLX (1B side) looking right down the line, and 2) wherever JV25 was standing. 

Call (Safe) reviewed and confirmed. 

Meanwhile, AF49 made a Safe call at 2B, from C-beyond (outfield side of 2B-3B baseline), which got overturned on review. Granted, here again, it took having to look at it from 2 (at least) other angles to notice that the fielder, while catching the thrown ball, had managed to graze the glove against the rump of the headfirst-sliding Runner… while the ball was in it. AF49 called “what he saw”. I think it’s much more intriguing to note – AF49, as the Crew Chief, had to (report the) overturn of his own call. 
Why is this significant, or noteworthy? Because there’s a generation of umpires who (still) maintain this “that’s my call!”, “my judgement”, “my my my”, “mine mine mine” – super-uber-possessive, and they don’t accept (well, or if ever) that there might be video review, or the perspective of a partner umpire. As it is, today’s professional player (and you’re seeing this more and more in college, too) is more… tolerant(?)… forgiving(?)… of umpires who consider (all it takes is to consider) that they could be wrong (in their call), and don’t get all possessive, defiant, and vindictive about it. Video review will, antiseptically, confirm it or overturn it. Done. 

Notice what’s largely gone from the professional game because of it? The “that’s on you, Blue!”, the helmet slamming, dirt-kicking tirades. 

Edit: It just struck me… some might be wondering . o O ( How in the hell does Max have time to watch all those plays?? Shouldn’t he be working? ) Good question. I (now) watch MLB.tv condensed games every night, to not only see how my beloved Brewers do, but to watch all those big plays – and appreciate and analyze how the Pro-Us call them. 

  • Like 2
  • 2 months later...
Posted
On 4/20/2025 at 9:43 AM, MadMax said:

It is impressive, and what I’m about to say in no way diminishes that… 

A play and call like this is a part-&-parcel of Video Review being integrated into The Game. The Umpire here can, even if/when achieving the best possible position, call “according to the perceived elements” plus “gut/intuition”, with the knowledge (confidence) that Video Review can confirm it or rectify it. 
Call something, and sort out the bodies (promptly) after. 

The NFL, NHL, and NBA have all adopted similar systems and doctrine. Famously, the NFL officials “let (certain) plays go”, now, such as potential change of possessions, or  boundary touches, or catch/no-catch where the critical event happens so fast, or so obscured to the human eye (in real time), only video review can properly clarify them. 

JV25 and AF49 both had similar plays at their bases wherein the Runner needed to be tagged in a slide attempt at said base. In JV25’s play, Ely De La Cruz stole 3B, and I bet dollars to donuts that 95% of amateur umpires call that as an Out; the ball arrived first, the tag was made, ball secured during the tag, everything. Maybe a higher percentage of Pro and pro umpires make the call of Safe (which JV25 made), partly due to proximity (afforded by being a U3 in D) or true read (actually saw the critical element) – De La Cruz’s right fingers touching the base a split-second before the glove covers them and tags, actually making contact, on the hand itself. Only two vantage points could see it: 1) a/the camera on 3BLX (1B side) looking right down the line, and 2) wherever JV25 was standing. 

Call (Safe) reviewed and confirmed. 

Meanwhile, AF49 made a Safe call at 2B, from C-beyond (outfield side of 2B-3B baseline), which got overturned on review. Granted, here again, it took having to look at it from 2 (at least) other angles to notice that the fielder, while catching the thrown ball, had managed to graze the glove against the rump of the headfirst-sliding Runner… while the ball was in it. AF49 called “what he saw”. I think it’s much more intriguing to note – AF49, as the Crew Chief, had to (report the) overturn of his own call. 
Why is this significant, or noteworthy? Because there’s a generation of umpires who (still) maintain this “that’s my call!”, “my judgement”, “my my my”, “mine mine mine” – super-uber-possessive, and they don’t accept (well, or if ever) that there might be video review, or the perspective of a partner umpire. As it is, today’s professional player (and you’re seeing this more and more in college, too) is more… tolerant(?)… forgiving(?)… of umpires who consider (all it takes is to consider) that they could be wrong (in their call), and don’t get all possessive, defiant, and vindictive about it. Video review will, antiseptically, confirm it or overturn it. Done. 

Notice what’s largely gone from the professional game because of it? The “that’s on you, Blue!”, the helmet slamming, dirt-kicking tirades. 

Edit: It just struck me… some might be wondering . o O ( How in the hell does Max have time to watch all those plays?? Shouldn’t he be working? ) Good question. I (now) watch MLB.tv condensed games every night, to not only see how my beloved Brewers do, but to watch all those big plays – and appreciate and analyze how the Pro-Us call them. 

now max, with your work and 4 hour games at the same time, there is no time left to do anything but eat and sleep, unless you are one of the few who dont need it, or you just tell everyone you are blind in one eye and cannot see out the other and if they yell at you it will make you cry and go home, so they never bother you on any of your calls. best to use your hanky and tearing up a little bit and wipe your eyes and blow your nose when making this statement

×
×
  • Create New...