Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4548 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

Guest dpf29
Posted

Majors Softball....

 

I know a girl is allowed to go directly to second on a walk...with risk of being thrown out....if the pitcher has the ball in the circle as long as she does not hesitate at or while rounding first base.  

 

What is the call, if any, if she does hesitate while rounding first base? 

 

 

 

Situation.....Runner on 3rd.  One out.  Batter earns a walk.  Starts off to first base.  Ball is returned to the pitcher who is now on the rubber, well within the circle.  R1 reaches first and starts toward second.  After a few steps she hesitates and tries to get attention of pitcher.  She steps back toward first and then goes off to second.

  • Answers 16
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters For This Question

Top Posters For This Question

16 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted

In FP SB the girl has the right to make a momentary stop at which point she must either return to 1B or continue to 2B without further hesitation. However, if F1 makes any play on the runner or even makes a motion as if she were to make a play, the LBR is no longer in effect.

  • 0
Posted

In FP SB the girl has the right to make a momentary stop at which point she must either return to 1B or continue to 2B without further hesitation. However, if F1 makes any play on the runner or even makes a motion as if she were to make a play, the LBR is no longer in effect.

"tries to get attention of pitcher."

 

What do you think that means?

  • 0
Guest Guest
Posted

by "tries to get attention of pitcher"....I mean she started stepping to and fro first and second....

  • 0
Posted

Here's the thing. If the runner "gets the attention of the pitcher", I would assume that means the pitcher is now making some sort of play which nullifies the LBR. The only way to get an out there is for the girl to pause between bases with F1 ignoring such act and in the umpires judgment, the pause was longer than allowed. Of course if she also started bouncing between the bases and was still not having a play made on her, that too would be an out.

  • 0
Posted

Goes directly to second.

I am no softball guy, but I think she is out on appeal only for missing first. :sarcasm:

  • 0
Posted

by "tries to get attention of pitcher"....I mean she started stepping to and fro first and second....

GUEST- this one of the bigest No-Nos in softball.

It is Softball 101 type of question.

  • 0
Posted

Soapbox you over complicating this.

The OP gave NO indication of the pitcher doing anything like making a play on the runner.

 

You also stated in your post # 7 "Of course if she also started bouncing between the bases and was still not having a play made on her, that too would be an out."  Guest post # 6 stated "I mean she started stepping to and fro first and second...."

 

 

This is softball 101.

 

Time is called and the runner is OUT.

  • 0
Posted

Here's the thing. If the runner "gets the attention of the pitcher", I would assume that means the pitcher is now making some sort of play which nullifies the LBR. The only way to get an out there is for the girl to pause between bases with F1 ignoring such act and in the umpires judgment, the pause was longer than allowed. Of course if she also started bouncing between the bases and was still not having a play made on her, that too would be an out.

OP stated " After a few steps she hesitates and tries to get attention of pitcher".

Obviously the pitcher was ignoring her.

  • 0
Posted

My bad. I only read Softball 100. Been meaning to get the new 101 version. I bow to your superiority. I now remember why I mostly read and never post. The joke is, we are really saying the same thing, but in the future will not participate, but only read. I look forward to always continuing to learn from you.

  • 0
Posted

My bad. I only read Softball 100. Been meaning to get the new 101 version. I bow to your superiority. I now remember why I mostly read and never post. The joke is, we are really saying the same thing, but in the future will not participate, but only read. I look forward to always continuing to learn from you.

Our guests deserve good answers AND I am in a snarky mood today.

I ripped umpirescott a new one earlier.

After the morphine wears off I get cranky.

No malace intended.

  • 0
Posted

Majors Softball....

 

I know a girl is allowed to go directly to second on a walk...with risk of being thrown out....if the pitcher has the ball in the circle as long as she does not hesitate at or while rounding first base.  

 

What is the call, if any, if she does hesitate while rounding first base? 

 

 

 

Situation.....Runner on 3rd.  One out.  Batter earns a walk.  Starts off to first base.  Ball is returned to the pitcher who is now on the rubber, well within the circle.  R1 reaches first and starts toward second.  After a few steps she hesitates and tries to get attention of pitcher.  She steps back toward first and then goes off to second.

R1 was fine going to second but as soon as she stopped and headed back towards first, then that is a textbook circle violation.  At that point, time should be called, a circle violation declared, and the runner out.  All other runners should go back to their bases.  Another thing to consider - what was the runner on 3rd doing when the BR touched 1st?  Do you recall?

  • 0
Posted

 

R1 was fine going to second but as soon as she stopped and headed back towards first, then that is a textbook circle violation.

 

 

Nope.

 

When the Look Back Rule (LBR) is in effect, the runner may stop ONCE in between bases. The runner then must immediately either advance directly to the next base or retreat directly to the previous one, without stopping or reversing direction a second time.

 

The runner in question *might* have violated the LBR when she "tried to get the pitcher's attention", if doing so caused her to remain stationary in one spot, failing to immediately advance or retreat. I don't know. That part is judgment and I'd have to see it. But she is allowed to make one momentary stop.

 

The runner was *probably* out when, after pausing, she "stepped back toward first, then went toward second". This is a second reversal of direction and that does violate the LBR.

 

If, at any point during this sequence, the pitcher attempted or even faked a play, all bets are off. That suspends the LBR and the runner is free to stop/go/reverse/dance around all she wants to.

  • 0
Posted

It depends on the rule set in which they are playing.  Chances are for the OP situation, BretMan is correct.  ASA and Fed rules allow for a stop and immediate move.  Under ASA (Rule 8-7T) and Fed (Rule 8-7. 1-4), the runner was out when they stepped back toward first and then went towards second.  This is of course under the assumption that LL rules are similarly written as ASA and Fed.  What I posted is under NCAA rules (12.21.1, 12.21.6.5) which reads that:

 

"the ball must be live, BR touched first base, F1 has possession in the circle.  If the ball goes back to the pitcher in the circle, the runner must go immediately back to the base she came from or to the next base (she cannot stop).  If she was already stopped, the runner must immediately go forward or back..."

 

But as I said before, considering the level of play and without having a LL rulebook in front of me, BretMan is probably correct. Just don't do what I just did and get your rules differences mixed up!   


×
×
  • Create New...