Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 6421 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I bounced this one off some folks on the other site and never got a reply.

OBR - Am.Legion 16 - 19 yr olds

Here in wonderful wyoming, i have a couple of RH pitchers, who will, during their stretch with R1, keep the ball in their rh and place it on their left shin as they lean in to take signs. Is this:

(A)Nothing,

(B)Don't do that, keep your hand at side or behind back (as per regs.)

© Balk - [intentional deception??]

(D) relates to A - the crappy end of the stick - don't go there

thanks ty

  • Replies 6
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

TY,

This sounds like the gorilla stance. With the ball in his right hand hanging in front is nothing in OBR. When watching MLB you will see several do this.

Allan

Posted (edited)

i do understand what you are stating as far as the gorilla arm, my consternation comes from the obvious intent to hide the ball by the left shin. I mean the arm is not hanging, the ball is literally placed against the left shinbone. Of course if the ball were in the glove, leaning on the left knee......

thanks ty

Edited by Tyennie
added content.
Posted

i do understand what you are stating as far as the gorilla arm, my consternation comes from the obvious intent to hide the ball by the left shin. I mean the arm is not hanging, the ball is literally placed against the left shinbone. Of course if the ball were in the glove, leaning on the left knee......

thanks ty

It's still nothing (in OBR). The rule is designed so R1 (assuming RH F1) can tell whether F1 is set or not. It's meant to stop F1 from standing (relatievley) upright, with both hands in front of his torso (but not joined) and then joining them with a slight move that can't be seen by R1. So, R1 can't take his "secondary" lead.

In your play, it's obvious that F1 hasn't come set, no matter whether the hand is dangling, or holding the ball against the knee. It's nothing.

Posted

It's still nothing (in OBR). The rule is designed so R1 (assuming RH F1) can tell whether F1 is set or not. It's meant to stop F1 from standing (relatievley) upright, with both hands in front of his torso (but not joined) and then joining them with a slight move that can't be seen by R1. So, R1 can't take his "secondary" lead.

In your play, it's obvious that F1 hasn't come set, no matter whether the hand is dangling, or holding the ball against the knee. It's nothing.

Great explanation!

Another example where if you follow the letter of the rule you'd technically be correct, but following the intent of the rule should govern.

Posted

Hence the reason for my last sentence concerning the ball in the glove on the knee........ Posted in a tone of "oh yeah this makes sense now, 'cause the other thing happens all the time" thanks for the comments. Some day it will freakin' warm up here in wyoming and we can actually go outside and play baseball. :yippie:


×
×
  • Create New...