Been doing LL for a few years now. Watching several of my son's middle school (60/90) games, I was confused when an overthrow from an infielder went out of play and R1 was awarded home. He was already around 2B when the throw was made. I thought it was clear cut that it's 2 bases from TOP on that, but was told by some friends who do big diamond ball, that at this level, it's umpire's judgement.
Does this mean runners are awarded bases based upon where the ump thought they could have made it to had the ball not gone out of play?
Thanks in advance!