Are you me back in 2015? I remembered this and found it in my archives (also a recreational men's league):
Oscar the catcher was routinely placing his glove as a target right over the plate. This caused a Catcher's Interference. Oscar questioned my call, saying the batter was too far back. He drew a line with the bat from the back point of the plate to the side, declaring that was the box. I told him he was wrong, pointed at the batter's footprint, and said the batter had been in the official box according to the Rules of Baseball.
A few batters later, another Catcher's Interference occurred. Oscar jumped up and aggressively started questioning my call. He took the bat again, and began drawing lines in the sand. I told him to "stop drawing lines immediately", and he responded by drawing two more. I ejected him.
Oscar asked me why I ejected him, and I told him that "not listening to an umpire is never a good thing."