Batter Runner BB called out at 1B for over running bag

[MAC]

Batter Runner awarded 1b on BB, touches 1b over runs awarded base. catcher throws down to 1b, 1b man tags him while on the outfield side of base where umpire calls BR OUT. Any thoughts?

[basejester]

Rules thread

[Jocko]

Absolutely correct in Fed

Absolutely incorrect in OBR

[BretMan]

It's like deja vu all over again!

Besides the recent lengthy rule thread covering this very subject, I'll add one question: Did the umpire by any chance judge that the runner made an attempt toward second base after overrunning first?

[JaxRolo]

Please lock this thread!!!!

[Jocko]

Speaking of gaseous formations, what is the difference in the composition of a cone nebula and a horse nebula. Will the form vary in relation to galactic positioning and gravitational anomolies?

[JaxRolo]

Speaking of gaseous formations, what is the difference in the composition of a cone nebula and a horse nebula. Will the form vary in relation to galactic positioning and gravitational anomolies?

Yes?

[Guest umpire78]

Speaking of gaseous formations, what is the difference in the composition of a cone nebula and a horse nebula. Will the form vary in relation to galactic positioning and gravitational anomolies?

Now, if the cone and horse nebulas collide, then there would be a rip in the space-time continuum.

Hey, YOU started it.  

[scrounge]

Speaking of gaseous formations, what is the difference in the composition of a cone nebula and a horse nebula. Will the form vary in relation to galactic positioning and gravitational anomolies?