Jump to content
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4148 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Question

Posted

1 runner picked off third with throw and tag on dugout side. base ump asks home plate ump by pointing at him and is just about to say did he tag him. before he can say that, home plate ump very alert to play comes up with he s out. we got it right, we did the right thing but home plate ump should have waited for  "did he tag him"  and let base ump call him out.  2 same ball game, we play with 20 foot panel gone in left centerfield. we discuss at groundrules if ball rolls thru it will be a double after a raise of outfielders hands and verification. we did not discuss what happens if outfielder catches fly ball in field of play and momentum carries him thru hole in fence.  what do we have?  3 runner on third comes home on groundball to ss. throw goes to first pulls firstbaseman off bag. he makes tag attempt and holds onto ball as batter runner hacks down on his arm holding ball. ball does not dislodge and runner is called out. is that interference, if it is should it be called and if it s called what do we do with runner who scored from third.  4  pitched ball hits knob of bat and goes directly to mound on ground. umpire calls foul ball or ball immediately but does realize his mistake.  what can we do   what do we have  if we do anything what do we do with runner who was on second and reached third or was thrown out at third.  should assignor fire the umpire?  what do we do  Sent from my LG-D415 using Tapatalk

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Posted

You haven't posted anything that supports it, and you're wrong.

Then you can't read, or you're not playing under OBR.

(That goes to you specifically, not others in this discussion)

  • 0
Posted

Then you can't read, or you're not playing under OBR.

(That goes to you specifically, not others in this discussion)

You haven't posted SH*# about throws. Stop being insulting and obstinate.

  • 0
Posted

You haven't posted SH*# about throws. Stop being insulting and obstinate.

If you say so. (For the last time PBUC 6.5:5 and 9.1:1 *cough*)

But you know, what a surprise you disagree with me. Bye :wave:

  • 0
Posted

If you say so. (For the last time PBUC 6.5:5 and 9.1:1 *cough*)

But you know, what a surprise you disagree with me. Bye :wave: 

 You haven't posted 6.5:5, and 9.1:1 doesn't cover throws. So, instead of being nebulous, post something that says throws can't be made from DBT.

  • 0
Posted

 You haven't posted 6.5:5, and 9.1:1 doesn't cover throws. So, instead of being nebulous, post something that says throws can't be made from DBT.

Screen Shot 2015-07-05 at 4.43.46 PM.png

What the hell are you talking about at this point. Maven already scanned it. 6.5:5 contains the exact same language as 9.1:1. It also defines catch and carry as per 6.5:  "..dugout, bench, grandstand, or any out-of-play area...". Or maybe you read out-of-play as not dead ball... How about spending less time looking in a thesaurus and more in the material mentioned.

  • 0
Posted (edited)

Let me break this down for you. A fielder can catch the ball in the field of play and go into any DBT (besides spectator areas) and the ball will remain live until one of three things happens: the fielder falls, the ball is dropped, or a throw hits something in DBT. There is nothing prohibiting a throw from those areas.

There have been at least three people explaining this to you.  

Edited by Matt
Umpire-Empire locks topics which have not been active in the last year. The thread you are viewing hasn't been active in 4148 days so you will not be able to post. We do recommend you starting a new topic to find out what's new in the world of umpiring.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...