Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 5033 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Recommended Posts

Posted

After completing "As They See 'Em" recently, I moved on to this book.

It's written by John Massaro, an amateur umpire who called for 24+ years in New York, everything from LL to HS, up to Stan Musial (adult league).

He starts w/ his youth playing ball and gives the background/impetus for what got him, and many like us into umpiring. The entire book is filled w/ antecdotes and war-stories, similar to what you'd see in other books, just all the material is from the amateur level, so most, if not all of us can relate.

He gives a pretty good insight into what makes umpires, as well as ball-players, tick and some of the stories, especially from the Stan Musial games are hilarious. He touches on the human natures and tendencies that make rat coaches and fans do what they do sometimes.

A warning now that some may be offended at a couple of different parts in the book. The author pulls no punches and shoots from the hip when he takes on a few subjects, such as women in umpiring/baseball and minority ball-players. Like it or not, he has no problem stating his opinions, but at least provides his rationale for his thoughts, and not just emotional rantings.

Along those lines, he seems pretty straight-forward w/ everything, including his own limitations. Though he admits he is laid back, etc, there were times in the book I found myself shaking my head at his inaction when there were times he clearly should've run someone...he chalks it up to maintaining calm, and I see his point in some of the situations, but still.

Only real beef I had with the book is the author often claims he is a good umpire and has no problem putting down other umpires for making bad calls/mistakes. Yet, he talks often of himself making, sometimes intentionally, those same calls!

To quote from pg. 183, "I just get mad when I see umpires make mistakes they shouldn't make."

Along those lines, he gives several examples of other umpires' blunders, sometimes questioning whether they should be on the field or not. And, several times in the book he calls himself a good umpire.

Yet on the other hand, as I mentioned, he freely gives several examples of himself intentionally making bad (terrible?) judgements/calls, sometimes to end a long game or keep another inning from starting.

I just had a little problem with it and found myself getting irritated at various times.

But, that's just my :WTF

So, for those who want a different perspective & stories from the MLB level, especially that the majority of us can readily relate to, then this is a good and entertaining read of which I'd recommend. It's not long--283 pages, chapters aren't too long and it flows pretty well.

He accurately captures what it's like to be an umpire at all levels of amateur ball, from the last-minute calls for a game, to rat coaches, to dealing w/ amateur players (of all levels), to fans, to burning out, etc. He even has a chapter where he fantasizes about some of the things he'd like to do on the field to teach rat coaches/fans a lesson...real funny stuff!

For those from Long Island, this book will hit home for you, but for the amateur umpire in general, you will easily find yourself in many of the same situations he describes in the book and can share in all the good/bad/funny/ugly of which he writes.

  • Replies 6
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • 4 months later...
Posted

I just finished this book and it's a pretty good read. I AM from LI so reading all the town names was fun. I do adult ball here in Portland but I wouldn't if I took the kind of abuse that he describes taking.

  • 6 months later...
Posted

Just finished Mr. Massaro's contribution to umpiring literature. Not a bad read. Not that impressive but well worth the quick read that it is. Like Widac and Big Red I can relate and I agree with both of their assessments and comments. No way I would put up with what he did. I, fortunately and unfortunately, am not laid back and I do not, would not, did not, will not allow some of those clown coaches and players to take over the game with their antics. Of course I have never umpired on Long Island but I would imagine Long Island troublemakers are similar to Kentucky, Tennessee, Ohio, Indiana, West Virginia, South Carolina, North Carolina, Virginia, Missouri and Kansas troublemakers but what would I know?

Anyway, it is worth the read. Other than the small portion of "As They See 'Em" dedicated to Bruce Weber's amateur umpiring efforts, I don't think any of the other dozen plus books on umpiring I have recently read have been by or about amateur umpiring. So it is worth if for us Non-Professionals just for the "common man's" perspective.

My two cents.........

  • 1 year later...
Posted

Throw a travel bug thing-a-ma-bob on it and send it out! I'll get it started.

Posted

Throw a travel bug thing-a-ma-bob on it and send it out! I'll get it started.

 

Sure! Good idea! I don't know how to make that fancy map tracking thing Warren had, but I could start a log on the inside cover when finished and send it to you. Just PM your address. I probably won't have it longer than a week, maybe two if I get busy.

 

I'll let the friend know, I'm sure he'll call me an ump nerd (aren't we all), but be happy it's getting put to an awesome use like this!


×
×
  • Create New...