Does run score

[Guest]

One out, runners on the corners. Ball hit to outfield, runner on third tagging up, runner on first goes. Ball is caught, runner on third scores, runner who was on first never goes back and is doubled off. Umpires ruled that since runner scored before third out was made, run counts. Is that right call?  This is also in men's softball league. 

[Cav]

Yes.  This is also in men's baseball. 

[Man_In_Black]

Yes, the call is correct. The appeal play at first base on R1 is a time play in both baseball and softball.

[FleasOf1000Camels]

YES, the run is good...baseball, softball, wiffleball, kick-dodge.

Lots of folks get confused on this because they don't grasp the difference between a FORCE out and an APPEAL out.

[Cav]

12 minutes ago, FleasOf1000Camels said:

YES, the run is good...baseball, softball, wiffleball, kick-dodge.

But only MAYBE in Calvinball.

[Kevin_K]

9 hours ago, Cav said:

But only MAYBE in Calvinball.

Careful Cav....... it depends on the rule set being used, referenced, implied, or considered.