Appeal play?

[Gfoley4]

R2 R3 1 out and a line drive is caught by F7. The throw to second to double off R2 gets away and eventually we get a play at the plate on R3, but he never tagged up. R3 beats the throw but is tagged. I am correct is saying this tag would most likely not be an unmistakable appeal?

[maven]

Yes: if it's a play at another base, it's certainly not an unmistakable appeal.

[Gfoley4]

1 minute ago, maven said:

Yes: if it's a play at another base, it's certainly not an unmistakable appeal.

That's what I was thinking. I was BU and the PU immediately came up with an out and said he didn't tag up. They then threw to third base anyway so R3 was going to be out either way. I talked to him between innings and told him about the "unmistakable appeal" rule and gave the example of calling safe when the B/R passes first base but misses it.